• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I could see him increasing his offensive output with better wingers like Kessel & Lupul than what he works with on the 2nd & 3rd line in Pittsburgh...and the other things he brings out there would be an awesome compliment to those 2....and yeah, I'd love to add him here, but not at the assumed cost of him being a 70+ point centreman. When I say "increasing his offensive output", I mean averaging 30/60 over a stretch of years.

Trading for him, simply for what he is...yeah..awesome, would love to add him. Giving up a premium package under the assumption that he's a PPG centre waiting to break out...no, not so much.
 
They were just mentioning on CBC that Semin was pissed about his ice time this year and is likely looking to move on from Washington.

He could be a great Mogilny-esq buy low signing.
 
I've been on that bandwagon for a long time....he's elite skill. I wouldn't throw long term money at him, but I'd definitely pay him what he's worth on a 2-3 year deal.
 
I'm with Pronger84.

Staal would be right around 70 points playing with Kessel and Lupul, while providing much needed size and defensive ability from the C spot. And that would make him a top 10 centre in the league.

In terms of realistic C options, he'd be one of the best. We ain't getting the other Staal or Getzlaf, those guys aren't traded. Maybe we can get an older guy like Marleau or Thornton.
 
#5 and Schenn for #1 (Take Yakupov)

MacArthur, #1 Pick (2013) for J Staal

Colborne + Connolly for R Luongo



J. Lupul J Staal P Kessel
N Kulemin M Grabovski N Yakupov
N Kadri T Bozak M Frattin
M Brown D Steckel D'Amigo
(M Lombardi C Armstrong)

J Gardiner D Phaneuf
LM Liles C Gunnarsson
C Franson K Holzer
(M Komisarek)

R Luongo
J Reimer
(B Scrivens)​
 
Sure Semin has elite skill but he's a very selfish player, also he's small and not physical he would not fit in well here under Caryle's structured crash and bang system.

If anything Burke will be looking for big bodied guys who play with a snarl and aren't allergic to playing defense, Semin is the polar opposite of what Burke is looking for in a player.
 
Semin isn't small. At 6'2 210 he'd be one of the Leafs biggest forwards, and definitely their biggest top 6 forward. If Selanne can fit into Carlyle's system, so can Semin.

I agree Burke won't go after him, but he should.
 
Semin isn't small. At 6'2 210 he'd be one of the Leafs biggest forwards, and definitely their biggest top 6 forward. If Selanne can fit into Carlyle's system, so can Semin.

I agree Burke won't go after him, but he should.

We already have a "Selanne" in the system and his name is Kessel. The thing is the leafs are skilled they were one of the better goal scoring teams last season but as usual they can't seem to keep them out, adding Semin doesn't fix the issues on this team.
 
Well what does "fix the issues" mean? Sure adding a dynamic offensive player isn't the number one need this team has, but that doesn't mean that they don't need one either. Especially one with size. Adding Semin would make this team a ton better. No question about it.

I don't think you can say the Leafs have too many "Selannes." Get all the high end skill you can. Why would you pass up an opportunity because you already have one good player?
 
Well what does "fix the issues" mean? Sure adding a dynamic offensive player isn't the number one need this team has, but that doesn't mean that they don't need one either. Adding Semin would make this team a ton better. No question about it.

"Fixing the issues" means bringing in players that can fit into Carlyle's system ie big bodied fast forechecking players, guys like Semin would have be an amazing asset under Wilsons' run and gun style but were a year removed from that. Sure if we add Semin it'll add 25-30 goals but it still doesn't fix our goaltending problems or are defensive system (which btw will improve under Carlyle's reign).
 
"Fixing the issues" means bringing in players that can fit into Carlyle's system ie big bodied fast forechecking players, guys like Semin would have be an amazing asset under Wilsons' run and gun style but were a year removed from that. Sure if we add Semin it'll add 25-30 goals but it still doesn't fix our goaltending problems or are defensive system (which btw will improve under Carlyle's reign).

Getting Semin doesn't mean you have to forgo getting a goalie, or filling other holes. I just can't buy the argument that the Leafs have too may high skill forwards, so they shouldn't be looking to add more. Thats a load of crap. This was the 5th worst team in the league last year. They have one. Maybe two if Lupul can repeat last year and stay healthy.
 
Carlyle had a healthy mix of skill vs size on his duck teams, which is hopefully what the leafs can back to sooner rather then later. Bottom line is I just don't see Semin fitting into the leafs, if I'm wrong and it happens I'll eat a lot of crow.
 
Getting Semin doesn't mean you have to forgo getting a goalie, or filling other holes.

I know but at the same token Semin will command a large salary, and as it stands right now we don't have much wiggle room. I'd rather the resources be used to fix our holes which are goaltending, 1A centre, 3rd line checking centre.
 
Back
Top