• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Also note, every single one of them are #1 (or 1A in the Weber/Sutter instance) on playoff teams.......further illuminating just how valuable true #1 Dmen are to building a playoff calibre squad.
 
I wouldn't take Keith Yandle over Phaneuf.....he puts up nice numbers, but he's unbelievably protected with the icetime he's given. The vast majority of his shifts start in the offensive zone, and his quality of competition faced was something like 7th amongst Phoenix defenseman last year.

I wouldn't take Letang over Dion either.

He's slowly become horrifically overrated in the span of about a year and a half. Nice defenceman but not all-world either.
 
It's predominantly because of fantasy hockey these guys gets overrated, imo........people start equating players fantasy value to real life value.
 
Find me the list of work horse defencemen (25+mins), with 200+ shots and 200+ hits.

Oh, here it is:

Weber
Chara
Phaneuf
 
Find me the list of work horse defencemen (25+mins), with 200+ shots and 200+ hits.
Oh, here it is:
Weber
Chara
Phaneuf

I love Sesame street...one of these things is not like the others, one of these things is just not the same...
 
I wouldn't take Letang over Dion either.
I'd take Letang over Dion in a landslide. Everything Letang does is better than Dion.

That being said, if we are looking to move Dion to make room for a position of need, then trade him to the Canucks for Luongo.
 
I love Sesame street...one of these things is not like the others, one of these things is just not the same...

He's one of a handful of defencemen in the league that provides big minutes, 200+ shots and 200+ hits - do I care if you rank him last on that list? Probably not.
 
I'd take Letang over Pietrangelo at this point due to him being more experienced. The sky is the limit for Alex Pietrangelo though. Really wish we had gotten him in the draft instead of Schenn.
 
We need a goalie(think Kipper in Calgary) to help our defence. Phaneuf is no where near as bad a defender as he was made to look last year. If we bring in a goalie, say Luongo, we all of a sudden have a player in net that provides a good sense of security for the defenders to play their game. What we saw last year was a very tentative defense that had to play mistake free hockey so that the score wouldnt be 5-1 by the end of the 1st period.

Give Phaneuf a goalie that can make a save to allow him to play a more offense focused game and he'll return to the 2012 1st half/Calgary Phaneuf that was a menace to play against.

If Phaneuf isn't free to use his body because if he misses its a goal, you'll have a much better Phaneuf. Alot less pressure, and the security of knowing the goalie can bail you out. HUGE mental advantage for the opponent when you have a tentative Phaneuf instead of the intimidating Phaneuf.
 
Letang reminds me of a slightly worse Dion from his Calgary days. I'd take Pietrangelo over him.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not knocking Dion. Phaneuf is easily one of the most underrated players in the game. And that will change as soon as we get a goalie that doesn't give up goals on shots from outside the circles, or anything that is deflected. But Letang is what we should hope Gardiner and Rielly become.
 
Phaneuf was top 12 in scoring, top 10 in minutes played and top 10 in hits. He ranked among the leaders in strength of opponents matched up against and his defensive metrics were good.

He was one of the best defenseman in the league last year.
 
But, he got beat to the outside in embarrassing fashion by Hansen and some other plug on HNIC, so therefore he sucks.

He's a consensus top 15 defender, who has shown the ability to play as a top 5-7 defender for extended stretches but isn't consistently at that level.

I'm quite interested to see 2 guys who are considered better than he is, play without each other this season. I dig Gunner, he's very good at what he does, probably the most slept on defensive specialist in the league...but playing next to him isn't quite like playing next to Suter or Shea
 
Phaneuf remarked to several people that he couldn't carry a team with Reimer/Gustavsson/Schenn and Komisarek for a whole season. And true to his word, he folded like a tent in the second half.

I gotta say, I admire him for this stance, because no team should carry three of those four players on their roster and expect the better players to continue digging deep into their resevoir.

So, if Dion sees a goalie and no Komisarek, we might a full 82 games of his Norris Trophy first half. So if that Dion is available, I don't trade him straight up for a lot of special players.

But if he is comfortable playing that second half Dion "magic", then we are probably fawked.
 
Back
Top