• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Not really sure why the Leafs should bother looking at Thomas. They're not close to being a legitimate contender and I doubt that Thomas would want to spend his few remaining years of quality play with a club that doesn't have championship aspirations.

The benefit of Luongo is the fact that most high-end goaltenders continue to play at a high level of effectiveness well into their mid to late 30s and even early 40s in some rare cases (Hasek, Brodeur, Belfour, and Roloson). The Leafs require that type of consistency beyond a season or two to finally solidify our goaltending issues long-term.
 
I can see Thomas being dealt in the offseason. His political antics and calling out teammates might be wearing thin. Most teams could live with this because he's so great, but when you have a goalie like Rask behind him, the Bruins don't have to be as patient.
 
Not really sure why the Leafs should bother looking at Thomas. They're not close to being a legitimate contender and I doubt that Thomas would want to spend his few remaining years of quality play with a club that doesn't have championship aspirations.

The benefit of Luongo is the fact that most high-end goaltenders continue to play at a high level of effectiveness well into their mid to late 30s and even early 40s in some rare cases (Hasek, Brodeur, Belfour, and Roloson). The Leafs require that type of consistency beyond a season or two to finally solidify our goaltending issues long-term.



I don't know, you put Thomas on almost any team in the league and they instantly become a threat.

Elite goaltending adds a lot more wins to your win total.
 
Why are people scared of solidifying our goaltending with a future hall of famer for the next decade?

Because there might be 2-3 years at the end where he may or may not be washed up and may or may not still want to play?
 
My issue isn't the contract length, it's the cap hit.

Hate to spend big bucks on goaltending. Because very few goalies actually earn those big bucks because the position is so unstable/unpredictable.

Although, despite what you think of him, Luongo has been pretty consistent over the years. I'm on the fence with him. He wouldnt be my 1st choice, but I wouldnt be upset if we got him because hed instantly make us better. But better at a hefty price.
 
Ken Holland says it best. You don't spend money/assets on goaltending because you can find average goaltending for cheap, and the difference between .912 and .917 isn't that much. But you can pay for a top goalie, and if you have the opportunity to get one, do it.
 
PTBNL: We keep hearing that, but it's clear that the situation is slowly turning backwards and going back to what it used to be: elite goaltenders making huge amounts of money.
 
Ken Holland says it best. You don't spend money/assets on goaltending because you can find average goaltending for cheap, and the difference between .912 and .917 isn't that much. But you can pay for a top goalie, and if you have the opportunity to get one, do it.

Agreed.

The amount of value that an upper-echelon goaltender playing 70 games a season brings to the table cannot be under-estimated in the least bit. If you get that stort of consistency and elite play should be willing to pay to get it, period.
 
Here is the exact quote:

My feeling is if you can get one of the five or six best goalies in the league you can spend the money. We can’t get into those guys, and the difference between the eighth goalie in the league and the 15th goalie, it’s a big difference in money. It’s not a big difference in performance.

I'm 100% in agreement with this. Don't give guys like Fleury $5 million, if you can get similar goaltending for $2. But if you have a chance to get the guy with the 4th best career save% of all time, get him.
 
Is Luongo elite though?

11/12: 12th in SV%
10/11: 3rd in SV%
09/10: 16th in SV%


He's def a big upgrade over what we got, but I don't know about being elite.

I think there's 3 guys who are above the rest (over the last 2-3 years) -- Thomas, Lundqvist and Rinne and I'd pay them big money. Then there's a big group after them and the order of this next tier changes from year to year.
 
Back
Top