• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

If you piece that together with the rumours that Burke wanted Read involved maybe something like Schenn, and Kuly for JVR and Read makes sense.

Don't think I'd do that one though.
 
Did you see that on TSN or? I saw it but they never mentioned names going the other way. That's way too much for JVR imo and i don't see the point of getting rid of one big body in Kully for another one in JVR (and on top of that Schenn and Kadri).
The names were from the Dreger rumors BEFORE he went down to concussions.

And there's supposed to be a little more coming our way from Philly too.

I am not a huge fan of JVR though ... while he has the size, I think thus far his development has been a little slow to say the least. And his ceiling isn't all that high either ... I see a Carter-lite in JVR, which isn't necessarily a core piece of the puzzle.

If we are indeed acquiring JVR, we'd better keep Kadri AND Colborne, and hope that either 1 of them develop into a top line center.
 
The names were from the Dreger rumors BEFORE he went down to concussions.

And there's supposed to be a little more coming our way from Philly too.

I am not a huge fan of JVR though ... while he has the size, I think thus far his development has been a little slow to say the least. And his ceiling isn't all that high either ... I see a Carter-lite in JVR, which isn't necessarily a core piece of the puzzle.

If we are indeed acquiring JVR, we'd better keep Kadri AND Colborne, and hope that either 1 of them develop into a top line center.

Yeah and it doesn't seem to make much sense in other ways too. Like i don't even know why we are looking at wingers. Can JVR play center as well? We have Lupul and Kully who use their size quite well. It makes more sense to get a big 2nd line center because we're pretty small in that area. That way we can ship one of Lombo/Connolly/Bozak (or play someone on wing) and have Bozak, Grabo, Physical Center, Steckel. Our d is pretty much set even if we move one of Schenn, Franson, Komi. Only goaltending becomes a bit of a question mark.
 
I would never EVER do Schenn straight up for JVR- Sorry, but Schenn is just scratching the surface with his potential as a solid NHL defencmen. Look at this way, it takes big bodied defensmen a lot longer to develop then it does say a forward, Schenn at 22 years old has steadily increased his point totals each season, he led the league in hits for defencmen last season, and he's doing so again this year, not to mention I believe he also has a plus rating. Guys like Schenn don't usually peak until 27-28 years old, he's already a beast out there, imagine what he'll be like when he reaches his prime. I can easily see Schenn being a 30-35ish pt defencemen with the occasiaonal foray into the 40 points terriotory not just that but he'll be a stud in the back end who will dish out plenty of hits.

The only way I would trade Schenn is if its a package deal for an elite player. Sorry, but JVR IM0 is the run of the mill 2nd line type player. Would I like to have him on this team? Sure, but not at the expense of Luke Schenn.
 
Yeah and it doesn't seem to make much sense in other ways too. Like i don't even know why we are looking at wingers.
Thus the title "Burke is desperate to make a move" I guess ... :)

What's the point of overpaying for a young player who's anything but a sure thing to be a top 6, and isn't even a great fit position-wise? No, JVR doesn't play center. He's been a winger all of his career.

If I have to go after a player on the Flyers I go after B. Schenn.
 
for msun..

Warrior-hogan2.gif
 
I would never EVER do Schenn straight up for JVR- Sorry, but Schenn is just scratching the surface with his potential as a solid NHL defencmen. Look at this way, it takes big bodied defensmen a lot longer to develop then it does say a forward, Schenn at 22 years old has steadily increased his point totals each season, he led the league in hits for defencmen last season, and he's doing so again this year, not to mention I believe he also has a plus rating. Guys like Schenn don't usually peak until 27-28 years old, he's already a beast out there, imagine what he'll be like when he reaches his prime. I can easily see Schenn being a 30-35ish pt defencemen with the occasiaonal foray into the 40 points terriotory not just that but he'll be a stud in the back end who will dish out plenty of hits.

The only way I would trade Schenn is if its a package deal for an elite player. Sorry, but JVR IM0 is the run of the mill 2nd line type player. Would I like to have him on this team? Sure, but not at the expense of Luke Schenn.

Currently if i'm a GM considering of getting Schenn on my team, i can look at each game and see so many things i dont like. From not being a great skater to making bad decisions quite often. I would not trade my elite player unless i got a lot more back. He's playing as our 5-6th dman right now. I was hoping he'd become a bit like Larry Murphy (Schenn is more punishing but not anywhere as smart though) and i just don't see that right now. Should we wait more? I don't mind keeping him but i wouldn't hesitate to pull a trigger because we do have depth and Aulie can replace Schenn imo.
 
So according to Dreger Philly wants Schenn, Kulemin, and Kadri for JVR?....and i thought underrated leafs prospects.

Dreger shouldnt quit his day job of organizing sleepovers for kids in his basement

So Philadelphia wants the NHL's hits leader and one of the top shot-blocking, stay-at-home defenders in the league, who also happens to have just turned 22 years old and is only three and a half years removed from being a top five draft pick, a budding power forward coming off of a 30-30-60 season and who is only 25 years old, and a former seventh overall pick who happens to be one of the league's better forward prospects? All of a talented, albeit inconsistent and still developing power forward who has never bettered 20-20-40 numbers and had a decent, yet brief post-season run last year? That's ridiculous.
 
I would never EVER do Schenn straight up for JVR- Sorry, but Schenn is just scratching the surface with his potential as a solid NHL defencmen. Look at this way, it takes big bodied defensmen a lot longer to develop then it does say a forward, Schenn at 22 years old has steadily increased his point totals each season, he led the league in hits for defencmen last season, and he's doing so again this year, not to mention I believe he also has a plus rating. Guys like Schenn don't usually peak until 27-28 years old, he's already a beast out there, imagine what he'll be like when he reaches his prime. I can easily see Schenn being a 30-35ish pt defencemen with the occasiaonal foray into the 40 points terriotory not just that but he'll be a stud in the back end who will dish out plenty of hits.

The only way I would trade Schenn is if its a package deal for an elite player. Sorry, but JVR IM0 is the run of the mill 2nd line type player. Would I like to have him on this team? Sure, but not at the expense of Luke Schenn.

I challenge you to an INFERNO MATCH....WITH LADDERS.
 
JVR's problem isn't so much his ceiling ... he's got the size, the skating, the hands ... he definitely has the raw talent, but he's not fulfilling those promises ... yet.

And he's 23, so his slow development is a little concerning. But it's also true big power forwards take longer to develop.
 
Currently if i'm a GM considering of getting Schenn on my team, i can look at each game and see so many things i dont like. From not being a great skater to making bad decisions quite often. I would not trade my elite player unless i got a lot more back. He's playing as our 5-6th dman right now. I was hoping he'd become a bit like Larry Murphy (Schenn is more punishing but not anywhere as smart though) and i just don't see that right now. Should we wait more? I don't mind keeping him but i wouldn't hesitate to pull a trigger because we do have depth and Aulie can replace Schenn imo.

Are you sure you're thinking of the player you're thinking of?

Larry Murphy was renowned for being an incredibly soft defenceman who was prone to defensive lapses and poor decision-making. Of course, he was also arguably one of the top five offensive defenders of all-time, played on multiple Stanley Cup champions, and is in the top three for all-time games played by a defenceman.

Not to mention stylistically he has nothing at all in common with Schenn: Murphy was one of the league's best skaters, smooth and effortless, adept at moving the puck. Schenn struggles in all of those aspects and his bread and butter is his physicality and willingness to punish the opposition.
 
Back
Top