Phaneuf remarked to several people that he couldn't carry a team with Reimer/Gustavsson/Schenn and Komisarek for a whole season. And true to his word, he folded like a tent in the second half.
I gotta say, I admire him for this stance, because no team should carry three of those four players on their roster and expect the better players to continue digging deep into their resevoir.
So, if Dion sees a goalie and no Komisarek, we might a full 82 games of his Norris Trophy first half. So if that Dion is available, I don't trade him straight up for a lot of special players.
But if he is comfortable playing that second half Dion "magic", then we are probably fawked.