• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

the thing is that he was good enough last year, they were just too cautious with schenn (who was awful) and kept trotting out komisarek (who is horrible).

losing him would definitely be a loss.
 
yeah for some reason I thought we had more depth on d. losing franson would be bad, but he's probably just waiting it out right now to see if we acquire any more d. can't say i blame him.
 
Franson is only twenty five years old by the start of next season and has been an offensive producer at every level. It would be silly to give up on such a young talented defenceman.
 
I've always liked Franson since he got here, but maybe his over-confidence and over-assessment of where he stands in the depth chart.

He saw himself as a top 4, which he isn't. He did get shafted because of the Schenn and Komi situations, but after December he did get the icetime he deserved, and did ok with it. He didn't do great, but he did ok. He finished the season on 34 pts pace playing very limited minutes, and was +3 through 38 games, in a very difficult stretch too where the teams gave up more goals than they scored.

With Schenn gone, and we failed to get Schultz, Franson's got every opportunity to move up in depth chart and icetime. He does have a lot of raw talent - he is a pretty decent skater, he has good vision, can move the puck up ice, he has a pretty good shot and what I like him the most is he plays with a bit of mean streak and can play physical.

Whether he manages to earn that icetime from Carlyle is all up to him, but if he's smart enough he's gotta like his chances this season - Schenn gone, Carlyle not exactly in love with Komi, and no immediate competition among the prospects - Holzer can at most fill a bottom unit role, none of Percy or O'Reiley or those guys are ready.

If he really believes he is the player he is, sign a 1 yr deal and prove himself this season, then the sky is the limit comes next summer for contract renewal.
 
And looking at who else is out there, I really don't think Leafs fans should be checking the UFA tracker every hour or so ...

We're not even in on either the Suter or Parise sweepstakes. Burke already pulled himself out from the teams bidding for Nash's service, and the Luongo situation can drag on for a LOOONG time... plus, it sounds like he'll be Florida bound too.

The only UFA which Burke should be interested in is Doan, but Doan isn't really an impact player anymore, and though he's a serviceable 3rd liner and a great veteran, he's also like 37 and isn't signing anywhere until the Phoenix situation clears up a bit on the 8th.

Burke can sure pull a rabbit out of the hat and make a blockbuster trade to surprise us all ... but chances are this is 90% the lineup we're gonna have on opening night.
 
Nahh even if Burke despises Franson he will try to trade him during the season, because there aren't too many options better than Franson for less $$ out there, and though we still have prospect depths at D, there isn't a lineup to get into the top 6 on opening night:

Phaneuf
Liles
Gunnarson
Gardiner
Franson
Holzer
Komi

That's how I'd rank out d-men. There're really only 7 serviceable NHL defenseman, including Holzer who will be a NHL rookie.
 
I'd like to see Franson stick with us for awhile longer. When he first got here i didn't like the fact he barely ever used his body and was kinda sloppy defensively. With more ice time he got better and started really showing his potential. Good at moving the puck up the ice and i love the quick shots from the point. Little better on the defensive end and i think he can be very effective for us.
 
better not be...for his sake and ours.
You mean the 1st part of 2nd part of my statement? LOL

To be fair, I think Burke's done an EXCELLENT job with almost all the trades he's made. It's the UFA signings that has been disastrous for him.

Phaneuf + Aulie, he won in a landslide considering NONE of the players he traded even makes an impact for Calgary (not a positive impact anyways)

Kessel trade is controversial, but you can't deny Kessel's offensive contribution when he's among the league's scoring leaders ... these players don't grow on trees, and he's still so young.

He also landed Gardiner with Beauchemin trade.

Colborne's still developing, but Burke did get excellent value out of Kaberle, who was turning UFA and despite Boston winning the cup he didn't play a big role in that run.

And JVR for Schenn trade is a fair trade ... which most Leafs fans also love.

And even the little trades (Ashton, Franson, etc) he did alright in most of them.

So I'm quite comfortable letting Burke do all the wheeling and dealing.

And I'm actually HAPPY we've only signed 1 UFA thus far ...
 
I'm not sold on Holzer as a solution yet either. Trading Franson would be a very, very bad idea.
Call me crazy, but I think Burke should be all in on the Suter signing. He keeps saying D isn't his priority, but there's just no UFA forwards that are worth spending the big bucks on out there.

If we get Suter, all of a sudden you can easily move 1 or 2 of Gunnarson, Liles, Franson ... or, even Gardiner isn't an untouchable anymore at the right price.

It's not to say Suter would come to TO, but Burke should be a lot more aggressive on Suter IMO ... and play the "Team USA" card more often.
 
