• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Mathew Knies.....

I don’t think I ever called into question Knies’ value as a prospect. My main worry was always the sneaking suspicion that he wouldn’t sign with us.

Was glad to be proven wrong on that one.
 
I'm pretty sure my position was always that his perceived value exceeded his actual value and so we should trade him to capitalize. That, and I expected any assets we recouped to be ready to contribute sooner than Knies would be able to make any impact.

Jury's still out on the first point but I'll take the L on the second as he does look like he belongs and can make a difference so far.
 
I'm pretty sure my position was always that his perceived value exceeded his actual value and so we should trade him to capitalize. That, and I expected any assets we recouped to be ready to contribute sooner than Knies would be able to make any impact.

Jury's still out on the first point but I'll take the L on the second as he does look like he belongs and can make a difference so far.
I still think that might end up all being pretty fair tbh. I guess it’d be tough to know without seeing the offered return if there was one.
 
I was with DP on that because I truly wanted them to add another impact forward but I don't think his trade value would have exceeded his actual value. You have to believe that if the Leafs traded Knies today his value would be greater than it was before he played an NHL game.. So we were wrong on that IMO. But I mean.. I guess it's a little early to know for sure and it largely depends on what kind of career he has with the Leafs but there weren't many of us who thought he'd make much of an impact this soon.
 
Knies had a big year. Previously his traditional stats were good, but not great. But he improved every year. And this year he had one of the top goal scoring seasons for his age historically, and he scored 30 points in his last 23 games this year and really upped the confidence in a high ceiling.

And that is on top of his elite nerdies.
 
Dark times for the dork squad. They ignored their own beloved nerd stats which only supported what the eye test screamed.
 
Knies had a big year. Previously his traditional stats were good, but not great. But he improved every year. And this year he had one of the top goal scoring seasons for his age historically, and he scored 30 points in his last 23 games this year and really upped the confidence in a high ceiling.

And that is on top of his elite nerdies.
Yeah I was late to the party compared to HL but that's about when my position on him evolved.
 
everyone in the dork squad thought he was a pretty sure bet to be an NHLer. the only questions were 'how good' and 'how soon'.
We all had our bull and bear cases. HL was the only one that stuck to her guns on the bull case and didn't really consider a bear case.



The only one.
 
Skating was my concern but maybe he is one of those with a stride that makes him look slower then he really is
 
I mean, come on Ezekiel. Own up to that one. I said the same thing btw, and it wasn't a knock on the player, just comparing the situations. I was on an island with you in liking the Foligno trade at the time. The ROR trade had similarities but it never meant the end result would be the same.
 
Presto has really managed to gaslight you all on that one, with one selected quote.

you and I went back and forth for pages....my therapist assures me that I will eventually forget...but it may take a while
 
I'll admit my concerns about ROR being washed appear to have been unfounded.

Always liked the Acciari addition though.

And I did support adding a 2LW or 3C (aka ROR), I just questioned whether ROR still had the juices to cut it. Shoulda trusted the nerdies though, not the stupid counting stats.
 
I mean, come on Ezekiel. Own up to that one. I said the same thing btw, and it wasn't a knock on the player, just comparing the situations. I was on an island with you in liking the Foligno trade at the time. The ROR trade had similarities but it never meant the end result would be the same.

heh. you've even gaslighted yourself.

everyone knows what i said about getting ROR all year long. even you.
 
Back
Top