• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

As for cost, IMO it would be something similar to what Philly gave up for Pronger with a year left on his deal. Lupul, Sbisa and 2 1sts.
 
is he, though?

think about how good phaneuf has been this year.

and then imagine getting 50 minutes of that a game.

60 minutes in a playoff game.

really, that's a hell of a team to have to play against.

again, i don't even love weber -- i don't really think he's even that much better than phaneuf (not by much, anyways). but that is, immediately, the sort of team you don't want to play against in the playoffs.

maybe gardiner becomes their 'suter'. but with phaneuf-weber you wouldn't really need a suter, or at least somebody as good as suter. you just need a heady defenseman who can skate the puck, and move it up ice. and they got it for $3.8mn. good value for a #3 defenseman, even on a team spending $14mn on it's top two.
Yes that's how I feel as well.

Was adding Niedermayers redundant when the Ducks have Pronger?

Imagine always having 1 of Phaneuf or Weber on the ice in a playoff series.

I'd HATE to play against that team.
 
If we had Weber then it would really push Schenn back to the point that id almost hope he was included in the deal. But if they require Gardiner too, then what, you give them both Schenn and Gardiner? I dunno if i like that idea! Just because it sounds like that even would it get it done.
 
Conspiracy theory #1, Burke/Poile already have a deal in place to move Weber to the Leafs at the deadline, talks that have been in place since the Franson/Lombardi deal.
 
Phaneuf and Weber are very comparable.

Big, physical, minute eating dman with big shots, that can be prone to defensive gaffs at times.

The advantage Weber has, that being in Nashville, his errors aren't shown on sportscentre every 30 seconds.
 
Stop comparing Phaneuf to Weber.

Weber is a top-5 defenceman in this league. Phaneuf is Bryan McCabe.

both Phaneuf are excellent top-10 dmen in the league, and have been since their early 20s.

McCabe reached that level for a few years in his prime.
 
Weber is Phaneuf part 2. Depending on which season you look at, sometimes Weber's been better, sometimes worse, sometimes the same. But in terms of style, they're close.

I'd love Weber. But Suter is probably a better fit, given we already have a similar player in Phaneuf.
 
is he, though?

think about how good phaneuf has been this year.

and then imagine getting 50 minutes of that a game.

60 minutes in a playoff game.

really, that's a hell of a team to have to play against.

again, i don't even love weber -- i don't really think he's even that much better than phaneuf (not by much, anyways). but that is, immediately, the sort of team you don't want to play against in the playoffs.

maybe gardiner becomes their 'suter'. but with phaneuf-weber you wouldn't really need a suter, or at least somebody as good as suter. you just need a heady defenseman who can skate the puck, and move it up ice. and they got it for $3.8mn. good value for a #3 defenseman, even on a team spending $14mn on it's top two.

Totally agreed. And it's a very Burke-like move.
 
Phaneuf has had a hall of fame like start to his career -- and his numbers are comparable to guys like Niedermayer, Blake, Pronger at similar ages.

McCabe was much more of a late bloomer.
 
Chara
Keith
Lidstrom
Phaneuf
Suter
Weber

I'd say those 6 are definite top-10 defensemen, then you have a whack of guys who arguably belong there but are maybe a bit more inconsistent or unproven - Boyle, Green, Letang, Karlsson, Doughty, Myers, Edler...maybe guys like Enstrom, Bouwmeester, Pietrangelo, Girardi.
 
Back
Top