Is Luongo *really* up there with Crosby and Lundqvist?? Like, REALLY??
There's only one other player in the league that is up there with Crosby and he happens to play on the same team. As for Lundqvist, Luongo's actually had a significantly more accolade-laden career to date and he came a relatively close second to Sid (relative given Crosby's season) in the MVP vote in 2007. In virtually any other season the type of performance that he had for Vancouver that year would have been enough to have made him just the third goaltender since Jacques Plante to take home Hart Trophy honours:
HART: Pts. 1st-2nd-3rd-4th-5th
1. Sidney Crosby, PIT 1225 (91-34-14-2-1)
2. Roberto Luongo, VAN 801 (25-46-35-16-6)
3. Martin Brodeur, NJ 763 (21-45-39-12-7)
And here are the two goaltenders' relative rankings in all of the major awards since they entered the league:
Roberto Luongo Awards History
Hart Trophy
2003-04: 6th
2006-07:
2nd
2007-08: 12th
2008-09: 10th
2010-11: 17th
Vezina Trophy
2003-04:
3rd
2005-06: 7th
2006-07:
2nd
2007-08: 7th
2008-09: 4th (three points out of second)
2009-10: 10th
2010-11:
3rd
All-Star Team
2003-04:
2nd
2005-06: 8th
2006-07:
2nd
2007-08: 5th
2008-09:
3rd
2010-11:
3rd
Henrik Lundqvist Awards History
Hart Trophy
2005-06: 9th
2006-07: 22nd
2009-10: 23rd
2010-11: 14th
Vezina Trophy
2005-06: 3rd
2006-07: 3rd
2007-08: 3rd
2008-09: 6th
2009-10: 6th
2010-11: 4th
All-Star Team
2005-06: 3rd
2006-07: 7th
2007-08: 4th
2008-09: 9th
2009-10: 9th
2010-11: 5th
And based on the statistics that 101 posted earlier in the thread, and deserve a re-posting, here's what they have done recently:
2006-07 to 2008-09:
1. Backstrom - .923
2. Vokoun - .921
3. Brodeur - .920
4. Luongo/Thomas - .919
** Rinne - .918 (* only 50 GP)
5. Huet - .916
6. Lundqvist .915
Last 3 years:
1. Thomas - .926
2. Lundqvist - .924
3. Rinne/Vokoun - .922
5. Miller - .921
6. Luongo/Halak - .920
8. Nabokov - .919
9. Bryz/Price/Quick/Ward - .918
So yeah, based on all of the aforementioned considerations I would definitely consider Luongo and Lundqvist to be on the same level. Without question.
There are players you'd just give them a blank check and let them write whatever $$ and terms. I am not 100% sure Luongo is quite up there.
What does this even mean though? Crosby, Malkin, Giroux, Stamkos, and Karlsson are probably the only five players in the entire league that would meet that sort of requirement at this point in time.
Regardless, I am not saying no to Bobby here. He might as well be the best available goalie in the market this summer, and after SO MANY YEARS Burke should stop gambling with the masked man. Let's finally have some stability in goal.
It STILL doesn't mean it has to be Luongo.
IF, for example, Boston is trading Thomas (I don't buy into the media story where BOS is gonna trade him ... I mean, look at it - with their season on the line, in game 6, and in game 7 there's not even a dispute on who starts for BOS) then Thomas at $5Mx1 yr is more intriguing to me than Luongo with his contract.
You want a 39 year-old starter with only a couple of quality seasons remaining over a significantly younger option?
Or, if Vokoun somehow is willing to sign with the Leafs.
Again, an older goaltender who is developing groin problems.
Or, if another top goalie is suddenly available via trade.
Which may or may not exist and which will CERTAINLY cost significant assets, unlike Luongo. He meets the four requirements I alluded to in my previous post in terms of being cheap, affordable cap-wise, consistent, and available. None of the other names bandied about really come close in terms of that sort of attractiveness as a fit in goal. Luongo's the best available name.
All I'm saying is, Luongo, to me, doesn't quite fall under the category of "If you can get this guy, give up anything to get him" category. I'd consider it, but it comes down to what other options are available and what VAN wants in return.
This just sounds like stereotypical media talking points that doesn't really mean anything substantive to me.