• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

San Jose has zero prospect-wise. Probably the worst group in the entire league by a fair margin. The Leafs could easily outbid any Sharks offer.
 
Shore up the goaltending situation and the chance gets even better. Thats a huge question mark that any FA who is consdiering coming here will want an answer to.
 
They can get both.

1. Are we even on Nash's list? That is a big factor into considering whether or not we can get him

2. If we are on his list (if at this point), what is the asking price this go round? If it's anything like what it was rumoured to be last trade deadline day then a big fat no thanks. Nash while he's a good player he's nowhere near an elite one, his best season was 71 points several years ago and the rest in the 50's and 60's, he's even a shade below Eric Staal level IMO.

3. Biggest priority is a goaltender and then a top flight centre. If there is any cap space and assets left after filling those two holes then go after Nash, but not right now.
 
1. Are we even on Nash's list? That is a big factor into considering whether or not we can get him.

According to every single legitimate source...yes we are.

2. If we are on his list (if at this point), what is the asking price this go round? If it's anything like what it was rumoured to be last trade deadline day then a big fat no thanks. Nash while he's a good player he's nowhere near an elite one, his best season was 71 points several years ago and the rest in the 50's and 60's, he's even a shade below Eric Staal level IMO.

I know Nash makes a lot of money, but Nash is only one of a handful of players with 5 straight 30+ goal seasons. Even in a bad season, he's a lock for 30 goals. I'm willing to overpay for that consistency. Plus, he's exactly the type of big, skilled player the Leafs lack on their top 2 lines.

As for the asking price, Columbus needs to shoot for the moon, but that doesn't mean they will get it.

3. Biggest priority is a goaltender and then a top flight centre. If there is any cap space and assets left after filling those two holes then go after Nash, but not right now.

The Leafs need to add another 1st liner and a goaltender -- it's not an either or situation.

Top flight centres don't grow on trees, so you can't wait for one to become available and ignore all other 1st line possibilities. Because then we would be rebuilding until 2020.
 
1. Are we even on Nash's list? That is a big factor into considering whether or not we can get him

Yes, we are.

2. If we are on his list (if at this point), what is the asking price this go round? If it's anything like what it was rumoured to be last trade deadline day then a big fat no thanks. Nash while he's a good player he's nowhere near an elite one, his best season was 71 points several years ago and the rest in the 50's and 60's, he's even a shade below Eric Staal level IMO.

I'm pretty shocked that the Rangers offer around the deadline was declined to be honest. That looked pretty damn good to me. Nash's best season was 79 points too, not 71 (just a correction there). He's overrated, but he's still one of the best scoring wingers in the game.

3. Biggest priority is a goaltender and then a top flight centre. If there is any cap space and assets left after filling those two holes then go after Nash, but not right now.

I don't think there's necessarily a laundry list determining the order in which the team needs to do things. Simply stock up top flight or elite talent anywhere you can. If it's available for a reasonable price get it, regardless of positional needs.
 
What was the Ranger's rumoured offer? The only thing I remember from the deadline was the Rangers turning down Columbus' "demand" for the Rangers to give up a roster blueliner (which i assume meant Staal or Del Zotto)
 
No surprise NYR rejected that deal.

Columbus isnt going to get as good a deal as they had initially thought.
 
If I remember correctly the rumour was NY offered Dubinsky, Miller, Thomas, Erixon and a 1st.

They weren't willing to give up McDonaugh, Del Zotto, Stepan or Kreider.
 
If I remember correctly the rumour was NY offered Dubinsky, Miller, Thomas, Erixon and a 1st.

They weren't willing to give up McDonaugh, Del Zotto, Stepan or Kreider.

Yeah, I remember them taking just about all of their best assets off of the table entirely...and publicly.
 
If you can get Nash without giving up Kadri, Gardiner or #5 then by all means get him.

Well then odds are it isn't happening because Columbus would ask for a package like that, to get value you have to give up similar value. Columbus badly needs a mobile puck moving top pairing defencmen, they could also use a NHL ready potential 2nd liner in Kadri and that #5 pick would be appealing to them because it would give them two top 5 picks in this year's draft.

It's a fair deal no doubt about it, but it shouldnt be done because it doesn't really address our needs for a goalie or top centre. If a guy like Spezza (just an example) was available and Ottawa wanted that package I'd pull the trigger in a nano second but not for Nash.
 
If Columbus holds out for a package like Kadri, Gardiner and a top 5 pick then they are keeping Nash, because no team was willing to even give up one player that good.
 
San Jose has zero prospect-wise. Probably the worst group in the entire league by a fair margin. The Leafs could easily outbid any Sharks offer.
Not really. If the Sharks decided that with Joe Thornton, Patrick Marleau (both of whom have NMC's) and Logan Couture already on the roster and all capable of playing center, that Joe Pavelski (who doesn't have any kind of NTC or NMC) was expendable, the Leafs wouldn't really have any answer for a package including him. Ryane Clowe would be another guy they could potentially offer, though admittedly he wouldn't be as attractive to Columbus, as he's a UFA at the end of next season. The only NHL roster forwards that we could reasonably offer up in comparison would be Kulemin (who has completely tanked his trade value) and MacArthur, who 2010/11 aside isn't in Pavelski's stratosphere.

Anyways, it'll be interesting to see how it shakes out. I'm still hopeful that he doesn't end up here, so if he ended up with the Sharks, that'd be A-okay with me.
 
Pavelski is turning 28 and is only signed for 2 more years. I highly doubt that is what Columbus is looking for in return for Nash. Actually we know for a fact it isn't. They want a handful of good prospects.
 
Last edited:
Pavelski is turning 28 and is only signed for 2 more years. I highly doubt that is what Columbus is looking for in return for Nash. Actually we know for a fact it isn't. They want a handful of good prospects.

that may be but he's pretty good and will be for a while yet.

with that said, i think that if san jose is serious about nash they put couture in play. and if they do that then it will be difficult to best them.
 
Back
Top