• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Mathew Knies.....

if you want to pencil in a dude with 2 games of professional experience and underwhelming NCAA counting stats (consider his line mates, team success, etc.) into your top-6 forever, power to ya. I will need more convincing.

and again, for clarity, my view has always been that his perceived value around the league (i.e. how you see him) far outstrips his actual value to the team, and his ability to make a material impact at this stage. nothing I've seen changes this yet. in fact it reinforces it.

Knies has made some bad giveaways, had a lot of trouble getting pucks out of his own zone, etc. He's also shown flashes and won some impressive individual battles. But yeah, he's far from a finished product, and we need a legit top-6 winger. He may eventually be that, but he sure ain't it yet.
First paragraph - I penciled him in before these two games.

Second paragraph- you are wrong.

Third paragraph - focus on the flashes.
 
First paragraph - I penciled him in before these two games.

Second paragraph- you are wrong.

Third paragraph - focus on the flashes.
1 - premature

2 - disagree, and we don't have any actual way of verifying this (on either end)

3 - don't ignore the gaffes, they matter in the playoffs
 
The gaffes are what you need to ignore in the first two games.

But they even showed a nice little montage in the third of his touches that game, and he made a lot of nice subtle plays, several in our own end.
 
The gaffes are what you need to ignore in the first two games.

But they even showed a nice little montage in the third of his touches that game, and he made a lot of nice subtle plays, several in our own end.
If you want to draw firm conclusions from a 2-game sample and some youtube clips, have at it!
 
I've been impressed by Knies. I had a feeling LOF would be doing victory laps and rubbing it in to people that want him to be a super elite player and that's what makes LOF king.
 
I don't care much about the gaffes FWIW. Least of my concerns. The concerns begin and end with sample size. College kids looking good in the show early isn't completely rare. Ryan Donato has carved out a nice career and all, but his start to the NHL fresh out of college for Boston that one year looked like something special. Patience is correct.
 
I still think people went a bit overboard or overcorrected on Knies a bit too much this year, at least I found that every time I posted almost anything about him. I guess I get that tendency since we’ve been burned by “big guys” in the past but… I just think he’s more talented than all of them.
 
I still think people went a bit overboard or overcorrected on Knies a bit too much this year, at least I found that every time I posted almost anything about him. I guess I get that tendency since we’ve been burned by “big guys” in the past but… I just think he’s more talented than all of them.
And he is already miles ahead on the Kaberle "shootthefuckingpuck" % stat
 
I still think people went a bit overboard or overcorrected on Knies a bit too much this year, at least I found that every time I posted almost anything about him. I guess I get that tendency since we’ve been burned by “big guys” in the past but… I just think he’s more talented than all of them.


I’m still not convinced that any high-end offensive potential is there. But his game, physical characteristics and the position he plays do seem tailor-made to being an ideal complementary player to our top players.
 
I still think people went a bit overboard or overcorrected on Knies a bit too much this year, at least I found that every time I posted almost anything about him. I guess I get that tendency since we’ve been burned by “big guys” in the past but… I just think he’s more talented than all of them.

His biggest flaw right now is skating and luckily that can be fixed. I don't ever see him having anything more then slightly above average speed but he will make up for that with board and net front play. He seems to work well in tight spaces and can protect the puck
 
Back
Top