• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

You don't need to argue with a small sample size regarding Thomas.

He posted one of the best seasons ever by a goalie two years ago.

He posted 920+ in both the reg season and playoffs this past season.

He's better than Luongo based on the above.

He suffered a serious decline in quality during the course of the season, and a 7 game playoff sample suggests that maybe it wasn't age related.

The last reasonable sample size we have to compare the two though, suggests that he's not the same goalie who posted one of the best seasons ever.

You're ignoring the obvious potential for his rapid decline. All in an extension of an already really silly anti-luongo argument that has spanned from playing Reimer & Scrivens over him, to playing "3 cheap goalies because it's unlikely all 3 will suck at the same time" and other knee slappers.
 
Thomas didn't have a bad 2nd half -- he had ONE bad month. That's it.

Oct: 929 SV%
Nov: 941 SV%
Dec: 946 SV%
Jan: 913 SV%
Feb: 919 SV%
Mar: 884 SV%
Apr: 935 SV%
Playoffs: 923 SV%
 
Thomas is an incredible goalie. You can't ignore all he's done because of a few weeks where his numbers dropped.

Why doesn't Burke ask permission to talk to him and bribe him with money? You can bet Tim not getting a contract extension has a little to do with him not playing.
 
Thomas didn't have a bad 2nd half -- he had ONE bad month. That's it.

Oct: 929 SV%
Nov: 941 SV%
Dec: 946 SV%
Jan: 913 SV%
Feb: 919 SV%
Mar: 884 SV%
Apr: 935 SV%
Playoffs: 923 SV%

Jan + Feb = 18 games
March = 15 games

With that said though, no...he had a poor 2nd half of the season.

Games under .900

Before Jan 1 - 4 of 24
After Jan 1 - 18 of 36

Look at his game log...he was horrible for most of the 2nd half, saved by being spectacular in handful of games.

For example...just to take the 2 months you claim he was "good in" during the 2nd half.

January - 8 GP - 4 of 8 games under .890...3 of them under .870
February - 10 GP 5 of 10 games .900 or lower.

Saved by a handful of great performances...but consistently pretty poor in both months.
 
Thomas is an incredible goalie. You can't ignore all he's done because of a few weeks where his numbers dropped.

Why doesn't Burke ask permission to talk to him and bribe him with money? You can bet Tim not getting a contract extension has a little to do with him not playing.


At 38 years old, you ignore a few months at your own peril. Especially when you're so willing to throw a contract extension at him that

1) He's clearly shown no qualms about not honouring
2) Being +35, we would have hanging on our cap hit should captain lunatic decide to not play

If he was a pure stand up guy and true professional...I would be more apt to ignore the troubling 2nd half trend.
 
I really think this whole deal with Thomas is because his NTC is expiring, and rather than be traded, he would just not play instead.

Either way, it still shows a total lack of commitment to do what he signed on to do. Why would/should we even have an inkling of interest in trying to acquire Thomas at this point in his career?
 
You can twist the numbers all you want -- but the reality is, he had one really poor month which distorted his overall second half SV%, which makes the number completely misleading. Especially considering he turned it back on in April leading into the playoffs when he almost matched Holtby save for save.
 
You can twist the numbers all you want -- but the reality is, he had one really poor month which distorted his overall second half SV%, which makes the number completely misleading. Especially considering he turned it back on in April leading into the playoffs when he almost matched Holtby save for save.

heh...you claim I'm "twisting the numbers", but then use 2 games in April as proof that he "turned it back on"

Hirarious.
 
Listening to crazy craig button on the radio today and he felt that Nash to the Rangers is what's going to happen and he mentioned that Pittsburgh wants help now on the blue line... He then stated that they will want Faulk from Carolina, but Rutherford would say no and offer up their top prospect. (name slips me now) Pittsburgh won't want it cuz they want something now..... So here is my inference and gut feeling about how it will all work out.

Nash to the Rangers
The Oilers will draft Yakupov
Luongo will be a leaf for Reimer, Komisarek and a late pick
The leafs will surprise everyone and will go for Jordan Staal and it will be the best hockey deal for both teams in which Pitt needs a young defenseman who can play.. Jordan Staal for Schenn and Bozak.

Luongo is a compromise with Nonis... Staal is the Burke pick.
 
After January 1, Tim Thomas turned in a poor individual performance in 50% of the games he played in. Before Jan 1, he turned in a poor individual performance according to SV% in 16.5% of the games he played in.

It wasn't just one really bad month skewing his numbers. Your analysis of the statistics here is shit, end of story.

Worst part is...I'm not even suggesting that he'd be a bad addition in theory. He just wouldn't be as good an addition as Luongo...and that's even if he wasn't ****ing crazy.
 
Listening to crazy craig button on the radio today and he felt that Nash to the Rangers is what's going to happen and he mentioned that Pittsburgh wants help now on the blue line... He then stated that they will want Faulk from Carolina, but Rutherford would say no and offer up their top prospect. (name slips me now) Pittsburgh won't want it cuz they want something now..... So here is my inference and gut feeling about how it will all work out.

Nash to the Rangers
The Oilers will draft Yakupov
Luongo will be a leaf for Reimer, Komisarek and a late pick
The leafs will surprise everyone and will go for Jordan Staal and it will be the best hockey deal for both teams in which Pitt needs a young defenseman who can play.. Jordan Staal for Schenn and Bozak.

Luongo is a compromise with Nonis... Staal is the Burke pick.

Craig Button is Nucking Futs, but I'd be okay with this. Just keep the pick and sign Schultz.
 
Thomas posted a SV% above 913 in EVERY MONTH including the playoffs but 1, and the conclusion is, he sucked in the second half. And I'm the one distorting the numbers?

Not only is Thomas one of the best reg season goalies, he's clutch in the playoffs as well. He's still better than Luongo.
 
Thomas posted a SV% above 913 in EVERY MONTH including the playoffs but 1, and the conclusion is, he sucked in the second half. And I'm the one distorting the numbers?

Not only is Thomas one of the best reg season goalies, he's clutch in the playoffs as well. He's still better than Luongo.

I'm adding context to the small sample size game you're playing, nothing more. Thomas was poor in the 2nd half.
 
Back
Top