I think many amateur scouting and drafting sources have confirmed the Leafs have drafted pretty well under Burke. They have constantly 're-drafted' the players after a few years of development, and compare them to their actual draft position, then rate the teams based on how well they draft, and the Leafs have always been in the top 10 for drafting well.
Your point on Kadri is valid, but players also take time to develop. Kadri was drafted in 2009, and while top picks like Tavares, Duchene and Kane have established themeselves as NHLers already, many others are still finding their way through the development program, including Glennie, Larsson, Ellis, or even the highly touted Ryan Ellis. And you'd know that cos Cowen played in his rookie season last year - not necessarily because he's ready, but because Ottawa's a young rebuilding team without a lot of depth on D.
I also read another article on the Globe (by Mirtle? can't remember now) which looked at the 'defensemen take longer to develop' concept and find that these days it's actually the forwards that take longer to develop these days. More and more there are 'late boomers' among forwards, while it's not uncommon for defensemen to comfortably play in the league at 22, 23. They credit this to the structured, organized plays of the NHL for defensemen that make it easier for them to adjust, while forwards have to learn to find that balance between being creative enough to get through checks and create offense, and also taking care of their own defensive responsibilities so they don't get sent down.
Anyways, I think it's too early to make the call on Kadri, or the draft class of 2009 since it's only been 3 yrs. I do acknowledge this is a make or break year for Kadri.
As for Burke hasn't put a competitive team on the ice - no question about that, you can't deny when you haven't been close to a playoff berth all these years. But the argument is had he been able to address ONE position (and most likely with just ONE player) this team would have been competitive for at least half the times Burke's been here. His failure to do so, is no excuse, but it also shouldn't overshadown the work he's done otherwise in rebuilding this team.
He needs to plug that hole, no question about that, and I'm not confident he will before Oct 14.