• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Breaking Point

Lots of people stepped up...Mike Johnson stepped up for crissakes.
I think you're thinking of Alyn McCauley. He put up 5 goals and 15 points in 20 games during that playoff run.

Johnson had been traded to Tampa for Darcy Tucker a couple of years before.
 
I think both sides are right in this instance. Do the Leafs have a leadership problem? I think it's pretty clearly a yes.

But to go on and on about leadership when we're missing some pretty big pieces seems a bit... misplaced to me.
 
... but not if Phaneuf was their Captain and / or top defender. That's the point here.
You think swapping Phaneuf for Brown would make no difference in LA's leadership? How about ours?
Sure, adding individuals from the Leafs to the Kings won't change much, but exchange their core with ours, and they'd be lacking leadership too.
Ours, OTOH, would improve by leaps and bounds.

This. You can surround the current Leaf's core with players that have already won multiple cups and sure, they'd still win but having them as the core? Doubtful. IMHO these guys playing together has run it's course. I'm not saying trade everyone, I'm saying there does need to be a leadership change in the core. Trading Phaneuf, Lupul and Bozak for solid pieces would change the face of the team. Whether those pieces make the team better or worse is the question and at this point, I don't see how it could get much worse.
 
It reminds me of the wholesale change done in 2010 in Montreal when 10 players were traded/not resigned. The face of the club changed.
 
I think both sides are right in this instance. Do the Leafs have a leadership problem? I think it's pretty clearly a yes.

But to go on and on about leadership when we're missing some pretty big pieces seems a bit... misplaced to me.

I'm not sure anybody is doing that though... I'm pretty sure all of myself, LGM, and leafman (just off the top of my head) have all advocated that this team needs both more talent, and better leadership. You'll notice nobody around here defends signings like Clarkstrongisarek on 'intangible' grounds. It's not like we're saying 'grit will cure all that ails the Leafs'.

And any time somebody mentions the idea that the leadership group on this team should be replaced/improved, zeke rails about "culture change" and his problems with it.
 
Do we have a leadership problem...or do we have a not having a 1C and 1D problem?

I've been contending the latter.

If you take this exact team and switch out Bozak for Tavares, and say Franson for Weber, are we not a contender right now?

If you think the answer is that we are still not a contender, then you're giving way too much weight to "leadership" (whatever that is) and not enough to talent.

They need to make a few meaningful changes. Lupul, Bozak, and maybe Phaneuf (mostly because the C has to be passed on) are the ones you move out. Find a way to bring in players who do those three jobs better, and add a couple more pieces here and there (an easy one would be Nylander), and we're good.

Hope they're not stupid enough to blow it up and start all over, dooming us to maybe 5 to 7 years of shit hockey only to get to the point that 90% of the teams get to anyway, even with great rosters - no Stanley Cup.
 
Do we have a leadership problem...or do we have a not having a 1C and 1D problem?

I've been contending the latter.

If you take this exact team and switch out Bozak for Tavares, and say Franson for Weber, are we not a contender right now?

If you think the answer is that we are still not a contender, then you're giving way too much weight to "leadership" (whatever that is) and not enough to talent.

They need to make a few meaningful changes. Lupul, Bozak, and maybe Phaneuf (mostly because the C has to be passed on) are the ones you move out. Find a way to bring in players who do those three jobs better, and add a couple more pieces here and there (an easy one would be Nylander), and we're good.

Hope they're not stupid enough to blow it up and start all over, dooming us to maybe 5 to 7 years of shit hockey only to get to the point that 90% of the teams get to anyway, even with great rosters - no Stanley Cup.

Yes we have a talent problem. No doubt.

Question for you though: how do you explain the tendency of this core group of players to completely wilt in the face of any adversity? What causes that? Lack of talent, or lack of leadership, or a combination of the two?

Also, you're advocating pretty big changes to what would amount to the 'leadership' group in the room by jettisoning Lups, Bozie and Phaneuf.
 
Yes we have a talent problem. No doubt.

Question for you though: how do you explain the tendency of this core group of players to completely wilt in the face of any adversity? What causes that? Lack of talent, or lack of leadership, or a combination of the two?

Also, you're advocating pretty big changes to what would amount to the 'leadership' group in the room by jettisoning Lups, Bozie and Phaneuf.

Well, to answer your question, what causes it is not enough talent. That, and other shit.

This year, it's keeping Carlyle around for 40 games when he was a proven idiot. Last year, it was having zero depth beyond the top two lines. The year before that, they played great, had Boston on the ropes, and in my opinion probably lost because their idiot coach had the same players out on the ice for the last several minutes without calling a timeout.

But in all three years, we are also missing key components - 1C and 1D.

And yes, you're right, I am advocating pretty big changes by trading those three. And that's the entire point. You don't need to dump a guy who has been top 10 in scoring in the last three years. Or a 25 year old who is probably a PPG player right now. Or a maligned young dman whose confidence was badly rattled by the coach.

We need to trade Bozak because he's not a 1C and Kadri is a better 2C. We need to trade Lupul because he can't stay healthy and leaves a big hole on our second line for half of every season. We may need to trade Phaneuf because he's the face of all the troubles we've had, and you can't take the C away from him.

