• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Schenn's absolute best case projection would be Scott Stevens ... but he doesn't really have Steven's offensive talent. If he develops into Adam Foote, that would be very good for us already.
 
The names were from the Dreger rumors BEFORE he went down to concussions.

And there's supposed to be a little more coming our way from Philly too.

I am not a huge fan of JVR though ... while he has the size, I think thus far his development has been a little slow to say the least. And his ceiling isn't all that high either ... I see a Carter-lite in JVR, which isn't necessarily a core piece of the puzzle.

If we are indeed acquiring JVR, we'd better keep Kadri AND Colborne, and hope that either 1 of them develop into a top line center.

In all fairness, this is not necessarily true. When looking at JVR's potential ceiling as a player you're talking about a possible John Leclair-esque type impact power forward. A legitimate 40-50 goal man who can crash the crease, and keep in mind that Leclair's development was even slower than JVR's and he didn't break out until he was in his mid to late twenties.
 
Schenn's absolute best case projection would be Scott Stevens ... but he doesn't really have Steven's offensive talent. If he develops into Adam Foote, that would be very good for us already.

Post-1994 Scott Stevens? Sure. After that season Stevens never scored more than 31 points in a year.
 
Are you sure you're thinking of the player you're thinking of?

Larry Murphy was renowned for being an incredibly soft defenceman who was prone to defensive lapses and poor decision-making. Of course, he was also arguably one of the top five offensive defenders of all-time, played on multiple Stanley Cup champions, and is in the top three for all-time games played by a defenceman.

Not to mention stylistically he has nothing at all in common with Schenn: Murphy was one of the league's best skaters, smooth and effortless, adept at moving the puck. Schenn struggles in all of those aspects and his bread and butter is his physicality and willingness to punish the opposition.

No, that's why i said a bit like Larry Murphy with physical part that Murphy didn't have. I wanted Schenn to be better with his passing ability (like Murphy was) and for the skating, i really don't remember Murphy being fast (but yes he was smooth). I notice even Schenn can look good at times with his moves although he gets brain farts quite often when he has to make a simple pass (was Murphy really that bad?).
 
And he's 23, so his slow development is a little concerning. But it's also true big power forwards take longer to develop.

He's not really developing all that slowly......he's playing at a 48 point pace, as a 22 year old. That's pretty solid for a power forward of that age.
 
i see schenn and jvr as comparable on a whole host of levels.

and to be perfectly honest i think that a schenn for jvr swap (straight up) is a very fair deal that makes a ton of sense for both teams.
 
He's not really developing all that slowly......he's playing at a 48 point pace, as a 22 year old. That's pretty solid for a power forward of that age.

and luke schenn's playing at a 25 point pace as a 21 year old, which is pretty solid for a physical defensive defenseman at that age.

i see them as similar players with similar upsides and similar limitations.
 
In all fairness, this is not necessarily true. When looking at JVR's potential ceiling as a player you're talking about a possible John Leclair-esque type impact power forward. A legitimate 40-50 goal man who can crash the crease, and keep in mind that Leclair's development was even slower than JVR's and he didn't break out until he was in his mid to late twenties.
And there are no shortage of examples even in today's NHL that big power forwards take long to develop and mature.

JVR himself grew up as an Adam Graves fan and modeled his game after him.
 
Overpaying to Philadelphia does us no favours, especially if they're a potential playoff match-up.

Let them rent another senior citizen and see how many more years they can handle 20-30 games of Pronger.
 
He's not really developing all that slowly......he's playing at a 48 point pace, as a 22 year old. That's pretty solid for a power forward of that age.
I guess ... as a 2nd overall pick, you usually expect more ... but granted, that was an extremely weak draft year after the 1st overall pick.
 
Andy Strickland suggests the Blues would consider moving Chris Stewart and that they're looking at Ruutu and Gleason.
Chris Stewart is exactly the kind of guy I'd love to see us go after. He's way behind his usual level of production, so you may be able to "buy low" on him. And of course, he fits our needs up front perfectly: size and scoring ability. And as an added bonus for LoF, he's from Toronto. And as an added bonus for TH, Stewart is black, so he'll have a role model to look up to on the Leaf roster.

As for the proposed Getzlaf trade, I'm not even really sure why it's being debated so much. It's a hypothetical trade scenario that the Toronto Star writer made up from an amalgamation of bogus online rumours, and it's a typical HFtards type "the Leafs will have to give up every single young player of any value in their organization AND a first round pick to get this player" trade scenario.

And then while I am definitely not opposed to trading Luke Schenn for help up front, I have zero interest in trading him for JVR. JVR hasn't really shown anything, besides one strong (but short) playoff run last year, to indicate that he has the potential to be anything more than a 20/50 guy at the NHL level. And unless I'm mistaken, while he may be big, he's not really known for using that size to his advantage.
 
Why would we deal a player that we have developed for the last 3 seasons for a guy that we dont know is healthy?

I dont see the point. Now if Philadelphia is giving JVR away for .10 on the dollar then we can talk.

Im not denying the fact that JVR is looking to become a solid player in the next few years, but is he worth giving away the league leading hitting defenceman? Im pretty sure guys like Schenn come in pretty handy when we will be in the playoffs.
 
Overpaying to Philadelphia does us no favours, especially if they're a potential playoff match-up.

Let them rent another senior citizen and see how many more years they can handle 20-30 games of Pronger.

This.
 
No, that's why i said a bit like Larry Murphy with physical part that Murphy didn't have. I wanted Schenn to be better with his passing ability (like Murphy was) and for the skating, i really don't remember Murphy being fast (but yes he was smooth). I notice even Schenn can look good at times with his moves although he gets brain farts quite often when he has to make a simple pass (was Murphy really that bad?).

You confused Larry Murphy with Larry Robinson didn't you?
 
Larry Murphy was renowned for being an incredibly soft defenceman who was prone to defensive lapses and poor decision-making. Of course, he was also arguably one of the top five offensive defenders of all-time, played on multiple Stanley Cup champions, and is in the top three for all-time games played by a defenceman.

larry murphy wasn't known for this at all. maple leafs fans invented this, because the team sucked and they made him the scapegoat.

larry murphy wasn't 'incredibly soft', and he wasn't prone to defensive lapses.

he was a bit slow footed but it wasn't really a problem for him at all.



strnage that somebody would compare him to schenn, though. outside of both having medicore lateral skating (which opened them up to getting beaten on the outside from time to time) i can't think of two less comparable defensemen.
 
You're without question correct that Leafs fans treated him like shit and I have railed against that literally dozens of times on this forum and on HFTards so there's really no need to lecture me about him. I've been Murphy's defender for years now.

But truthfully he was prone to defensive lapses from time to time and that's not really even debatable. It was just silly for Leafs fans to boo a first-ballot Hall of Famer whose offensive abilities more than made up for his occasional mistakes in the defensive zone and who was coming off of an all-star starter's appearance in his first season with the team.
 
Back
Top