• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

....and Ben Scrivens is two years older.

James Reimer is 24 and has .911 in 70 games or so in the NHL so we already have a guy with those types of numbers and just 1 year older..Try again. This to me is just trying to patch things up by giving up valuable assets (if it ends up being for Kulemin or Frattin)...Those guys have the game we desperately need(physical with scoring potential).
 
....and Ben Scrivens is two years older.


And as good as Scrivens was in a legitimate workload this season, Bernier was better, & 4 years younger. Then take into account that in Bernier's 1st go around in the NHL as a 22 year old, he played more and was quite a bit better than 25 year old Scriven's in his 1st NHL go around.

Goalies are weird, so it's almost impossible to write off a goalie for an odd career trajectory, but so far Bernier has outperformed Scrivens at every level they've both played in, at a younger age.
 
I think him being 21 and dominating AHL is very impressive for sure but i still think it's a risk and he hasn't proven anything in the NHL. For those reasons i wouldn't trade any of our valuable assets. Mac i'd probably do but not Kuly or Frattin.
 
James Reimer is 24 and has .911 in 70 games or so in the NHL so we already have a guy with those types of numbers and just 1 year older..Try again. This to me is just trying to patch things up by giving up valuable assets (if it ends up being for Kulemin or Frattin)...Those guys have the game we desperately need(physical with scoring potential).

What do you mean "try again"?....I love Reimer, but just like Bernier I recognize he's by no means a lock to become a #1 calibre goalie.....that's why I want to double our chances to have one, by acquiring Bernier.

If Luongo isn't a realistic option, then doing whatever we can to try and find a longterm solution in goal should be Burke's top priority. Adding a kid with Bernier's potential, does just that.
 
Why would you trade Mac, but not Kuly or Frattin? There's 2.5 years difference between MacArthur & Frattin. One of them is a 2 time 20 goal scorer, the other is Matt Frattin. 15 months between Mac & Kulemin.
 
Why would you trade Mac, but not Kuly or Frattin? There's 2.5 years difference between MacArthur & Frattin. One of them is a 2 time 20 goal scorer, the other is Matt Frattin. 15 months between Mac & Kulemin.

Our need mostly. Frattin has amazing ability to do shit down low (much like Kuly) and so we as a soft team need players like that more. Scorers, i think with Kadri coming up and JVR here we have enough to produce solid offensive numbers.
 
The ability to "do shit down low", while scoring 7, & 8 goals respectively, is pretty easily replaced in free agency.

The Ability to score 40+ goals & 100+ points over a 2 years span is significantly more expensive and difficult to replace.
 
The ability to "do shit down low", while scoring 7, & 8 goals respectively, is pretty easily replaced in free agency.

The Ability to score 40+ goals & 100+ points over a 2 years span is significantly more expensive and difficult to replace.

haha..my nigga! :)..See now you're using stats against me but in the other one i found the argument really weak. I mean ok 21 year old dominated in the AHL, still his NHL numbers aren't anything to be excited about...yet you guys think it's a good enough risk to take based on potential and not much else. Well, i can use the same thing against you here. Kuly scored 30 the year before so it shows his potential and Frattin was the top scorer of the AHL playoffs. I love Mac btw, but if it came down to him or some more physical players going, i think we need physicality more so i keep those 2. Also as i said, with addition of JVR who can get very similar numbers and Kadri is good for 35-40 points at least.
 
To add, replacing those guys for physical players isn't hard, the thing is both of those guys have potential of scoring around 20 goals and giving us the physical game. That, you cannot replace so easily.
 
haha..my nigga! :)..See now you're using stats against me but in the other one i found the argument really weak. I mean ok 21 year old dominated in the AHL, still his NHL numbers aren't anything to be excited about...yet you guys think it's a good enough risk to take based on potential and not much else. Well, i can use the same thing against you here. Kuly scored 30 the year before so it shows his potential and Frattin was the top scorer of the AHL playoffs. I love Mac btw, but if it came down to him or some more physical players going, i think we need physicality more so i keep those 2. Also as i said, with addition of JVR who can get very similar numbers and Kadri is good for 35-40 points at least.

You're conflating things though. We're comparing Bernier to Scrivens...or potential Vs potential, as Scrivens is still very much an unknown himself. That's where the use of AHL statistics is of some value.

Using AHL stats to compare Fratting to MacArthur (who isn't that much older at all) is silly. You're arguing potential Vs actual production. In Kulemin's case, there is at least actual NHL production to lean on in the argument, and if you had simply stated that you wouldn't trade Kuly for Bernier based on that possibility that he returns to his previous NHL production, I'd actually agree with the argument.

I dig Frattin as a player. He plays bigger than he is and at worst will turn into a really nice 3rd line winger who can do a bit of everything. But to not trade him for Bernier? Who could quite easily become the legit #1 we're screaming for in Toronto....insanity.
 
To add, replacing those guys for physical players isn't hard, the thing is both of those guys have potential of scoring around 20 goals and giving us the physical game. That, you cannot replace so easily.

