• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Gunnarsson is the Leafs best defensive player by most metrics.

I think it's equally short-sighted to just be putting him into deals when he likely has more value to the team than he would in a prospective trade. And I doubt with all of the blue-line talent in St. Louis they would be interested in him anyways.

Kulemin for Stewart is a pure hockey deal that provides both players with a welcome change of scenery following disappointing seasons, and at the same time doesn't deplete size from St. Louis. Moreover, it gives the Leafs more consistent offensive talent, a more abrasive combative forward, and a home-town product to boot.

Kulemin doesn't need a change of scenery after one down season. He needs patience.

Just as much chance that Kulemin bounces back to 30 goals and Stewart doesn't than vice versa.
 
Valid Points.

Gunnarson is a good defender, but you have to give to get. I would much rather have Kulemin AND Stewart in our lineup than Gunnarson and Stewart. Finding a guy like Stewart is alot harder than finding a Gunnarson. I can comfortably say (from my Internet-GM Chair) that we can find a replacement for Gunnarson through FA or internally. Not so much Stewart.
 
This team is worse with Kulemin and Stewart than it is with Kulemin/Stewart and Gunnar.

He was arguably our best defenseman last year.
 
I really don't like any of your D outside Gardiner. Phaneuf puts up numbers but I never liked the guy. Gunnarsson is a third pairing guy anyway.
 
Kulemin doesn't need a change of scenery after one down season. He needs patience.

Just as much chance that Kulemin bounces back to 30 goals and Stewart doesn't than vice versa.

Stewart already has two 28 goal seasons, a 64 point season, and a 53 point season.

He's got a more established track record than Kulemin, is a year younger, and had over twice as many goals last season in a bad year.
 
Valid Points.

Gunnarson is a good defender, but you have to give to get. I would much rather have Kulemin AND Stewart in our lineup than Gunnarson and Stewart. Finding a guy like Stewart is alot harder than finding a Gunnarson. I can comfortably say (from my Internet-GM Chair) that we can find a replacement for Gunnarson through FA or internally. Not so much Stewart.

It would make our forward group much harder to play against but i'd worry about our D a bit cause Gunnar is very solid. Getting young/inexperienced guys to replace him could be a problem and it's not that easy to just trade for a player like him.
 
And my meaning was Gunny would be a third pair guy on any serious contender. I stick by that... for now.
 
Bullshit. You guys really underestimate Gorges who just lead the league in blocked shots and was a +14 for the 15th place squad. Gunny? -9.

Put Gorges on our roster last year and you would see how that +/- would drastically change
 
Back
Top