• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Mathew Knies.....

early returns are that you can see why they want him. he brings some size and will be a problem along the boards and in front of the net...few Leaf forwards can check those boxes. he keeps that up he'll find himself in a Zach Hyman-esque position before too long.
 
So watching the game last night I could see why ZAR gets the hate. He makes very stupid decisions.
 
early returns are that you can see why they want him. he brings some size and will be a problem along the boards and in front of the net...few Leaf forwards can check those boxes. he keeps that up he'll find himself in a Zach Hyman-esque position before too long.


He’s shown some definite signs of being a very good puck retriever along the boards.

He has tended to chuck it away like a hand grenade as soon as he gets it on his stick, but presumably that’ll improve with time and experience.
 
IMO they are different, but I agree that you want him to fill that role. Crazy Rob Brown year aside Hyman is a grinder that excels with elite players due to his elite forechecking ability. Knies potential impact is more dynamic. I like the JVR comp. only physical and plays D.
 
yeah Knies has not really been what I was expecting so far, granted its a teensy weensy sample.

skating is worse than I expected. physicality is better. hands may be a bit better, same with his vision/passing.

he's not quite Hyman, not quite JVR. dunno who the best comparable for him is, or if they exist.

a potential unicorn. likely just a middle six forward who can hopefully keep up with the big boys; that's all we really need.
 
humiliated? I always had Knies floor as being an NHLer. in fact I'm pretty sure I had him as a likely middle six winger.

you must be humiliated often on this standard.
Never.

But to suggest he’s not even surefire top 6 will have you red faced before long.
 
Never.

But to suggest he’s not even surefire top 6 will have you red faced before long.
if you want to pencil in a dude with 2 games of professional experience and underwhelming NCAA counting stats (consider his line mates, team success, etc.) into your top-6 forever, power to ya. I will need more convincing.

and again, for clarity, my view has always been that his perceived value around the league (i.e. how you see him) far outstrips his actual value to the team, and his ability to make a material impact at this stage. nothing I've seen changes this yet. in fact it reinforces it.

Knies has made some bad giveaways, had a lot of trouble getting pucks out of his own zone, etc. He's also shown flashes and won some impressive individual battles. But yeah, he's far from a finished product, and we need a legit top-6 winger. He may eventually be that, but he sure ain't it yet.
 
Back
Top