• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

but because Carter was dealt before certain clauses came in they were null and void, right... so if he's stinking it up in the last few years of his deal, you can bury him on the marlies no problem.

I think Carter is the smarter choice because. 1. it fills the need of a centre, 2. He can be had for alot cheaper than Nash. 3. He has demonstrated chemistry with Lupul.

I don't know, I like it better than Nash
 
I can see him putting up those numbers and until his mid 30's. 7 to 8 years of 60-70 pt production at 5.27 is a good imo.
 
I have absolutely zero interest in making a guy who doesn't show up in the playoffs a core part of this team for the next decade.
 
Carter can be had relatively cheap I suspect. definitely cheaper than Nash. even despite that and the potential Carter-Lupul-Kessel chemistry, I can't see Burke going back on his contract policy for a non-elite player.
 
I have absolutely zero interest in making a guy who doesn't show up in the playoffs a core part of this team for the next decade.

We haven't made the playoffs since 04, and yet your worried about a guy not doing well there? Lets just worry about simply making the playoffs first. Also, I still think we should spend our resources on finding a veteran goalie, stud defensemen and a new coach above all else, we don't need any more scoring.
 
but because Carter was dealt before certain clauses came in they were null and void, right... so if he's stinking it up in the last few years of his deal, you can bury him on the marlies no problem.

I think Carter is the smarter choice because. 1. it fills the need of a centre, 2. He can be had for alot cheaper than Nash. 3. He has demonstrated chemistry with Lupul.

I don't know, I like it better than Nash

Eh, Carter is a good player but far from a great one, I dont think he solves our top centre woes. Only way he should be even considered is if Grabo doesnt re-up here, thats when we bring a guy like Carter in. Very similar game to Grabo (minus the craziness) and is a bit more talented, he'd be an upgrade on the 2nd centre postion.
 
We haven't made the playoffs since 04, and yet your worried about a guy not doing well there? Lets just worry about simply making the playoffs first. Also, I still think we should spend our resources on finding a veteran goalie, stud defensemen and a new coach above all else, we don't need any more scoring.

And we also don't need yet another defenceman.
 
Will convincing Howson to take back some dead weight (Komi, Lombardi, Armstrong etc) from us free up enough room to still go after Parise?

All contracts that are expiring within the next two years and it still gives him some veteran leadership for his young team he is gunning for

A top 6 of Lupul, Kessel, Carter, Praise, Mac A and Kully looks pretty on paper.
 
Last edited:
Why would Burke trade our second best player, especially when is only making around 850k? That would be Gardiner. I am hoping the big splash trade that he makes is trading Dion Phaneuf. I watched a special on how hard Dion works out in the summer, yet I still see a play one great game, followed, by a good game, followed by two or three horrible games cycle.

Getting rid of Phaneuf would really open things up for us. I fear, we wouldn't get anything other than a bag for him though. Based on his popularity around the league.
 
Trade him at his peak. SEE if someone will REACH. Burke is probably too loyal to do it, but we might get a pigeon to throw some nice assets at us. And I think our team would improve trading him. Guys like Schenn would take it as a sign that the corportation MLSE actually respects them.
 
By the way? What would LUPUL get back in a trade now? Some say a lot, some say very little. Opinions?
 
Lupul is our best player.

What's with this desire to trade everyone and rebuild when we have an excellent, young core that only needs a first line center, a goalie, and some peppering here and there?
 
Back
Top