This year not withstanding, Nash is a better player than Kessel. He would instantly be the best player on the leafs.
why would you disregard kessel's breakout year? not only that, why would you disregard the fact that kessel is in the midst of a season that would rank, by a healthy margin, as the best of nash's 10 year career?
nash isn't the better player because of what he did in the past. right now kessel is the better player and if he can keep up what he has done for the first 60 games of this season, he is also the best player overall.
not only that, but what nash has done as a 24-27 year old (when most forwards see their production peak) has been only a step up from what kessel has done as a 21-24 year old.
Adding Carter and Nash to this team would add to our talent pool. Thinking any of those players "might" become as effective is wishful thinking.
wishful thinking implies unlikelihood.
nikolai kulemin scored 30 goals last year. rick nash scored 32.
luke schenn has been a valuable member of this team's blueline for 4 seasons now. he has had some bumps in the road but he is currently on pace for over 25 points, is the most physical defenseman in the league and -- despite having over 200 nhl games under his belt -- is just 22 years old and was a top 5 pick just 4 years ago.
nazem kadri hasn't produced yet, but projecting that a recent top 10 pick who has produced at about a point per game through a year and a half in the ahl to become a productive nhl'er isn't 'wishful thinking'. it is, statistically, more likely than not that he becomes a productive nhl'er. how productive is obviously a matter of some debate, but the chances of him becoming at least a second line forward should be classified as better than possible or 'wishful'.
A perennial Rocket Richard candidate in Nash, and a guy in Carter who has averaged over 30 goals a season in his career would be good value.
perennial rocket richard candidate?
he has topped 40 goals just once since the lockout.
over the past four seasons:
78 gp 40 g
76 gp 33 g
75 gp 32 g
58 gp 18 g
287 gp 123 g
35 g per 82 gp
for what it's worth, over that same stretch our own phil kessel:
70 gp 36 g
70 gp 30 g
82 gp 32 g
59 gp 30 g
281 gp 128 g
37 g per 82 gp