• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Kovalchuk played with Savard, Heatley, Hossa, Kozlov.......those are some pretty damn good linemates.

Especially when compared to the likes of Vermette, Vyborny, Umberger, etc.

I may be mistaken but isn't the adage that a superstar makes players around him better? Paying superstar prices for Nash is a mistake in my opinion.
 
I would say not making the playoffs isn't satisfying Burke's standards.

Burke has nobody to blame but himself if we miss- He chose to go with two raw goalies this year instead of bringing in an experinced vet (ala Vokoun) and he also chose to stick with Wilson knowing full well how horrible he is.

Right now the leafs IMO have a 50/50 shot, for Burke's career he better be on his knees praying to god we get into the playoffs.
 
I may be mistaken but isn't the adage that a superstar makes players around him better? Paying superstar prices for Nash is a mistake in my opinion.
Problem is that the risk/return ratio isn't all that favorable. At best, he might play up to the value of his contract.
 
Bringing in Vokoun wasnt going to happen as much as we keep repeating it. He wanted to go to a potential contender and we weren't there at the time. He was not signing here
 
I may be mistaken but isn't the adage that a superstar makes players around him better? Paying superstar prices for Nash is a mistake in my opinion.
Problem is that the risk/reward ratio isn't all that favorable. At best, he might play up to the value of his contract.
 
General Manager records Post Lock-out:


JFJ: W L T PTS GMS PACE
2005/06 41-33- 8 90 82 90.0
2006/07 40-31-11 91 82 91.0
2007/08 16-16- 8 40 40 82.0

Total 97-80-27 221 204 88.8



Fletcher W L T PTS GMS PACE
2007/08 20-19- 3 43 42 84.0
2008/09 7- 9- 5 19 21 74.2

Total 27-28- 8 62 63 80.7



Burke: W L T PTS GMS PACE
2008/09 27-26- 8 62 61 83.3
2009/10 30-38-14 74 82 74.0
2010/11 37-34-11 85 82 85.0
2011/12 29-24- 6 64 59 88.9

Total 123-122-39 285 284 82.3
 
Last edited:
Bringing in Vokoun wasnt going to happen as much as we keep repeating it. He wanted to go to a potential contender and we weren't there at the time. He was not signing here

I wonder how old Tommy boy is feeling about his decision to take a massive pay cut to play on a "contender".
 
You just have unrealistic expectations. That he would build the cup contender within 3 years. Thats nuts. This is the youngest team in the NHL. Yeah they need to add more. They also need time for the rookies to stop making rookie mistakes.

the expectations we're discussing aren't mine, that's the point. they're Burke's. my prediction for this year's team was 10th in the East.

and nobody said anything about the Leafs being a contender inside of 3 years...that's obviously ridiculous. we were just talking about a team that makes the playoffs and won't get beaten easily in the first round -- that's the expectation directly from Burke stated in the last few months. that's certainly still possible, but it's likely to take more than a minor addition with the holes we have.

Burke still has to find players to fill two of the top 3 toughest positions and address a major lack of size and board game up front with the top 6. those aren't "tweaks". Yes, I expected that a GM who preaches toughness and building from the net out would be much further ahead, at the very least in those two specific areas, than we are now.
 
I may be mistaken but isn't the adage that a superstar makes players around him better? Paying superstar prices for Nash is a mistake in my opinion.

Nash has made his linemates numbers better.....doesn't change the fact those linemates are the likes of Vermette, Umberger, Vyborny, etc.

He's no Kovalchuk, but if you don't think he'd have put up considerably better numbers with linemates like Savard, Hossa, Heatley and Kozlov over the years, you're only kidding yourself.
 
Last edited:
There is no way in hell we make the playoffs with Reimer and Gustavsson. Just NOT going to happen. Not unless an overworked pair of Lupul and Kessel get matched by Grabovski, MacArthur and Kulemin again. Then, its possible.

If we had a solid goalie we would be ripping up this conference, ripping it right up.

But make no mistake, Burke has done a very good job. And if he trades three or four veterans and gives up on the playoffs, we will be THAT much stronger. Especially if he resigns Grabs in the offseason. Let him get some playoff experience.
 
Assuming the leafs make the playoffs in the 8th seed and we play the Rangers, I think we'll win the series in 6. The rangers have shown time and time again they can't match our speed, and also they don't have much firepower in their lineup, the leafs have what it takes to win that series. If we play Boston in the 1st round were ****ed, we'll be lucky if we don't get swept by the Bruins, because we just dont have the size/goaltending/defence to compete with the cup champs.
 
I don't understand why Nash all of a sudden became such a shitty, overrated player. Two years ago, when he was named to team Canada, the team with by far the deepest pool of talent, nobody seemed to have a problem with him.

The guy has been playing for the worst team in hockey his entire career and it's affected his numbers.

You guys don't want to pay him 7 million, but I'd much rather do that than pay Connolly his 4.
 
Hey, I like Rich Nash, but not at the cost of Jake Gardiner going the other way. Package up anyone you want other than Gardiner and Kessel, and drive them to the airport.
 
Assuming the leafs make the playoffs in the 8th seed and we play the Rangers, I think we'll win the series in 6. The rangers have shown time and time again they can't match our speed, and also they don't have much firepower in their lineup, the leafs have what it takes to win that series. If we play Boston in the 1st round were ****ed, we'll be lucky if we don't get swept by the Bruins, because we just dont have the size/goaltending/defence to compete with the cup champs.

They have two good goalies, we dont have one anywhere in our organization. None to be found. Leafs get beaten in four or five by any of the top six teams because of that reason. If we had a top six goalie? We would beat anyone other than Boston easily imo. Because of our speed.
 
Watching cammalleri make the move to centre.I wonder what Nash would feel about playing centre for a while. I mean with his size and having kessel and loops on his wing he'd be pretty damn surrounded by talent. Then basically trade the whole second line and have Connolly centre the second line until his contract is up and colborne is ready. Call kadri back up and done.
Mac grabs Kule schenn and a first for nash
 
Watching cammalleri make the move to centre.I wonder what Nash would feel about playing centre for a while. I mean with his size and having kessel and loops on his wing he'd be pretty damn surrounded by talent. Then basically trade the whole second line and have Connolly centre the second line until his contract is up and colborne is ready. Call kadri back up and done.
Mac grabs Kule schenn and a first for nash

LOL! You realize Grabo is putting up very similar numbers to Nash this season right? Yet somehow you want to give up our entire 2nd line and Schenn for one overrated merely average 1st line player? Thanks for the laugh.
 
I don't understand why Nash all of a sudden became such a shitty, overrated player. Two years ago, when he was named to team Canada, the team with by far the deepest pool of talent, nobody seemed to have a problem with him.

The guy has been playing for the worst team in hockey his entire career and it's affected his numbers.

You guys don't want to pay him 7 million, but I'd much rather do that than pay Connolly his 4.

first, a lot of us have been calling him an overrated player (who said shitty?) long before he was named to team canada. and in fact his inclusion on the team was only fuel to that fire.

as for the impact playing on columbus has had on his numbers... that's conjecture.

i mean, just look at kovalchuk -- his numbers were much better on an inferior atlanta team (and before anybody goes ahead and brings up heatley, hossa and savard, kovalchuk was on pace to match his career highs in goals and points when atlanta traded him) than on the devils.

there are so many variables that seem to go into these spikes that it's difficult to say just what sort of impact a move to a better team would have on nash. either way, imo, it has much more to do with chemistry and playing in the right system than it has to do with playing with equal talents and on a more sucecssful team.
 
Back
Top