• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

First of all Bozak isn't this teams best center. Secondly, if they draft a center in this years draft it won't chnage the depth chart for a few years anyway. That is why you take the BPA and don't pass up a better player for need. Draft picks don't fill needs until down the line when your needs are going to be different.

If you really want Grigorenko, by all means move up to number 2 and take him. But if you are picking first there is only one choice.
 
First of all Bozak isn't this teams best center. Secondly, if they draft a center in this years draft it won't chnage the depth chart for a few years anyway. That is why you take the BPA and don't pass up a better player for need. Draft picks don't fill needs until down the line when your needs are going to be different.

If you really want Grigorenko, by all means move up to number 2 and take him. But if you are picking first there is only one choice.
H

Sorry what I meant to say is Bozak is minutes wise the teams best centre by playing on the top unit with Kessel, Grabo is the most skilled centre. It doesnt matter though because even if Grabo was our "top line centre" he still wouldnt be a good one, still would have the production of a 2nd liner. This year the leafs need to draft Grigorenko, who knows he may end up NHL ready this year just as much of a chance of him needing AHL time, bottom line its' a risk that needs to be gambled upon if the leafs are to truly get the right building blocks here.
 
You don't pass up a potential franchise player because you want a center. You'd just end up kicking yourself. Grigorenko isn't going to step into the NHL and put up first line center points next year. Guys like Stamkos couldn't even do that. And Grigorenko is no Stamkos. On the other hand Yakupov just might be a Stamkos.
 
H

Sorry what I meant to say is Bozak is minutes wise the teams best centre by playing on the top unit with Kessel, Grabo is the most skilled centre. It doesnt matter though because even if Grabo was our "top line centre" he still wouldnt be a good one, still would have the production of a 2nd liner. This year the leafs need to draft Grigorenko, who knows he may end up NHL ready this year just as much of a chance of him needing AHL time, bottom line its' a risk that needs to be gambled upon if the leafs are to truly get the right building blocks here.
It would be OHL or NHL, I don't think most scouts believe Grigorenko to be NHL ready this season. Plus to get him you wouldn't need to trade for the first over all.
 
You don't pass up a potential franchise player because you want a center. You'd just end up kicking yourself. Grigorenko isn't going to step into the NHL and put up first line center points next year. Guys like Stamkos couldn't even do that. And Grigorenko is no Stamkos. On the other hand Yakupov just might be a Stamkos.

This ^^^
 
Drafting for need is a bad strategy. These are 18 year old kids that won't be ready to contribute for 3-4 years (aside from the top end guys like Yakupov). You have to take the best player available.

This.

Drafting for need is about the most moronic strategy teams could employ as positional needs are constantly in a state of flux. I'm surprised this is even being contested.
 
While that may be true that he's the best of the class, drafting him woulnd't help us to address our biggest need which is a topflight centre. We already have an elite top 5 goalscorer in Kessel and a 30 goalish guy in Lupul on the other side, but we don't have that top line centre. It's a risk to see if we can get one with the #5 overall pick, but landing the top overall pick would gurarantee us we'd be able to draft the best centre in the draft.

Look at it this way, say your at home cooking a garden salad, and you have everything but the salad dressing so you go to the store. While your at the store, you come across a 2lb steak which is your favourite meal, you only have $10 so you decide to purchase the steak but you can't afford to get the salad dressing which is needed for the salad. When you get home sure you have a nice juicy steak in the freezer but you don't have the salad dressing needed for the salad at dinner, it's the same thing with this years draft.

It doesn't matter if Yakupov is not a centre. He is clearly the best available draft eligible talent. The Leafs lack of a top flight pivot should have absolutely no relevance to whether they draft him or not. You always go BPA at the draft. Employing the strategy you are advocating is wasteful because it intentionally passes on accumulating superior assets that could be used to directly address positional needs down the road anyways.

If they wanted to take a centre at all costs (again, something that is idiotic given the time frames and malleability of positional strength changes involved) they could just stay at five and hope the two inferior talents in Grigorenko and Galchenyuk are available, or trade down for additional picks and select Faksa.

