• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Given Carlyle's success isn't it worthwhile to give him the benefit of the doubt that he knows what he wants for his third line?....especially when line matching is such a large part of his coaching style?
Nope. I think Randy's going to get a crash course in how it's a lot easier to run with a two-line offensive team when you've got the likes of Teemu Selanne, Bobby Ryan and Andy MacDonald on your second line (with Getzlaf/Perry on the 1st, of course).
 
Nope. I think Randy's going to get a crash course in how it's a lot easier to run with a two-line offensive team when you've got the likes of Teemu Selanne, Bobby Ryan and Andy MacDonald on your second line (with Getzlaf/Perry on the 1st, of course).

And Bozak instead of McClemant on the 3rd line closes that gap does it?

If anything he should be focussed on making sure his 3rd line in Toronto is better than his 3rd line in Anaheim because the offensive defediency will force him into protecting more 2-1 and 3-2 leads.
 
no, I haven't.

I also hadn't watched a game where I noticed the play of Steckel, Sjostrom, Dupuis, Finger before we signed them. Well, I'd noticed Steckel a bit before we got him actually. but That is a bad thing, because I watch too much hockey to be happy signing a 30 year old who I've barely ever noticed.

And let's be real, do you really think this 30 year old has been a secretly awesome 3rd line centre for years and nobody's noticed enough to ever give him a real contract?

and I'm tired of reserving judgement when it comes to yet another one of Burke's plug signings, anyways.

I actually knew you were going to reply by saying that you hadn't noticed, and that proves your point, but figured I'd let you say it.

Truth is, unless you're a professional scout, you're not going to notice a lot of the unsung heroes or diamonds in the rough on other teams. For instance, who the hell knew anything about MacArthur before we got him? But he turned out to be a pretty good find.

Now, McClement may turn out to be nothing, just another Steckel, but if he's a serviceable bottom six guy who can help kill penalties and keep the puck out of our net, two things we're like the worst in the league at, then it's a worthwhile signing and keeps lower tier guys off the team. Aren't we happy to have a guy like Mike Brown down there? Sure, he doesn't score much, but he brings a lot of other things to the table that we need.

It's just premature and overemotional to dismiss the McClement signing simply because you didn't like the Dupuis signing, or Boyce or Crabb or whatever other shit we've had to suffer through.
 
Nope. I think Randy's going to get a crash course in how it's a lot easier to run with a two-line offensive team when you've got the likes of Teemu Selanne, Bobby Ryan and Andy MacDonald on your second line (with Getzlaf/Perry on the 1st, of course).

This is a good point though I wouldn't overstate it. I am no fan of this top six bottom six shit and worry that there won't be much scoring depth. I also am not wild about 2 offensive voids centering the bottom two lines. But I'll give him a shot to show what he can do with this. It can't be any worse than what we've seen over the past six years. *deja vuing*
 
I don't think anyone should believe whoever Carlyle had on his third line was the difference cause of their success or the reason for their demise.

I don't think that's an argument in favor of not getting Carlyle the guys he wants to play the kind of system he prefers though.....if we don't have the required players necessary for our top 6, getting Carylyle to change the way he coaches, and what has made him successful, just to get someone like Bozak into the lineup, likely isn't the right course of action.

We need to get better in goal, we need to get a first line center.......but we also needed the kind of 3rd line center necessarily for Carlyle's system, and we addressed that.
 
Our bottom lines have to be able to keep the puck out of our end and out of our net. Last year, and in the many years previous, they absolutely stunk at doing that. If McClement helps the PK, and helps our 3rd line not be a black hole defensively, it will be an improvement over previous years.

And has been mentioned previously, with our plethora of 2nd line wingers, it's not like he's going to be playing with Joey Crabb and Matt Lombardi. He'll likely be with two of MacA, Kuly, Kadri, Connolly, etc... all offensively talented players. Look back no further than the Quinn years to see lines that were extremely effective in both ends of the ice that didn't necessarily have three offensive minded studs on them.

People flipping their shit about this...I just think it's a bit premature. Let's wait and see what the opening day lineup looks like before doing anything. And another point worth mentioning...if Carlyle uses the McClement line to match up against other teams top lines, and they shut the down... well then we don't need to score 3-4+ goals/game to win anymore.
 
Everyone loves to add their own fictitious narratives to these kinds of situations (note: Steve Nash situation)....truth is all those teams have been successful of late, and a plenty of them have media markets that would blast him just as much as Calgary, Ottawa, Vancouver or Edmonton's media would.
 
Monty's right, those markets for the most part are just as fierce. The difference is on each one of those teams he wouldn't have to be the best player. That's why he's a bitch.
 
Anaheim's cup winning top 6 (regular season stats).

Penner (29gls/97hts) - McDonald (27gls/44hts) - Selanne (48gls/10hts)
Kunitz (25gls/159hts) - Getzlaf (25gls/99hts) - Perry (17gls/59hts)

2011-12 Maple Leafs

Lupul (25gls/110hts) - Bozak (18gls/117hts) - Kessel (37gls/12hts)
Kulemin (7gls/97hts) - Grabovski (23gls/56hts) - MacArthur (20gls/60hts)

If Kulemin and/or van Reimsdyk can put up a solid 25gl/100hit season next year that top 6 has enough "grit" and offence to make the playoffs.

If Burke can find a bonafide top-line centre (and of course a goaltender), this group could do some damage.
 
In those Cup Playoffs:

Moen: 21gms, 7gls, 12pts (82gms, 27gls, 47pts)
Pahlsson: 21gms, 3gls, 12pts (82gms, 12gls, 47pts)
Niedermayer: 21gms, 5gls, 10pts (82gms, 10gls, 39pts)
 
what is the tax rate in each area for Nash... I know he is making 7+ mil but I would rather not have to give 40+% to the govt like he would if he came back to Canada.
 
Back
Top