• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I'd say 1 - as much as I like Gardiner, I don't see him as an untouchable. As per Eakins, Gardiner may not be an offensive defenseman in the NHL. He will be a very effective defenseman who can move puck up ice quickly and with confidence, he can log a lot of minutes, but not sure he'll be a consistent 40-50 points dman in the NHL.

Second of all, I think you're under-estimating the value of a consistent 30+G power forward who's only 28, and I don't even like Nash all that much.

I like Eakins but i think he's going to be wrong here. I think Jake will put up good offensive numbers..As much as i like Nash (as i already said above) defencemen like Jake don't come around very often so unless i was getting back a top 5 in the league type player and in his early 20's (Nash is late 20's now) i don't make a move. I give more value to a defenceman simply because it's not as easy to excel at that position.
 
this Nash frenzy reminds me alot of the Owen Nolan sweepstakes ..... I say thanks but no thanks .... Crosby will be a UFA in another year and would rather take my chances there.
 
Big difference- Kovalchuck was a pending UFA that offseason, New Jersey wasn't going to overpay for the guy when he could be have been had for free several short months later. Nash has a fair number of years left on his contract, and Columbus isn't making the playoffs, again they are in NO rush to trade the guy, they can afford to wait it out and drive up the trading value for Nash.
they can, but again, so could Flyers with carter and Richards.

Nash is the franchaise player, and once your franchaise player has told you he wants to get traded, you don't want this to drag on for too long.

True they don't have to trade him by trade deadline, but that's also when you get the best deal. I'd say if not before trade deadline, Nash is gone in the summer. He won't be a CBJ when next season starts.
 
First of all, no way you get Nash for strictly "B" players. In fact, I'd say Nash will fetch more than Gardiner + Colborne + 1st.

2. interesting you call Kadri a "B" prospect but Colborne an "A" ... but I won't go there.

They're not "B" players. They're just the guys I would give up before Colborne and Gardiner.
 
@ LOF

You have to look at Columbus's big weakneses which are a # 1 goalie, a mobile puckmoving defencmen and a 2nd line centre. If the leafs/jackets do a deal, Gardiner will 100% be part of the package going back in return for Nash.

It will likely cost something like this: Gardiner, Kadri/Colborne, 1st rounder. And that is just a starting point. Personally, I wouldnt do this deal even though its a fair one, we dont need scoring, what we need is a steady #1 goalie above all else.
 
this Nash frenzy reminds me alot of the Owen Nolan sweepstakes ..... I say thanks but no thanks .... Crosby will be a UFA in another year and would rather take my chances there.

The Leafs gave up hardly anything of lasting value for Nolan or Leetch when they acquired them, excluding the media's brief pitched-tent for Brad Boyes.
 
Nash, with that contract and his subpar performance, is not going to cost us our entire minor league system people.

There's only a few teams he'll accept a trade to, a few teams that could afford him, and a few teams that would be willing to trade for him.

He's not going to command our entire minor league system if we get him.
 
As for Colborne and Kadri, i'm not too high on either one. I think their limit is good 2nd line players..If we can get Nash for 1 of them in a package deal, i'd do it.
 
As for Colborne and Kadri, i'm not too high on either one. I think their limit is good 2nd line players..If we can get Nash for 1 of them in a package deal, i'd do it.

I've never been overly high on Kadri either, I don't see some elite player in him, I don't even see him as an above average player. I see Sam Gagner upside with Kadri, which is a guy who can net 15-20goals/40-50pts annually on the 2nd or 3rd line, good player to have but not a type you build your team around either.
 
Brad Boyes and his 153 goals and 362 points as a 2nd line player or Alyn McCauley and his excellent pk and defensive play? Or that 1st rounder who turned out to be Steve Bernier who I think has played 7 seasons in the NHL as a serviceable defenceman for Owen Nolan and his 26 goals and 60 points he brought to the leafs over 2-3 seasons ..... Bad math if you think that they didnt give up anything of lasting value.
 
The Flyers didn't have to trade Carter or Richards either.

Every single year there are big names up for grabs and people always consistently over-estimate what it will take to acquire them. Every. Single. Year.

Stop falling for the blatantly obvious hype, people.

You don't think the Flyers got good deals for those two malcontents? Brayden Schenn, Wayne Simmonds and a 2nd round pick for Mike Richards? B. Schenn had more value last offseason than Luke or Gardiner does now didn't he? And this was for a guy with 12 years left on his deal. That's why I'm saying it would take one of those guys, plus added value (from Toronto in a Nash deal) since Brayden was considered one of the top prospects in hockey at the time.

Carter went for Jakub Voracek and the 8th overall pick (Couturier), plus a 3rd rounder.

I'd rather have Nash than either of those guys (although Richards is debatable), but yeah, the deal is going to have a somewhat similar value, I would think.
 
Brad Boyes and his 153 goals and 362 points as a 2nd line player or Alyn McCauley and his excellent pk and defensive play? Or that 1st rounder who turned out to be Steve Bernier who I think has played 7 seasons in the NHL as a serviceable defenceman for Owen Nolan and his 26 goals and 60 points he brought to the leafs over 2-3 seasons ..... Bad math if you think that they didnt give up anything of lasting value.

Brad Boyes and his combined 20 goals in the past three seasons? Buffalo's considering dumping him to Rochester at this point.

Alyn McCauley and his persistent post-concussion syndrome that caused him to retire from the NHL just two seasons after being dealt at the age of 29?

And Steve Bernier? Really? You're hanging your hat on Steve Bernier? And no he wasn't a defenceman. He was a third/fourth-line right winger who was a draft bust and played remarkably below expectations. He was also one of the few non-impact players or all-stars drafted in the greatest draft of the past twenty five years.

The only one here using bad math is you if you think that those players were in any way substantial value for an impact player like Nolan.
 
Back
Top