Again though, MacArthur does provide 20 goals. Not potentially, but actually.
 
You're conflating things though. We're comparing Bernier to Scrivens...or potential Vs potential, as Scrivens is still very much an unknown himself. That's where the use of AHL statistics is of some value.

Using AHL stats to compare Fratting to MacArthur (who isn't that much older at all) is silly. You're arguing potential Vs actual production. In Kulemin's case, there is at least actual NHL production to lean on in the argument, and if you had simply stated that you wouldn't trade Kuly for Bernier based on that possibility that he returns to his previous NHL production, I'd actually agree with the argument.

I dig Frattin as a player. He plays bigger than he is and at worst will turn into a really nice 3rd line winger who can do a bit of everything. But to not trade him for Bernier? Who could quite easily become the legit #1 we're screaming for in Toronto....insanity.

We should give Scrivens some more time in the NHL to see what he's capable of(only has like 12 games i think). The stats of those 2 are fairly similar. The fact that Scrivens is a bit older than the other doesn't mean much really.

Bernier posted .910 in 08-09 in 54 games in the AHL and then posted .936 in 58 games. Everything else from there is pretty weak argument to use as his numbers aren't very good after 09-10.
Scrivens posted .924 in 10-11 and .926 in 11-12.

The Kuly argument is exactly that. I don't want a 7 goal Kuly either so i'm assuming he will get at the very least 15 goals or so next year. If he doesn't, he can go play elsewhere.

The point about Mac and Frattin is fair enough but i think you have to look at the bigger picture. If we found goals elsewhere (in this case JVR and Kadri) why not stick with players who can helps us in other aspects of our game (in this case physicality/play on the boards).

You are thinking of Bernier very highly if you think he can easily become our #1. To me nothing in his numbers says that (nothing our other goalies haven't shown anyway) so again i think it's not a very necessary risk.
 
Mac is under appreciated for what he brings to the table. By no means is he untouchable, but why move a guy like tht at this point. He's been a big part of one of the most productive lines in the NHL the last couple years.
 
Mac is under appreciated for what he brings to the table. By no means is he untouchable, but why move a guy like tht at this point. He's been a big part of one of the most productive lines in the NHL the last couple years.

Oh i agree. When Mac came i told Leafovic he'd score 20 goals for us and still believe he can keep going like that.
 
tough call.

as far as I can see, we have a full top-9 forwards even if we play mcclement on the 4th line.

Lupul - Bozak - Kessel
Mac - Grabo - Kuly
JVR - Connolly - Kadri/Frattin

Moving one of those guys to make room for both kadri and frattin (with colborne/ashton/d'amigo/mckegg/ross/biggs as injury insurance) kinda makes sense to me......and that's even if McClement is on the 4th line....if he's on the 3rd, then even less room for the kids.

we're not trading Kessel, lupul, grabo, jvr in any deal for anything other than a star player....connolly would be tough to move for any value back....so that leaves with three youngish borderline top-6 guys that might interest other teams and we could afford to give up and expect to have value - Mac, Kuly, and Bozak.

Bozak would likely be the least valuable of the three and might not be worth trading.

Mac and Kuly would both have solid value, though, and I think we can afford to give one up......but which one?

When both are at the top of their game, Kuly's the better player - similar production but with a physical and defensive game extra. Problem is he was horrendous last year and we don't know what to expect.

Given his higher upside, and the smallishness of our forwards overall, I'd probably trade Mac before Kuly, even though that could easily be the wrong choice if Kuly can't get it back together.

But if we can have all of Lupul, JVR, Kuly, Frattin healthy and productive, then our top-9 won't be looking quite as soft anymore.
 
We should give Scrivens some more time in the NHL to see what he's capable of(only has like 12 games i think). The stats of those 2 are fairly similar. The fact that Scrivens is a bit older than the other doesn't mean much really.

I disagree entirely. The fact that Bernier has been good enough to be a legitimate NHL backup at his age, while Scrivens has had to take the long way to the NHL says quite a bit imo.



Bernier posted .910 in 08-09 in 54 games in the AHL and then posted .936 in 58 games. Everything else from there is pretty weak argument to use as his numbers aren't very good after 09-10.

Excuse me? A weak argument because his numbers weren't very good after 09-10?...He was in the ****ing NHL at 22 and not playing in the ECAC.

The numbers of Bernier's you're quoting are from when he was 20-21 years old, the numbers of Scrivens'? 24-25.





The Kuly argument is exactly that. I don't want a 7 goal Kuly either so i'm assuming he will get at the very least 15 goals or so next year. If he doesn't, he can go play elsewhere.

Kuly may not get top 6 minutes next season with the addition of JVR, and if he struggles again, his value is roughly equivalent to a puddle of piss. For it to not be worth moving him for Bernier, you have to be absolutely certain that he returns to 25+ goal, top 6 forward form...and soon.

The point about Mac and Frattin is fair enough but i think you have to look at the bigger picture. If we found goals elsewhere (in this case JVR and Kadri) why not stick with players who can helps us in other aspects of our game (in this case physicality/play on the boards).

