leafman101
Well-known member
You trade Kuly for Stewart because Stewart is better.
You trade Kuly for Stewart because Stewart is better.
Gunnarsson is the Leafs best defensive player by most metrics.
I think it's equally short-sighted to just be putting him into deals when he likely has more value to the team than he would in a prospective trade. And I doubt with all of the blue-line talent in St. Louis they would be interested in him anyways.
Kulemin for Stewart is a pure hockey deal that provides both players with a welcome change of scenery following disappointing seasons, and at the same time doesn't deplete size from St. Louis. Moreover, it gives the Leafs more consistent offensive talent, a more abrasive combative forward, and a home-town product to boot.
Kulemin doesn't need a change of scenery after one down season. He needs patience.
Just as much chance that Kulemin bounces back to 30 goals and Stewart doesn't than vice versa.
I really don't like any of your D outside Gardiner. Phaneuf puts up numbers but I never liked the guy. Gunnarsson is a third pairing guy anyway.
Valid Points.
Gunnarson is a good defender, but you have to give to get. I would much rather have Kulemin AND Stewart in our lineup than Gunnarson and Stewart. Finding a guy like Stewart is alot harder than finding a Gunnarson. I can comfortably say (from my Internet-GM Chair) that we can find a replacement for Gunnarson through FA or internally. Not so much Stewart.
I really don't like any of your D outside Gardiner. Phaneuf puts up numbers but I never liked the guy. Gunnarsson is a third pairing guy anyway.
Gunnarsson would be Montreal's best defenceman GA-wise.
Bullshit. You guys really underestimate Gorges who just lead the league in blocked shots and was a +14 for the 15th place squad. Gunny? -9.
Bullshit. You guys really underestimate Gorges who just lead the league in blocked shots and was a +14 for the 15th place squad. Gunny? -9.
You underestimate how good/bad good/bad goaltenders can make defensemen look.