• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

people said the same thing about the Kessel trade. there's no "wrong" time to add an elite player in his 20s.

Different scenerio with Kessel- We didnt give up any roster players or prospects, just draft picks. IF we trade with Anahiem for Getlzlaf it will take roster players, prospects and draft picks going the other way.
 
Actually it does, if he resigns with Anahiem or hes traded to another team and he resigns with them, it shows he doesnt want to sign here.

It shows he wanted to sign there. doesn't say anything about his willingness to sign with the Leafs given the opportunity.
 
Different scenerio with Kessel- We didnt give up any roster players or prospects, just draft picks. IF we trade with Anahiem for Getlzlaf it will take roster players, prospects and draft picks going the other way.

You did nothing to discount the point he made. You don't turn down the opportunity to get elite players in their 20s.
 
I'm sorry, but that's not how logic works.

I'll dumb this down for you- If Anahiem offers Getlzaf a contract he has a choice to either accept it and agree to the terms OR he declines it, he has a choice in the matter there. If he agrees to sign with Anahiem (as an example) then it shows he wants to be with the ducks, if he didnt then he wont sign the contract, simple no? Lets say the ducks trade him to the Rangers (just an example) and he signs a long term contract there then it shows he wants to be with the Rangers. Am I getting through to you here?
 
I'll dumb this down for you- If Anahiem offers Getlzaf a contract he has a choice to either accept it and agree to the terms OR he declines it, he has a choice in the matter there. If he agrees to sign with Anahiem (as an example) then it shows he wants to be with the ducks, if he didnt then he wont sign the contract, simple no? Lets say the ducks trade him to the Rangers (just an example) and he signs a long term contract there then it shows he wants to be with the Rangers. Am I getting through to you here?

So if I go on a vacation to Turkey, it means I didn't want to go on vacation to New Zealand?
 
I'll dumb this down for you- If Anahiem offers Getlzaf a contract he has a choice to either accept it and agree to the terms OR he declines it, he has a choice in the matter there. If he agrees to sign with Anahiem (as an example) then it shows he wants to be with the ducks, if he didnt then he wont sign the contract, simple no? Lets say the ducks trade him to the Rangers (just an example) and he signs a long term contract there then it shows he wants to be with the Rangers. Am I getting through to you here?

But you can't infer from any of that that he wouldn't have signed with the Leafs if given the option.
 
I'll dumb this down for you- If Anahiem offers Getlzaf a contract he has a choice to either accept it and agree to the terms OR he declines it, he has a choice in the matter there. If he agrees to sign with Anahiem (as an example) then it shows he wants to be with the ducks, if he didnt then he wont sign the contract, simple no? Lets say the ducks trade him to the Rangers (just an example) and he signs a long term contract there then it shows he wants to be with the Rangers. Am I getting through to you here?

I've never heard someone use this phrase and it be true in THIS way.
 
But you can't infer from any of that that he wouldn't have signed with the Leafs if given the option.

See thats the thing he would have an oppurtunity, he would decline any contract extension with Anahiem (or whichever team he is traded to) and would let Burke know that he wants to be a leaf.
 
See thats the thing he would have an oppurtunity, he would decline any contract extension with Anahiem (or whichever team he is traded to) and would let Burke know that he wants to be a leaf.

Thats pretty extreme. The only way a player would like to play for a team if given the chance is if he privately states that he will only play there?

Logic suggests that there are likely multiple teams Getzlaf would be willing to play for. Signing with any one team does not necessarily imply that he would not have signed anywhere else.
 
Thats pretty extreme. The only way a player would like to play for a team if given the chance is if he privately states that he will only play there?

No thats not what I said. What I am saying its high risk to trade a boat load of assets for a player with no guarantee of wanting to play here for the long term. My point is to wait it out until hes a UFA, and if he truly wants to be a leaf then sign the guy to a long term contract.
 
Lupul - Getzlaf - Kessel
Liles - Phaneuf

All would be Burke acquired players. That'd be just insane. One hell of a core.
 
No thats not what I said. What I am saying its high risk to trade a boat load of assets for a player with no guarantee of wanting to play here for the long term. My point is to wait it out until hes a UFA, and if he truly wants to be a leaf then sign the guy to a long term contract.

and the wheels on the bus go round and round...
 
Back
Top