You mean the 1st part of 2nd part of my statement? LOL

To be fair, I think Burke's done an EXCELLENT job with almost all the trades he's made. It's the UFA signings that has been disastrous for him.

Phaneuf + Aulie, he won in a landslide considering NONE of the players he traded even makes an impact for Calgary (not a positive impact anyways)

Kessel trade is controversial, but you can't deny Kessel's offensive contribution when he's among the league's scoring leaders ... these players don't grow on trees, and he's still so young.

He also landed Gardiner with Beauchemin trade.

Colborne's still developing, but Burke did get excellent value out of Kaberle, who was turning UFA and despite Boston winning the cup he didn't play a big role in that run.

And JVR for Schenn trade is a fair trade ... which most Leafs fans also love.

And even the little trades (Ashton, Franson, etc) he did alright in most of them.

So I'm quite comfortable letting Burke do all the wheeling and dealing.

And I'm actually HAPPY we've only signed 1 UFA thus far ...
I don't think you can isolate a GM's moves into drafting, trades and signings. Burke has made great trades, but has made absolutely horrible UFA signings that have almost completely nullified his good moves. Drafting has been good, but not great.

Overall though, he simply hasn't put a competitive team on the ice. Worse yet, he hasn't even put a team on the ice that fits his idea of "truculence and belligerence". The Leafs simply aren't a very good team overall. Add to that to the fact that they aren't even a hard team to play against, and you have to wonder what the hell Burke has been doing over the past few years.

Sure full cupboards are nice, but if those players don't translate into contributing NHL'ers (see: Kadri) then what is the point?
 
Call me crazy, but I think Burke should be all in on the Suter signing. He keeps saying D isn't his priority, but there's just no UFA forwards that are worth spending the big bucks on out there.

If we get Suter, all of a sudden you can easily move 1 or 2 of Gunnarson, Liles, Franson ... or, even Gardiner isn't an untouchable anymore at the right price.

It's not to say Suter would come to TO, but Burke should be a lot more aggressive on Suter IMO ... and play the "Team USA" card more often.

he might not be willing to pay the 12 year card or the 100M card

and really..after that...no other card matters.
 
I think many amateur scouting and drafting sources have confirmed the Leafs have drafted pretty well under Burke. They have constantly 're-drafted' the players after a few years of development, and compare them to their actual draft position, then rate the teams based on how well they draft, and the Leafs have always been in the top 10 for drafting well.

Your point on Kadri is valid, but players also take time to develop. Kadri was drafted in 2009, and while top picks like Tavares, Duchene and Kane have established themeselves as NHLers already, many others are still finding their way through the development program, including Glennie, Larsson, Ellis, or even the highly touted Ryan Ellis. And you'd know that cos Cowen played in his rookie season last year - not necessarily because he's ready, but because Ottawa's a young rebuilding team without a lot of depth on D.

I also read another article on the Globe (by Mirtle? can't remember now) which looked at the 'defensemen take longer to develop' concept and find that these days it's actually the forwards that take longer to develop these days. More and more there are 'late boomers' among forwards, while it's not uncommon for defensemen to comfortably play in the league at 22, 23. They credit this to the structured, organized plays of the NHL for defensemen that make it easier for them to adjust, while forwards have to learn to find that balance between being creative enough to get through checks and create offense, and also taking care of their own defensive responsibilities so they don't get sent down.

Anyways, I think it's too early to make the call on Kadri, or the draft class of 2009 since it's only been 3 yrs. I do acknowledge this is a make or break year for Kadri.

As for Burke hasn't put a competitive team on the ice - no question about that, you can't deny when you haven't been close to a playoff berth all these years. But the argument is had he been able to address ONE position (and most likely with just ONE player) this team would have been competitive for at least half the times Burke's been here. His failure to do so, is no excuse, but it also shouldn't overshadown the work he's done otherwise in rebuilding this team.

He needs to plug that hole, no question about that, and I'm not confident he will before Oct 14.
 
he might not be willing to pay the 12 year card or the 100M card

and really..after that...no other card matters.
And that's dumb.

Think about this - Burke's publicly said Weber is the first guy he would pick if he can pick ANYONE in the league to build the team around.

Weber is turning UFA next season. If you have Suter, your chance of getting Weber just got THAT much better.

And if you have a top 3 of Weber, Suter and Phaneuf, who cares who you have in the bottom 3? And these 3 guys are still very much in their prime, got YEARS of quality service left in them.

You can trade Gardiner, Gunnarson, Liles ... for Forwards.

Judging from the immense interest in Gardiner, all of a sudden addressing the #1 C position isn't a pipe dream anymore.

Sometimes the thing with UFA is kindda like drafting ... you go for the best elite talent, and you throw all the $$ you can at it ... everything else will take care of itself.
 
Back
Top