• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

It is a CAP NHL. No way you give up Gardiner for Weber. No way. We have Phaneuf, who may not be as good as Weber, but it is what it is. Gardiner at his salary is BETTER than Weber, in a cap world. You trade Gardiner for a top six guy MAYBE, and that is only maybe.

And I like Weber. Seen him play a fair amount, nice hack and chop, five on five NHL dman. Gardiner is the future of hockey though. Sublime talent. Controls the game.
 
you would be crazy for gardiner to be a stumbling block to acquiring weber. the cap hit, too.

burke had $13 or $14mn tied up in neidermayer and pronger when he won. no reason the leafs couldn't accommodate phaneuf and weber.

and i don't even like weber that much. but... the leafs would have the best pair in the league. split them up in a playoff game and you could literally have phaneuf or weber on the ice for an entire game.
 
I do think Weber is pretty redundant with Phaneuf already here.

I'm hopeful Gardiner can turn into our Suter, too.
 
I do think Weber is pretty redundant with Phaneuf already here.

I'm hopeful Gardiner can turn into our Suter, too.

is he, though?

think about how good phaneuf has been this year.

and then imagine getting 50 minutes of that a game.

60 minutes in a playoff game.

really, that's a hell of a team to have to play against.

again, i don't even love weber -- i don't really think he's even that much better than phaneuf (not by much, anyways). but that is, immediately, the sort of team you don't want to play against in the playoffs.

maybe gardiner becomes their 'suter'. but with phaneuf-weber you wouldn't really need a suter, or at least somebody as good as suter. you just need a heady defenseman who can skate the puck, and move it up ice. and they got it for $3.8mn. good value for a #3 defenseman, even on a team spending $14mn on it's top two.
 
obviously, he'd be a huge addition, and make us a much better team.

But there's probably a number of better fits out there.
 
The question is whether any of those players are "out there"

Then again, in fairness...I don't think Weber is "out there" yet. Nashville would get as much for him in the summer, as they would now, and chasing that playoff dollar is a big deal for them.
 
These types of players typically resign, with the only exceptions being where the team is an absolute mess like Hossa and Kovalchuk with Atlanta. Its doubtful that any of these guys will actually be moved. But apparently Weber was pretty pissed off with Nashville after arbitration in the summer, and that relationship might not be repairable. Then again another good playoff run and maybe it is.

But I really don't see Staal or Getzlaf going anywhere, and we know Nashville is trying really, really hard to keep Suter and Weber.

But if any one of those guys becomes available to you, IMO it would be foolish to pass and hope for a "better fit" to be moved. If you have an opportunity to acquire one of the best players in the game you take it IMO. All 4 of those guys are among the top 5-10 players at their positions in the NHL.
 
Last edited:
Schenn, Kadri, and Aulie for Weber, as far as I'm concerned.

Even though that would eat away at our assets for a deal for a first line center, I think Weber is that good. I wouldn't pass it up.
 
If Nashville asked for Gardiner and the rights to his unborn children you do it.....jesus some of you people are bonkers.

I can also tell you thins, if and when Nashville moves him/suter a defenceman wont be the main piece going back.
 
I would rather have Gardiner going forward than Phaneuf. Our team is NOT built to win in the playoffs, so STAY YOUNG, and STAY STRONG. We are a nice regular season team. We would get stomped in the playoffs. With just Gus in net and fleas up front.
 
Weber wouldn't just be here this year. He is 26. You'd have a 5-10 year window of having two of the best physical, two way, shut down dmen in the NHL. That IS what helps you win in the playoffs. Being able to match up against teams with more than one good line, and make their skilled players lives a living hell.
 
Back
Top