• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I buy it. Clowe probably gives Burke raging wood. I'm actually terrified that he would drastically overpay to get him.
 
I am hoping if this is for real, Kulemin won't be the one going. They can take Mac or Lombardi instead. Kully and Clowe are both 6'2 and over 220 lbs. I think they would work well together and we're in need of a line that can dominate on the boards.
 
I think that we can definitively say, especially when it comes to trades, that Burke is the furthest thing possible from a complete idiot. So, with that information in mind, I think we can safely conclude that Burke will not trade Kulemin and Schenn for a 6'2" Newfie that will typically get you around 20 goals and 50 points per season. I can definitely see Burke being interested in him, but that is not what he will cost. Full stop.

As for Shane Doan, he'd be a good, physical veteran leader to pick up, but if you did trade for him, the price would have to reflect the fact that he's 35 years old and an unrestricted free agent at the end of the year. If Doan is willing to conclude that it's very likely that the Coyotes are moving out of Phoenix at the end of the year, and as a result would be willing to agree to a contract extension prior to a trade, then maybe the price goes up a bit.
 
I'd do Schenn and Lombo (even a pick if we have to). Our lines would be pretty good mix of size and speed.

Lupul-Connolly-Kessel
Kadri-Grabovski-Macarthur
Clowe-Bozak-Kulemin
Boyce-Steckel-Brown
 
If we got a full year of Liles for a pick, we'll pay less for 35 games of Doan for the rest of the season.

As for Kulemin for Clowe, fat chance. Kulemin >>>
 
We have NO goaltending. And the reason Schenn is part of these trade rumours is because HE has asked to be traded. Hates Wilson apparently.
 
If we got a full year of Liles for a pick, we'll pay less for 35 games of Doan for the rest of the season.

not a chance

they got liles for a song and i don't think anybody can really explain why he came so cheap. the starting point for doan negotiations would undoubtedly be higher, and only creep up higher in light of the fact that it would be a deadline deal.
 
Does Burke have Tim Thomas' clone hatching in an incubator funded by his Jesuit masters? Otherwise, why would he bother going for an over the hill member of the Phoenix Coyotes? We have NO goaltending, and until that is addressed we are pretty much a candidate to be a big time seller. Not a buyer.
 
You would think someone would love to get Grabo the way he is playing now. He could be awesome as a second line center now. Or even a third liner with an expiring contract. Burke HAS to play this chip properly.
 
Man, I can believe Burke is big on Clowe but if we pay Schenn + Kulemin for Clowe that's a HUGE overpayment ... I don't believe Burke is that dumb.

Clowe is turning 30 soon, so he's not exactly young. He has 1 more season before he turns UFA, but at least his cap hit is a very manageable $3.62M at the moment.

Clowe is a power forward, and is one of those guys that I would file under 'Over-rated' because of that. He is really a 20-25G, 55-60 points forward who plays with grit and physicality, but beyond scoring around the net his offensive creativity is limited. I don't consider him a big upgrade over Kulemin ... in fact, I consider Kulemin a better offensive player if you give him a few years, and almost as physical.

I don't know if I'd trade Kulemin for Clowe straight up, giving up almost 5 years of youth and what I consider a higher ceiling. There's no way I'd trade Kulemin AND Schenn for Clowe, which is a somewhat limited player IMO.
 
Height: 6-2 Weight: 225lbs
Age: 29


Ryane Clowe is a nice power-forward, who wouldn't want him? Having said that, for 22yearold Luke Schen, its a BIG cost and not worth the price. Bad move if Burke pulls this deal off not to mention if Kulemin is added to the package. What a complete RIP off!! If Clowe was a missing piece to a Stanley Cup then you pay the price but this version of the Leafs, the notion is laughable.
 
I think we all know that a Schenn/Kuly package is a ridiculous idea that will never happen for Ryan Clowe.
 
I like Clowe, but i would have to be a much bigger deal as they just don't have the picks/prospects to make up the difference.

Give us Thornton/Clowe for Kulemin/Schenn/center
 
Back
Top