• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

i think you have it backwards... i think komisarek submits a list of teams he WOULDN'T accept a trade to.

Yeah, you might be right. And if he had to submit at the start of the year, perhaps Columbus having just picked up Carter wouldn't be on there.
 
anyways.. i don't like the deal, because i don't like nash.

would it make the leafs better right now? yup. it would address their biggest need and give them a big upgrade up front. another first liner doesn't hurt.

but it reeks of a desperate move, because imo rick nash will never be a top option on a cup winner. the guy just doesn't have it. i don't think he's suddenly going to love trying just because he's in toronto instead of columbus. and, in fact, going from the obscurity of columbus to the glare of toronto is just as likely to affect him nevatively as it is to kick him in the ass and get him to try harder.
 
Huselius only played 39 games last year and all of 2 games this year and is still on the IR

I cant see us trading both Kadri and Schenn in the same deal, especially if one of the players is on the IR..

Huselius is there for cap purposes only...he's not really expect to play much this season, and is a UFA in the summer. We wouldn't be bringing him back.
 
anyways.. i don't like the deal, because i don't like nash.

would it make the leafs better right now? yup. it would address their biggest need and give them a big upgrade up front. another first liner doesn't hurt.

but it reeks of a desperate move, because imo rick nash will never be a top option on a cup winner. the guy just doesn't have it. i don't think he's suddenly going to love trying just because he's in toronto instead of columbus. and, in fact, going from the obscurity of columbus to the glare of toronto is just as likely to affect him nevatively as it is to kick him in the ass and get him to try harder.

he's not bad to have as our 3rd best winger, though.
 
I'd hate to give up Kadri, but how can you turn that deal down. Even if Nash is overrated he is a 6'4 220 pound 70+ point winger, who is one of the best goal scorers in the NHL and has elite speed and skill.

Especially when you get to dump Komi in the process.
 
though now that I think about it, all that deal would do in reality would be replace Grabo with Nash (questionable upgrade at this point...maybe even a downgrade), and then see us lose Kadri, Schenn, and Komi on top of that.

maybe I wouldn't do that deal.
 
he's not bad to have as our 3rd best winger, though.

agreed completely.

i just see it as a case of bringing in a guy who might make you better, but won't help you win a cup.

kind of like columbus bringing in carter.

that said, yeah, i'd have a tough time saying no. because the leafs definitely get the best player out of that deal, and like you said... it gives them a hell of a 2nd line.
 
though now that I think about it, all that deal would do in reality would be replace Grabo with Nash (questionable upgrade at this point...maybe even a downgrade), and then see us lose Kadri, Schenn, and Komi on top of that.

maybe I wouldn't do that deal.

The assumption has to be that he returns to being a 70-80 point player in Toronto.

If you're trading for the 33 point in 49 games Nash, then ya, the Leafs lose big.
 
Last 2 years:

R.Nash (27): 124gms, 49gls, 99pts (82gms, 32gls, 66pts)
M.Grabo (27): 124gms, 45gls, 90pts (82gms, 30gls, 60pts)
 
Odds are that we're not bringing Grabo back anyway.

This is really a tough one to handicap because of the inclusion of Komi...I mean, how valuable to us is being rid of that ****ing albatross? He makes our blueline immediately better just by not being here...and opens up that chunk of cap space this summer.

Would I do Grabo, Kadri, & Schenn for Nash? No, no I wouldn't....but **** me, the appeal of being rid of Komi makes it close.

Even then, I think I'd want more from Columbus. A useful body instead of Huselius. Prospal maybe....someone who we can at least flip for something at the deadline. Huselius is just a contract at this point.
 
I;d reject that deal if i am Burke, i simply don't like Nash enough, or at all for that matter, and it doesnt address the need for a center.
 
I'd rather trade for a Ruutu for now and then target Parise in the off-season. Just as much risk involved and we can keep Kadri.
 
The only hope to sign Parise as a UFA is if he is willing to leave a bunch of money on the table from one of those retirement deals to sign with the Leafs.
 
Back
Top