• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Come on. Your reply was meaningless.

Some stats are good sometimes, but not good other times?

Giveaway statistics are rarely good because the best players normally rank at the top of the lists. Why? Because they log the most ice-time. Your reply was projection, pure and simple.
 
You're being deliberately obtuse...some advanced statistical measures are far more useful in evaluating players than other, more basic, subjective ones.

But you know this.

He knows exactly what he's doing and he insists on sticking his head in the sand. It's being difficult for the sake of it without any reference to rationality.
 
John Mitchell was very good defensively last year. His GA/60 and CORSI rating were top notch. But you won't hear anything about him because he doesn't throw huge open ice hits or throw is body into a ton of shots which gets you the press. There's too much bias when evaluating a players defensive ability.

The Avs signed a cheaper and better player in John Mitchell to replace the "intangible" filled Jay McClement. That's a good hockey decision. Decisions Burke hasn't been making in Free Agency.
 
I saw a great post against using CORSI recently:

I have had a lot of battles with the pro-corsi crowd with regards to the merits of using Corsi as a player evaluation tool. I still get people dismissing my goal based analysis (which seems really strange since goals are what matters in hockey) so I figured I should summarize my position in one easy to understand post. So, with that, here are 10 significant reasons why I don’t like to use a corsi based player analysis.

1. Look at the list of players with the top on-ice shooting percentage over the past 5 seasons and compare it to the list of players with the top corsi for per 20 minutes of ice time and you’ll find that the shooting percentage list is far more representative of top offensive players than the top corsi for list.

2. Shooting percentage is a talent and is sustainable and three year shooting percentage is as good a predictor of the following 2 seasons goal scoring rates as 3 year fenwick rates and 3 year goal rates are a far better predictor.

r^2
2007-10 FF20 vs 2010-12 GF20 0.253
2007-10 SH% vs 2010-12 GF20 0.244
2007-10 GF20 vs 2010-12 GF20 0.363
3. I have even shown that one year GF20 is on average as good a predictor of the following seasons GF20 as FF20 is as a predictor of the following seasons FF20 so with even just one full season of data goal rates are as good a metric of offensive talent as fenwick rate is. Only when the sample size is less than one season (and for almost all NHL regulars we have at least a seasons worth of data) is fenwick rate a better metric for evaluating offensive talent.

4. Although difficult to identify, I believe I have shown players can suppress opposition shooting percentage.

5. Zone starts affect shots/corsi/fenwick stats significantly more than they affect goal stats thus the non-adjusted shot/corsi/fenwick data are less useful than the non-adjusted goal data.

6. Although not specifically a beef with Corsi, much of the corsi analysis currently being done does not split out offensive corsi and defensive corsi but rather looks at them as a percentage or as a +/- differential. I believe this is a poor way of doing analysis because it really is useful to know whether a player is good because he produces a lot of offense or whether the player is good because he is great defensively. Plus, when evaluating a player offensively we need to consider the offensive capability of his team mates and the defensive capability of his opposition, not the overall ability of those players.

7. I have a really hard time believing that 8 of the top 9 corsi % players over the past 5 seasons are Red Wing players because they are all really talented and had nothing to do with the system they play or some other non-individual talent factor.

8. Try doing a Malkin vs Gomez fenwick/corsi comparison and now do the same with goals. Gomez actually has a very good and very comparable fenwick rating to Malkin, but Malkin is a far better player at producing goals thanks to his far superior on-ice shooting percentage (FSh% = fenwick shooting percentage = goals / fenwick for). Gomez every single season has a much poorer on-ice shooting percentage than Malkin and this is why Malkin is the far better player. Fenwick/Corsi doesn’t account for this.

Malkin Gomez Malkin Gomez Malkin Gomez
Season(s) FF20 FF20 GF20 GF20 FSh% FSh%
2011-12 16.5 14.0 1.301 0.660 7.9% 4.7%
2010-11 16.1 16.4 0.949 0.534 5.9% 3.3%
2009-10 15.3 14.2 1.112 0.837 7.3% 5.9%
2008-09 12.4 16.8 1.163 0.757 9.4% 4.5%
2007-08 14.1 15.9 1.206 0.792 8.5% 5.0%
2007-11 14.7 14.7 1.171 0.745 8.0% 5.1%


So there you have it. Those are some of the main reasons why I don’t use corsi in player analysis. This isn’t to say Corsi isn’t a useful metric. It is a useful metric in identifying which players are better at controlling play. Unfortunately, controlling play is only part of the game so if you want to conduct a complete thorough evaluation of a player, goal based stats are required.
 
You are going to hate McClement

Theres more to sports then just stats.

And when looking to round off your roster and add 3rd - 4th line guys, Id rather have the guy who only scores 20pts in the season, but also blocks shots, finishes checks, kills penalties and is a leader both on and off the ice, instead of the guy who scores 30pts but does nothing else.

I wouldn't mind McLement at his price tag on our team.....but you're right that I'm going to hate it if he's our 3rd line C all year.

and we've had plenty of 3rd/4th liners in your preferred mold under Burke......Armstrong, Sjostrom, Steckel, Brent, Dupuis, Wallin, Brown, Rosehill, Orr...how's that worked out for us?
 
Wellwood did not have a "kickass" season.

Wellwood looked like an NHL player for the first time since his sophomore year. Which is a tremendous improvement.
 
So stats are useless, eh?

Hmm.

certain stats simply don't tell you what they sound like they tell you.

"Giveaway" sounds like an outright negative, so that more giveaways must be a bad thing.....until you realize that to giveaway the puck a lot, you must have the puck a lot, which would probably make you a good player, not a bad one.

"Penalty Minutes" used to be considered a good stat, because it meant the guy was tough.....but no we look at them mostly as a liability.

But this is all silly anyways - Beauch's giveaway numbers are very good regardless, considering that he plays more minutes than most any player in the league.

2011/12: 2095:33toi (4th), 47gv (77th)
 
I wouldn't mind McLement at his price tag on our team.....but you're right that I'm going to hate it if he's our 3rd line C all year.

and we've had plenty of 3rd/4th liners in your preferred mold under Burke......Armstrong, Sjostrom, Steckel, Brent, Dupuis, Wallin, Brown, Rosehill, Orr...how's that worked out for us?

McClement will be our 3rd line C all year..its why we got him..

I think the biggest issue is the style a game we played.

With a wide open, run-and-gun system, if you cant skate you will be exposed. Its a style of game where its very difficult to not have guys out of position, and now they're fighting to get back in the play or to their correct position on the ice. With guys like Army, Steckel etc, once their outta position, they dont have have the foot speed to get back.

I can see with a wide open system its not beneficial to have grinders within your lineup, as they can cause more issues as they wont be able to keep up with the flow of the game.

Now with Carlyle, there will be a much bigger emphasis on defense, physicality and positional play, and without guys who can play that kind of game, the system is not going to work. To me the most glaring issue down the stretch was that we were just not big enough to play Carlyle's system.
 
Back
Top