But if you're moving up to first overall the point would be to select Nail.
 
You don't pass up a potential franchise player because you want a center. You'd just end up kicking yourself. Grigorenko isn't going to step into the NHL and put up first line center points next year. Guys like Stamkos couldn't even do that. And Grigorenko is no Stamkos. On the other hand Yakupov just might be a Stamkos.

Exactly..

So then explain to me in what world would Edmonton prefer Ryan Murray or Ryan Murray+Schenn over Yakupov again?
 
It doesn't matter if Yakupov is not a centre. He is clearly the best available draft eligible talent. The Leafs lack of a top flight pivot should have absolutely no relevance to whether they draft him or not. You always go BPA at the draft. Employing the strategy you are advocating is wasteful because it intentionally passes on accumulating superior assets that could be used to directly address positional needs down the road anyways.

If they wanted to take a centre at all costs (again, something that is idiotic given the time frames and malleability of positional strength changes involved) they could just stay at five and hope the two inferior talents in Grigorenko and Galchenyuk are available, or trade down for additional picks and select Faksa.

But if you're moving up to first overall the point would be to select Nail.

Exactly..

So then explain to me in what world would Edmonton prefer Ryan Murray or Ryan Murray+Schenn over Yakupov again?

No one said anything about turning down an attractive group of collective young high upside assets that could simultaneously address a positional need. If the assets offered to Edmonton equal or exceed the perceived value that adding another high upside forward (and the associated need to find appropriate ice-time with other young stars present) it would be silly for the Oilers not to think long and hard about taking them.

Even now there are rumors Lowe is giving serious thought to potential trades, but at the same time is considering just drafting Yakupov and worrying about positional problems defensively later on.
 
Would you...... trade the 5th and Schenn for Taylor Hall??

I mean, maybe Edmonton says we need the BPA and draft Yakupov, then they see a glut of first line youth and trade the oft injured Hall.

Is Hall less of a franchise player than Yakupov??
 
Would you...... trade the 5th and Schenn for Taylor Hall??

I mean, maybe Edmonton says we need the BPA and draft Yakupov, then they see a glut of first line youth and trade the oft injured Hall.

Is Hall less of a franchise player than Yakupov??

Hell no
 
I would if his shelf life wasn't so short. His reckless ways are going to shorten his career pretty quick if he doesn't smarten up
 
It only works if Edmonton wants Murray and not yakupov.

Exactly. This is one of those situations were a team has an abundance of one thing but needs to fill some major holes in another area.

This place isn't a big draw for UFA's so the only way to do it is through the draft and trades. If you can fill a major need on the back end up picking up 2 assets for something you already have in your system you should really think about it.
 
Hall would be fantastic.

I think he's had a bit of bad luck the last year, not a true indicator on the player he is or will be.

If we have the chance to move up in the draft using Luke Schenn + 5th overall, we have to do it.
 
I would if his shelf life wasn't so short. His reckless ways are going to shorten his career pretty quick if he doesn't smarten up

Wow, almost word for word what the Edmonton scout I talked to, said about him. And guys, guys, guys, WE love Luke Schenn, the rest of the NHL has pretty well figured out that the city of Toronto and its impatient ways have seriously diluted the poor guys potential.

He still could be a phenomenal shut down dman, but now he needs guidance and mental rehabilitation after being festooned as the golden boy of Toronto, and the silly expectations that go with that.
 
That's like saying that maybe Edmonton thought Hall wasn't a franchise player two years ago and that they would have preferred Schenn+Gudbranson over him. I mean, it's possible that they're really dumb, but my point is that it's highly unlikely. The #1 pick is rarely traded for a reason.. especially when there's a clear #1 like there is this year.

Maybe you guys just think more highly of Schenn than I do. Stay at home d really don't hold much trade value. They are typically worth more to their team than they are to others and often get overrated by their own fans. In Schenns case, he's a stay at home d with no real skills at the moment. He hasn't proven anything yet, and his upside is a #4. If Edmonton trades the #1, maybe they won't get a lot, but they can do much better than Schenn.
 
Back
Top