• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I saw a great post against using CORSI recently:

He's right for the most part IMO. Corsi is a good idea but it needs obvious refinements - it's not properly accounting for team/teammate quality, nor for ice time.

None of the cumulative stats really work right as of yet, but some of the component stats are good enough - quality of competition is one of the best of the "new" metrics, as it's a sampling of numbers against the entire range of opponents, and important factors like quality of team/teammate and icetime are totally independant of it.
 
McClement will be the 3rd line C for like 20 games, then when they're 20th in scoring, they will finally play their best players, like the usually do. It typically takes about 20-25 games for the Leafs to filter out their scrubs.
 
This team isn't built to be a defensive, physical team, they don't have the personnel. In order to play that way, most of your top players need to play that way for it to be successful, not your 3rd and 4th liners.
 
McClement was a 17 point, 4th liner for a non playoff team, who just let him go despite the low price to re-sign him.

And we want to make him this super elite 3rd line checking centre.

I really don't understand the facination.
 
Nah. Brent was an AHLer who made the team by surprise in camp, Steckel was always considered nothing more than a faceoff/pk specialist and Wallin had no track record in the NHL.

McClement is a better player than some here are giving him credit for. But it doesn't matter. He's just a placeholder until the kids are ready. Thats why it was such a great signing. Short and cheap for a quality player that will help now.
 
See, we are judging players sorely on the pts..

A 17 point Center will most likely be a 3rd line checker. Someone who can play on the pk and defend a lead with a minute to go..

You're not looking for him to score, you're looking for him to prevent the other team from doing so.

Now if we signed him to be our #1 or 2 guy, then yeah, thats a problem.
 
so you're committing to your 3rd line being unable to score, and thus your 4th line as well, meaning half your forwards can't score., and when we're down a goal late in a game we'll be forced to put a non-scoring line out there even when we shorten the bench.


and all this based on the assumption that Jay Freaking McClement is some superhero of grit and defense.
 
You absolutely need some sort of scoring on your 3rd line. But Im not looking for them to be offensive stalwarts.

And I am not saying McClement is a superhero of grit and defense, however he fits the 3rd line role a lot better then Connolly or Bozak.

I'm also a big supporter of defensive hockey and not opposed to playing the trap. So our views are going to differ dramatically. Defense wins game.
 
Pigeonholing McClement as a "17 point center" is a bit disingenuous.

McClement had 36, 26, and 29 point seasons in St. Louis as a third line center.......only in Colorado was he pushed to the 4th line, due to them having Stastny, Duschene, O'Reilly.
 
McClement vs Leafs potential 3rd line centers

McClement
GFon/60: 1.93
GAon/60: 2.34
+/-: -0.71

Connolly
GFon/60: 2.31
GAon/60: 3.17
+/-: -0.86

Steckel
GFon/60: 1.31
GAon/60: 2.41
+/-: -1.09

Lombardi
GFon/60: 1.91
GAon/60: 3.48
+/-: -1.57


Statistically McClement is an improvement over what we had there last year, that is for sure. Even if he does score less.

I don't really buy that some combination of McClement with Connolly, Kadri, Mac, or Kuly won't be able to score though.
 
A little exaggeration there.

no not really....AHL superstar...NHL spare part

At his abolute best he might qualify as a worst top 6 forward on a very very good team, with players that can overcomehis limitations ( ie what kessel and lupul did)...

he cant play in anyone's bottom 6 ever.
 
Giveaway statistics are rarely good because the best players normally rank at the top of the lists. Why? Because they log the most ice-time. Your reply was projection, pure and simple.

That is easy to work with though.

Giveaway per minutes played.

Of course giveaways is a weird stat and subjective.
 
Back
Top