• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

What's harder to find though? A 2nd pairing dman or a 2nd line PF?

I'd take Hartnell over Martin for example.

Hartnell: 1.3PPG in his draft year
Brown: 1.3PPG in his draft year

These were talented players in the minors though. Seems like you'd be just hoping for the absolute best case scenario.
 
Hartnell is really borderline 1st line though. He only put up 1st line-ish numbers this year.

He's typically been a 50-60 point guy.

I'd rather have Scott Hartnell from this season over Paul Martin. But I would rather have a typical Martin than a second-line PF type. They tend to be incredibly overrated.

There hasn't been a legitimate monster PF franchise type since Lindros and Leclair in the 1990s, and then Bertuzzi for two seasons in 2002 and 2003.
 
Hartnell: 1.3PPG in his draft year
Brown: 1.3PPG in his draft year

These were talented players in the minors though. Seems like you'd be just hoping for the absolute best case scenario.

It's hard to compare him with these guys because he played in the USHL.

It's all about potential with Biggs right now. But he seems like he's got a decent skillset -- skating along with a decent shot and we all know he isn't scared to play in the tough areas.
 
It's hard to compare him with these guys because he played in the USHL.

Sure, but we know 1.3PPG+ in your draft year is terrific production. If you could show me that you think Biggs' numbers in the USHL and as a college were "terrific" production or even "good" production for those respective leagues, I might feel better about his chances of ending up like a Brown type player.
 
Sure, but we know 1.3PPG+ in your draft year is terrific production. If you could show me that you think Biggs' numbers in the USHL and as a college were "terrific" production or even "good" production for those respective leagues, I might feel better about his chances of ending up like a Brown type player.

At this point, compared with a lot of other USHL NHLers, his numbers don't look too impressive from an offensive potential standpoint.

But with PF's, you never know.

It's all about position scarcity, and there aren't many PF's in the league, so I don't mind taking these type of chances sometimes. You can always sign a 2nd liner or 2nd pairing dman in free agency. Go big or go home.
 
I didn't agree with the Biggs pick at the time. I still don't. Seems like a classic case of making a "safe" pick and getting a guy who probably stands a pretty decent chance of playing on an NHL third line some day, over someone with higher potential (like the players HL was advocating at the time). And that's not really the kind of pick I like to see my team making in the first round. But that being said, we still don't really have much idea what we actually have with him. His NCAA numbers at first brush don't look that impressive, but he was one of the youngest players on that team. There were four 23 year-olds, seven 22 year-olds, three 21 year-olds, five 20 year-olds and only three 19 year olds, and two 18 year-olds (of which Biggs was one) on Miami this year.

So you're in tough already when 92% of your own team is older than you and you're battling them for ice-time, and then most of the guys you're playing against are older than you as well. And while the other 18 year-old on the team may have outscored him, he's a 5'8", 140lb midget, and those kind of players seem to flourish in the NCAA before fizzling out as pros. So, we'll have to see what he does in the OHL this year to really know what he brings to the table. If he's anything less than comfortably above a PPG pace from wire to wire, then it's probably safe to say that our chances of getting an impact offensive player out of that 1st round pick are slim to none. If he does dominate offensively, then there still may be hope.
 
At this point, compared with a lot of other USHL NHLers, his numbers don't look too impressive from an offensive potential standpoint.

But with PF's, you never know.

It's all about position scarcity, and there aren't many PF's in the league, so I don't mind taking these type of chances sometimes. You can always sign a 2nd liner or 2nd pairing dman in free agency. Go big or go home.

My argument wasn't really against taking players that project as power forwards though - it's about Biggs specifically and how likely I think the chances are that a guy who can't produce at a lower level can put it together at the NHL level.
 
My argument wasn't really against taking players that project as power forwards though - it's about Biggs specifically and how likely I think the chances are that a guy who can't produce at a lower level can put it together at the NHL level.

The thing is, PF types with impressive numbers in junior, are typically taken a lot higher than Biggs.

Like the two guys you referenced, Dustin Brown went 13th overall and Hartnell 6th for example.
 
Almost every player of this type in the league - Brown, Hartnell, Clowe, Malone, Backes, etc. - had good to great production all the way up. Biggs doesn't. You're free to hope he turns out to be as effective as any of these players but I find it unlikely. I'd love to be wrong.
 
Malone and Backes actually good comparables because they played in the USHL.

Draft Year:
Backes: 57 gms, 28 gls, 69 pts (82 gms, 40 gls, 99 pts)
Malone: 51 gms, 14 gls, 36 pts (82 gms, 23 gls, 58 pts)
Biggs: 20 gms, 7 gls, 11 pts (82 gms, 29 gls, 45 pts)




Backes was REALLY undervalued. Another case where if scouts actually looked at the numbers, he would have went a lot higher than late 2nd round. Malone's numbers weren't all that impressive though.
 
But that's what I mean, how much do these USHL numbers mean?

Malone's scoring at the same level in the NHL as he did in the USHL.

A lot easier to make judgements/predictions on Canadian junior hockey players imo than Americans/Euro's.
 
Post-Draft Year - Freshman Season:
Backes: 39gms, 16gls, 37pts (82gms 34gls 78pts)
Malone: 38gms, 9gls, 30pts (82gms 19gls 65pts)
Biggs: 37gms, 9gls, 17pts (82gms 20gls 38pts)

I don't think Biggs has done anything to make me reconsider my feelings on his offensive upside. If he dominates the OHL next season, I'll re-evaluate then.
 
Even if dominates the OHL, I don't know how much that will tell us. He will be playing against skinny kids.

We need to see him in the AHL against men with some talent.
 
It would concern me if he doesn't.

Anyways, back to my original point - if they pass up Grigorenko at 5, I'll be ticked.
 
Back
Top