Because those other aspects of the game, are reasonably easy to replace in the bottom 6, every year in the free agent market. Why trade a guy who does score 20 goals a year if you can trade a guy who "might", when they're of similar ages?

Again, you have to be damn sure that Matt Frattin becomes a 20-25+ goal top 6 forward if you're trading one of those for the sake of keeping him.

You are thinking of Bernier very highly if you think he can easily become our #1. To me nothing in his numbers says that (nothing our other goalies haven't shown anyway) so again i think it's not a very necessary risk.

He was stuck behind a vezina calibre performance last season, and a small sample size doesn't tell us a lot about his play (for example, remove 1 shit game of his 16gp and his SV% was .916....thus is the danger of the small sample size).

I do think very highly of Bernier. He was absolutely dominant at the AHL level, and has been an average NHL backup since getting stuck behind Quick's break out. All the markings of a future stud is there. It would be silly to not acquire him because we were afraid of missing out on Matt Frattin.
 
I disagree entirely. The fact that Bernier has been good enough to be a legitimate NHL backup at his age, while Scrivens has had to take the long way to the NHL says quite a bit imo.





Excuse me? A weak argument because his numbers weren't very good after 09-10?...He was in the ****ing NHL at 22 and not playing in the ECAC.

The numbers of Bernier's you're quoting are from when he was 20-21 years old, the numbers of Scrivens'? 24-25.







Kuly may not get top 6 minutes next season with the addition of JVR, and if he struggles again, his value is roughly equivalent to a puddle of piss. For it to not be worth moving him for Bernier, you have to be absolutely certain that he returns to 25+ goal, top 6 forward form...and soon.



Because those other aspects of the game, are reasonably easy to replace in the bottom 6, every year in the free agent market. Why trade a guy who does score 20 goals a year if you can trade a guy who "might", when they're of similar ages?

Again, you have to be damn sure that Matt Frattin becomes a 20-25+ goal top 6 forward if you're trading one of those for the sake of keeping him.



He was stuck behind a vezina calibre performance last season, and a small sample size doesn't tell us a lot about his play (for example, remove 1 shit game of his 16gp and his SV% was .916....thus is the danger of the small sample size).

I do think very highly of Bernier. He was absolutely dominant at the AHL level, and has been an average NHL backup since getting stuck behind Quick's break out. All the markings of a future stud is there. It would be silly to not acquire him because we were afraid of missing out on Matt Frattin.

First off, why are you making it seem that a 22 year old can't have success in the NHL? Carey Price at 20 had .920, Jim Carey similar numbers at 20 or 21, J.S. Giguere at 23 and i could go on..All posted .915+ while around that age. If you're good you're good, end of story. It doesnt mean that you can't get better but i am not trading for another potential (we have 2 or 3 already).


Second, you seem so impressed by the AHL numbers yet have you even seen an AHL game? The way a lot of those guys play (the inability to put pucks up into top corner and general lack of offensive talent) i'm actually not impressed very much by a guy who had one good season in the AHL. Even with Scrivens posting something like .940 in the playoffs and watching those guys not be able to beat him..You don't think it's weird how these guys can't beat him yet NHL player's are doing it and fairly easily too.

The point above stands and you guys are simply seeing things that aren't there. It's the pattern here really. Even when stats show otherwise you use your own "expertise" to project what the guy is possibly capable of doing. When others do the same you call them out for not looking at the stats as the only facts.
 
TORONTO*-*The Maple Leafs’ interest in acquiring Los Angeles Kings goaltender Jonathan Bernier dates to at least the entry draft in Pittsburgh in June.

It might have waned at some point, but a source told the Toronto Sun on Wednesday night that the Leafs’ interest in Bernier has picked up steam.

Whether an actual offer has been made by the Leafs is not clear, but one name that has been apparently involved in trade talk is Leafs forward Matt Frattin.
http://www.torontosun.com/2012/07/18/bernier-on-leafs-radar
 
For me, the issue with Bernier isn't just that he's unproven as an NHL starter. He's unproven as a good goaltender period. The past two years, he's only played 31 games, and his overall performance in those 31 games has been pretty mediocre. So, if you trade for him, you're banking entirely on the fact that he was a first round pick six years ago, and a very good starter in the AHL three years ago. No thanks.

As for trading Kulemin, I can't picture very many scenarios where trading him this summer would be a good move. He's at the absolute lowest point of his trade value. Nobody will offer a good return for him.
 
bernier's size has me worried.

there just aren't very many good goalies under 6 ft tall. halak is one, but he is still yet to prove he can handle a starting workload. thomas is the other, but he's the most unorthodox goalie in the league.

bernier would definitely be bucking the trend by becoming a quality starter.

of course, if you can get him for something centred around frattin that isn't a terrible chance to take. but it still reeks of another one of those 'let's go for raycroft or toskalol and mock the teams that overpay for luongo and vokoun' situations.
 
Back
Top