• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Schenn should be rock solid in another year or two. He probably would be right there if he had been able to go to the AHL under better NHL rules.
 
The crazy thing is another year or two Schenn will still only be 24-25 and still a couple of years away from just entering his prime years.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again, it took Chris Pronger 6 -7 years to finally put it all together. Leaf fans are just too impatient, we want results and we want them now. Its probably why the Leafs for years have made patch work type moves to tread water, rather then actually build a legitimate contender. You don't give up on 22year-olds that have been rushed to the NHL.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again, it took Chris Pronger 6 -7 years to finally put it all together. Leaf fans are just too impatient, we want results and we want them now. Its probably why the Leafs for years have made patch work type moves to tread water, rather then actually build a legitimate contender. You don't give up on 22year-olds that have been rushed to the NHL.

Very good point.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again, it took Chris Pronger 6 -7 years to finally put it all together. Leaf fans are just too impatient, we want results and we want them now. Its probably why the Leafs for years have made patch work type moves to tread water, rather then actually build a legitimate contender. You don't give up on 22year-olds that have been rushed to the NHL.

Please say it again!
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again, it took Chris Pronger 6 -7 years to finally put it all together. Leaf fans are just too impatient, we want results and we want them now. Its probably why the Leafs for years have made patch work type moves to tread water, rather then actually build a legitimate contender. You don't give up on 22year-olds that have been rushed to the NHL.

The salient point of course is that, similarly to Schenn, Pronger played his first few formative seasons on an abominably awful team.

When a young defender is expected to shoulder a heavy burden (top four minutes) right out of the gate with raw offensive skills that need further development, it's probably a hindrance to him long-term in developing an effective all-around skill-set to play in the NHL before he's comfortable. And of course when they're playing on a team with poor goaltending that is known for its defensive struggles it encourages them to play a more conservative, laid-back game rather than initiate in risk-taking and creative plays. I go back and forth in my mind whether or not it was the right move to have Schenn make the team as an eighteen year-old a lot on nights where he struggles (especially with the puck-handling game), but hindsight is always 20/20. At the time the Leafs were desperate for defensive help and Schenn had an incredibly promising training camp.

Ultimately it looks like he would have benefited from another season in the WHL with Kelowna to work on his offence, but defensively he's been NHL ready since he was seventeen.
 
ps - trading a 22 year old defenseman, for equally young forward that fills a hole on your team is "giving up" on him.



You can't trade players, unless you think they're junk, apparently.
 
ps - trading a 22 year old defenseman, for equally young forward that fills a hole on your team is "giving up" on him.



You can't trade players, unless you think they're junk, apparently.

I suppose you mean JVR and his concussion. That wouldn't be giving up on him, that would just be foolish.
 
montana, you make me chuckle at least once a day

motel-6.jpg


:sarcasm
 
1. Why does trading a 22 yr old always = "giving up" on him? Are we suggesting to trade him for a 31 year old whose best days are behind him? Or are we suggesting to trade a 22 yr old from our abundance of defensemen for a similarly aged forward, which we desperately need?

2. Who said it has to be JVR? And who said JVR's damaged good because he had his first concussion of his career?

3. Our entire blueline, with the exception of Liles (30) is young ... so going with the theory of "let's not trade any young guy" Aulie will be stuck in the AHL forever. Percy will never play for this team no matter how well he develops.
 
1. Why does trading a 22 yr old always = "giving up" on him? Are we suggesting to trade him for a 31 year old whose best days are behind him? Or are we suggesting to trade a 22 yr old from our abundance of defensemen for a similarly aged forward, which we desperately need?

2. Who said it has to be JVR? And who said JVR's damaged good because he had his first concussion of his career?

3. Our entire blueline, with the exception of Liles (30) is young ... so going with the theory of "let's not trade any young guy" Aulie will be stuck in the AHL forever. Percy will never play for this team no matter how well he develops.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Trading him regardless if its for a 22 year old at the beginning of his career or a 39 year old at the end of his, is giving up on Luke no way around it

2. Good point

3. Schenn isn't the one who is cock blocking the development of the young blueliners, that would fall on Komiserak. The guy is 30 years old he isn't getting any better and at this point in his career is an extremely overpaid fringe NHL player who can't even play a full schedule. Burke has to find a sucker to unload this guy on, that or bite the bullet and buy him out so that guys like Aullie and company can get a shot in the NHL.
 
and the media begins anew...

David Pagnotta
Kadri is only piece Cbus MIGHT consider in a package, forget Scrivens & Kulemin. Frankly, Leafs don't have the total pieces for Nash. #sorry
 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Trading him regardless if its for a 22 year old at the beginning of his career or a 39 year old at the end of his, is giving up on Luke no way around it

2. Good point

3. Schenn isn't the one who is cock blocking the development of the young blueliners, that would fall on Komiserak. The guy is 30 years old he isn't getting any better and at this point in his career is an extremely overpaid fringe NHL player who can't even play a full schedule. Burke has to find a sucker to unload this guy on, that or bite the bullet and buy him out so that guys like Aullie and company can get a shot in the NHL.

Sorry, but that's really really dumb. Trading somebody does =/= giving up on them. Trading somebody = using your available assets to improve your team.

As AA likes to point out, he wants to complete trades that work for both teams so you can deal with them again. Trading a player is not saying you don't think they are good, or don't think they will improve; it's simply one of the many ways you can improve your team. Especially when you trade from a position of strength (Leafs D) for weakness (forwards with size).
 
I love Luke Schenn, but I have to say, if a James Van Riemsdyk for Luke Schenn deal is on the table, both GM's are going to feel some level of temptation to give it some serious thought.
 
and the media begins anew...

David Pagnotta
Kadri is only piece Cbus MIGHT consider in a package, forget Scrivens & Kulemin. Frankly, Leafs don't have the total pieces for Nash. #sorry

Doesn't this guy work for thefourthperiod.com?

Another Eklund wannabe.. I'd rather hear it from the mouth of Bob MacKenzie or someone who actually has any connections.

Pretty sure the Leafs could easily put together a package for Nash if they wanted him bad enough.
 
Doesn't this guy work for thefourthperiod.com?

Another Eklund wannabe.. I'd rather hear it from the mouth of Bob MacKenzie or someone who actually has any connections.

Pretty sure the Leafs could easily put together a package for Nash if they wanted him bad enough.

+1
 
Back
Top