• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I question if the offer M.E. came up with would either be

a) best offered
b) good enough for anaheim to quit on the year.


A) debateble, sure....but similar guys like Kovy didn't land nearly as much as one would think when they were sold off as a rental
B) Depends on if they view Nashville as a cautionary tale or not...they should.
 
Yeah...I'm seriously heartbroken today about Getz resigning. I have such a mancrush on him. Such a complete hockey player.

It's why pursuing the top guys who do become available is so important. You just don't know when the next one is going to be available.
 
It's why pursuing the top guys who do become available is so important. You just don't know when the next one is going to be available.

Yeah, can't argue with that. Perry would be a hell of a consolation prize, but this team needs a big, talented C to take it to the next level. If we signed Perry, better use that depth to upgrade.
 
It's the absurdity of the logic, I'm pointing to. If you pay no mind to position and just collect elite talent without any consideration, which is what you and ME have advocated, it could lead to a completely imbalanced roster in a cap environment. Which is, in fact, how it turns out with adding Perry at 9M to: JVR, Lupul, Kessel and any other longer term commitments/players you'd want to extend (e.g., Frattin).

Then there's the issue of how you build a team. From the wing in? Sam Pollock rolls in his grave. You build the wings around a solid centre complement. If you want to see why, take a gander at how the current roster can't control pucks in the offensive zone.

But we're not ****ing deciding between an elite center and an elite winger. There's no elite center available. No idea why you'd pass on Perry and I'm the absurd one.
 
But, what if an elite centre came avaiable and you had all these wingers and defenders clogging up your cap space...what then???
 
I'd love to get Perry, center or not.

If we get him, we can trade Kessel for a center.

Or, we can trade Bozak, go with Kadri on the first line unless he proves himself unworthy, Grabs on the second line (unless we can find a taker), and Colborne on the third line.

If we have four elite wingers in Kessel, Lupul, JVR, and Perry, we should be in pretty good shape.

It just doesn't seem like an elite center will ever become available unless we draft him or a Phaneuf-type trade comes up.

Though I'm still quite partial to the idea of a Perry import and Kessel export for the guy we need.
 
But, what if an elite centre came avaiable and you had all these wingers and defenders clogging up your cap space...what then???

That's my issue. Don't spend the money for the sake of spending it. If there's no top centre available, leave it. I really like our depth on the wings right now as it is. A top centre will become available eventually.
 
That's my issue. Don't spend the money for the sake of spending it. If there's no top centre available, leave it. I really like our depth on the wings right now as it is. A top centre will become available eventually.

The answer is that you can trade one of your many good wingers for a center.

It's not for the sake of spending it. Perry's an elite forward, he plays with an edge, he's won a Stanley Cup, he's only 27, he's scored 50 goals.

Why would we pass because we have Lupul, Kessel, JVR and Frattin?
 
some seem to want to just 'wait and see'. the leafs have been wait and seeing about an elite centre since the late 1990s. they wanted badly to add another first line quality centre with size to play behind sundin. never got it.

they've been seeking one since sundin left. not only have they not acquired one -- few have been available over the past several years to acquire.

in fact, since the first season post-sundin era (08-09), the only centres to switch teams who have, in at least one season during their careers been amongst the top 15 scoring centres are mike richards, brad richards and mike ribeiro.

so, a guy who scored 40 points last year, a guy who the people who seem most intent on waiting it out specifically didn't want when he was a ufa, and a guy who those same people are saying not to acquire as a free agnet this summer.

i'm not sure what you're waiting on. mats sundins don't grow on trees. and generally when team sget them, unless they are subject to unbelievably stupid management, they keep them for as long as htye possibly can.

if your plan for building a team is to wait for malkin, crosby, staal, getzlaf or kopitar to come available you will probably be waiting an eternity.

now, there is something to be said about not locking up lon gterm cap dollars in secondary talent. grabovskis, liles', and the like. all replaceable. keeping guys like that hsouldn't factor into the discussion at all.

but if your cap problem is that you have kessel, lupul, kadri and perry and you need to add $8mn in space to add that centre when/if they come availble, you won't have difficulty dealing with it. but you can't just rest on the presumption that you will get one of those guys because history suggests that you probably won't.
 
I sure like the odds of Kadri turning into that #1C with a guarantee he'll be playing with two of JVR, Lupul, Perry or Kessel on his wing.
 
That's my issue. Don't spend the money for the sake of spending it. If there's no top centre available, leave it. I really like our depth on the wings right now as it is. A top centre will become available eventually.

Sorry, I guess I should have ended the previous post with [/sarcasm] or something. Top line centres don't "become available". They just don't. Waiting for one to become available, to the point of passing on other elite talent to save cap space for an elite centre is a surefire way to stay mediocre for a long time.

There's a few things I simply don't understand about this stance I'm seeing a few people support:

1) The cap...even being capped out isn't an impediment to chasing an elite centre who becomes available in free agency. You can go over the cap in the summer and worry all summer about dumping contracts to get under the cap for October 1.

2) An elite centre isn't winning you shit by himself: see Sundin, mats for more information on that. The more elite pieces around him, the better your chances of actually winning a title.

3) Trade...if an elite centre comes available in the trade market, those elite pieces you already have in house are awesome trade chips for him. Of course it's better yet if you don't have to give up another elite piece to get him and now you've added an elite centre to a core of Kessel, Perry, Kadri, Phaneuf, Gardiner, Rielly...

Acquire elite talent, worry about the minutae later.
 
Corey Perry is exactly what this team wants, just he plays wing instead of center. He is a big, physical, nasty player that plays a strong two way game and can be your best offensive player.

Saying no to a player like that if you have the opportunity to get him is just dumb. I don't care how many wingers you have. None of them are Corey Perry.
 
Corey Perry is exactly what this team wants, just he plays wing instead of center. He is a big, physical, nasty player that plays a strong two way game and can be your best offensive player.

Saying no to a player like that if you have the opportunity to get him is just dumb. I don't care how many wingers you have. None of them are Corey Perry.

Yeah, how often do you get a chance to get your hands on a 50-goal scorer, Hart winner, and Cup winner, who's 27 (28?)? You don't pass those opportunities up.
 
Flaws on either side here, but one thing that jumped at me was the idea of "just trading" for a centre. With the cap, trades are harder nowadays, but even without the cap, you guys roll that "just trade" off your tongues way too easily. What if the team that has what you want doesn't want what you have? What if salaries don't match?
I'm just saying it's not necessarily simple.


On the other side, there will always be players out there that are the worth going after no matter what. It doesn't have to be only a Crosby or Malkin...there are players that change the game, and if you can get them you try your damnedest. Then it's up to the GM and owners I guess, to decide for example, if Perry is one of those.
 
Flaws on either side here, but one thing that jumped at me was the idea of "just trading" for a centre. With the cap, trades are harder nowadays, but even without the cap, you guys roll that "just trade" off your tongues way too easily. What if the team that has what you want doesn't want what you have? What if salaries don't match?
I'm just saying it's not necessarily simple.

On the other side, there will always be players out there that are the worth going after no matter what. It doesn't have to be only a Crosby or Malkin...there are players that change the game, and if you can get them you try your damnedest. Then it's up to the GM and owners I guess, to decide for example, if Perry is one of those.

As opposed to "just wait and sign a #1 center"? That's even more unlikely.
 
Back
Top