• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Mathew Knies.....

What about Hyman as a comp?
Much better player at the same age but if he develops into a Hyman type then we're laughing. I don't hate it. Similarly choppy skater, though Hyman really learned how to wheel at some point.
 
He has grown on me. With NCAA prospects it's not always easy. The studs are very obvious so all we can say is that he's not a can't miss, clear stud. Tough to truly tell what his upside is and how likely he is to reach that potential.. there is a wide range of possibilities, including a relatively high risk of completely busting based on other dudes that put up similar numbers to him. Although, he did turn it on later in the year and that encouraged me quite a bit, even if that may have a lot to do with his linemates.

I will continue to sit on the fence because I've seen him play a total of 1 time and there is way too much uncertainty to be confident in any outcome.
He’ll have better linemates with the Leafs.
 
Yeah and I wouldn't expect him to be as strong defensively either.. Not sure their skating is all that similar either. I still have JVR as my upside comp. But that's with only seeing him play once.. He just reminded me of a young JVR.

Was JVR soft in college? Legit question

I see Knies has a tendency to use his size to his advantage from clips and bully his way through defenders. Likes to throw big hits on the forecheck as well
 
the other promising thing about him is, like Hyman, he has shown the ability to play with really high end players.

which is important for us. Even if he is just a 40 point winger, he is much more valuable to us if he can play with Matthews then if he is a Kerfoot.
 
Was JVR soft in college? Legit question

I see Knies has a tendency to use his size to his advantage from clips and bully his way through defenders. Likes to throw big hits on the forecheck as well
Knies definitely has more edge to him but JVRs appeal was his size and how he used his body, similar to how Matthews uses his. JVR was a better skater too.. Definitely more toolsy overall but his lack of drive and edge is what largely held him back. He was supposed to be Rick Nash. In other words they're probably not comparable at all now that I'm typing this out. I'll veer back to Hyman.
 
I think JVR is a pretty good comparison. Jvr is a better skater but jvr hasn’t been a good player because of his speed but because of his size and hands from in tight, which is pretty much what knies is known for.
 
He's not a great prospect, but he's a good one.

On this board we often look at draft +1 production a lot to determine how excited we're going to get about prospects. wasn't paying super close attention but seems he did finish the season pretty well...but the college hockey production level is not there to expect an impact NHL top liner or anything like that.

If he can be a scoring 3rd line winger that uses his size I think we've got a winner. any more than that would be a pleasant surprise to me.
Nothing wrong with that from a late second round pick
 
I was JVR's #1 fan here, so it's no surprise that I'm Knies' #1 fan now.

I see lots of similarities in their games too, but I think Knies projects to be more dynamic, better skater, more deft at playmaking, and uses his hands to do more than just find ways to poke the puck in from in close.
 
Really depends one what year of JVR you're talking about. Young JVR was actually a really great skater and would beat dmen consistently outside off the rush. That was kind of his go to. He didn't start converting himself into a net front specialist until part way through his time here when when the wheels started to get a little rusty.

At least as I remember it. But I drink a lot.
 
That's true too, his game did change somewhat as time went on. I loved that fucking guy.

Why couldn't Dubie just have brought him in at the deadline. I would've given that Sandin 1st for him frankly.

Fucking Dubie.
 
Yeah as usual I'm just blabbering away giving a deep analysis of a guy that I've seen 13 youtube/twit clips of and 1 Leafs prospect scrimmage. I don't know jack shit but I'm excited to get to watch him with the Leafs soon. They'll give him a shot hopefully in place of Lafferty on the 3rd line. If he's worse than Laffety then just trade him now.
 
I was JVR's #1 fan here, so it's no surprise that I'm Knies' #1 fan now.

I see lots of similarities in their games too, but I think Knies projects to be more dynamic, better skater, more deft at playmaking, and uses his hands to do more than just find ways to poke the puck in from in close.

But is he more JVR or more Kulemin tho?
 
Yeah as usual I'm just blabbering away giving a deep analysis of a guy that I've seen 13 youtube/twit clips of and 1 Leafs prospect scrimmage. I don't know jack shit but I'm excited to get to watch him with the Leafs soon. They'll give him a shot hopefully in place of Lafferty on the 3rd line. If he's worse than Laffety then just trade him now.
The only question is, will be actually see him this year? I say 50/50.
 
The only question is, will be actually see him this year? I say 50/50.
They gave Abbruzzese the longest leash known to man (may have been a condition on him signing last year) so I think they'll do the same with Knies and get him in as many games as possible. I'm almost positive he will be given a chance.
 
Maybe I am in rare company here but I am expecting him to be a top 6 winger. The Hyman comparison off to me - Knies has way better hands. I don't see Hyman even trying some of the shit this guy is able to pull off. I
t's hard not to optimistic about our own drafted players - which is why it sucked so much to see Sandin get traded.

 
I can see the Hyman comparison as they both look to be running on skates. The stride is not smooth but they can get from A to B

Marner has a similar style where it looks like every stride is a extra work but his speed and edges are what separates him from those guys
 
Really depends one what year of JVR you're talking about. Young JVR was actually a really great skater and would beat dmen consistently outside off the rush. That was kind of his go to. He didn't start converting himself into a net front specialist until part way through his time here when when the wheels started to get a little rusty.

At least as I remember it. But I drink a lot.
He could beat guys on the outside, sure, but all of his goals were at the net
 
Back
Top