We should give Scrivens some more time in the NHL to see what he's capable of(only has like 12 games i think). The stats of those 2 are fairly similar. The fact that Scrivens is a bit older than the other doesn't mean much really.
I disagree entirely. The fact that Bernier has been good enough to be a legitimate NHL backup at his age, while Scrivens has had to take the long way to the NHL says quite a bit imo.
Bernier posted .910 in 08-09 in 54 games in the AHL and then posted .936 in 58 games. Everything else from there is pretty weak argument to use as his numbers aren't very good after 09-10.
Excuse me? A weak argument because his numbers weren't very good after 09-10?...He was in the ****ing NHL at 22 and not playing in the ECAC.
The numbers of Bernier's you're quoting are from when he was 20-21 years old, the numbers of Scrivens'? 24-25.
The Kuly argument is exactly that. I don't want a 7 goal Kuly either so i'm assuming he will get at the very least 15 goals or so next year. If he doesn't, he can go play elsewhere.
Kuly may not get top 6 minutes next season with the addition of JVR, and if he struggles again, his value is roughly equivalent to a puddle of piss. For it to not be worth moving him for Bernier, you have to be absolutely certain that he returns to 25+ goal, top 6 forward form...and soon.
The point about Mac and Frattin is fair enough but i think you have to look at the bigger picture. If we found goals elsewhere (in this case JVR and Kadri) why not stick with players who can helps us in other aspects of our game (in this case physicality/play on the boards).
Because those other aspects of the game, are reasonably easy to replace in the bottom 6, every year in the free agent market. Why trade a guy who does score 20 goals a year if you can trade a guy who "might", when they're of similar ages?
Again, you have to be damn sure that Matt Frattin becomes a 20-25+ goal top 6 forward if you're trading one of those for the sake of keeping him.
You are thinking of Bernier very highly if you think he can easily become our #1. To me nothing in his numbers says that (nothing our other goalies haven't shown anyway) so again i think it's not a very necessary risk.
He was stuck behind a vezina calibre performance last season, and a small sample size doesn't tell us a lot about his play (for example, remove 1 shit game of his 16gp and his SV% was .916....thus is the danger of the small sample size).
I do think very highly of Bernier. He was absolutely dominant at the AHL level, and has been an average NHL backup since getting stuck behind Quick's break out. All the markings of a future stud is there. It would be silly to not acquire him because we were afraid of missing out on Matt Frattin.