But I don't think we should be salary dumping these guys into the laps of other teams. I'd like to use them to pry O'Reilly out of Colorado maybe, or Staal out of Carolina. Address needs without tearing open brand new holes.

Part of what should be the managerial manta of always trying to improve, and trading the least essential pieces of your team to do it.
 
Well, to answer your question, what causes it is not enough talent. That, and other shit.

This year, it's keeping Carlyle around for 40 games when he was a proven idiot. Last year, it was having zero depth beyond the top two lines. The year before that, they played great, had Boston on the ropes, and in my opinion probably lost because their idiot coach had the same players out on the ice for the last several minutes without calling a timeout.

But in all three years, we are also missing key components - 1C and 1D.

And yes, you're right, I am advocating pretty big changes by trading those three. And that's the entire point. You don't need to dump a guy who has been top 10 in scoring in the last three years. Or a 25 year old who is probably a PPG player right now. Or a maligned young dman whose confidence was badly rattled by the coach.

We need to trade Bozak because he's not a 1C and Kadri is a better 2C. We need to trade Lupul because he can't stay healthy and leaves a big hole on our second line for half of every season. We may need to trade Phaneuf because he's the face of all the troubles we've had, and you can't take the C away from him.

But I don't think we should be salary dumping these guys into the laps of other teams. I'd like to use them to pry O'Reilly out of Colorado maybe, or Staal out of Carolina. Address needs without tearing open brand new holes.

Part of what should be the managerial manta of always trying to improve, and trading the least essential pieces of your team to do it.

Really the only commonality between the original "18 wheeler" and this year's version are those core pieces... Kessel, Bozak, Phaneuf, Lupul.

And this whole 'blame randy' act is ridiculous, unless you also want to blame him for the team sucking under Horachek.

Talent is part of the equation, but as you also said, "other shit".

It seems like people are arguing against the idea of just 'dumping' guys for nothing. I'm not sure where anyone has advocated for that. You can concede that this team would benefit from improved leadership and still focus primarily on acquiring talent.

The problems we have are two fold if you ask me: our best players (not necessarily Phil, but the rest of the brigade) simply aren't good enough (lack of talent) and are also lacking in their abilities as leaders.
 
Really the only commonality between the original "18 wheeler" and this year's version are those core pieces... Kessel, Bozak, Phaneuf, Lupul.

And this whole 'blame randy' act is ridiculous, unless you also want to blame him for the team sucking under Horachek.

Talent is part of the equation, but as you also said, "other shit".

It seems like people are arguing against the idea of just 'dumping' guys for nothing. I'm not sure where anyone has advocated for that. You can concede that this team would benefit from improved leadership and still focus primarily on acquiring talent.

The problems we have are two fold if you ask me: our best players (not necessarily Phil, but the rest of the brigade) simply aren't good enough (lack of talent) and are also lacking in their abilities as leaders.

I guess here's what it boils down to. I can take the following partial roster and love these players regardless of who you fill in the blanks with. The key to turning this around is filling in the blanks with the players that will make this team a team. Not having a roster full of blanks and slowly adding pieces through the drafts for the next five years.

JVR _________ Kessel
______ Kadri Nylander
Komarov Holland ______
______ _______ ______

_______ Franson
Rielly Gardiner
______ _______
 
I don't know why this is so hard.

Set an objective. For the purposes of this, let's say it's winning a playoff round in 2017 the centennial year. Then ask yourself, do you have pieces right now that could be major contributors to accomplishing that objective?

Being honest, you probably have 4 for sure, possibly as many as 8.

Rielly, Kessel, JVR and Kadri are all pieces that could be big contributors that year.

Look at the rest of the roster. Ask why you wouldn't class them with the above.

Lupul: Hurt all the goddamn time. His cap space is now more valuable than his contributions on the ice

Phaneuf: You can argue he's been set up to fail. Fine. But he's being paid like a #1 and he isn't one. You can't strip the 'C' from him and keep him in Toronto. Won't work.

Bozak: As long as he's here, there's going to be a temptation to play him with Kessel. We know, statistically, that isn't what's best for this hockey team. We also know that he's not a #1C, Kadri is a better #2C and he's paid too much to be a #3C

Gardiner: A great player. Same skillset as Rielly though, and Rielly's better. You have depth so you can move it to fill positions where you don't have depth.

Santorelli, Winnik, Panik, Smith, Polak, Robidas: Don't have much open market value and aren't a part of achieving the long term objective of competing in 2017.

Reimer: A good goaltender. Could be trade for good assets at the deadline because the market for goaltenders right now tilts for the sellers.

Now, you take a look at your 4 bubble players

Komarov: Plays physical, kills penalties, brings some offensive depth. Cap-friendly contract. Not a lot of reason to move him

Franson: Big, young, right handed offensive defensemen are hard to come by. If you move Phaneuf, someone has to replace the minutes. If you can get him for a reasonable contract, you consider keeping him. No doubting he could contribute to a team in 2017, but only at the right price.

Bernier: When he's good, he's an all-world goaltender. But he has brain cramps. A mediocre season with a mediocre team this year will keep his contract demands reasonable. Like Franson, if you don't have to pay too much, keep him.

Holland: Having Peter Holland as your #3 centre probably isn't a bad thing. He's cheap, kills penalties, is young and brings some offence. While you maybe wouldn't consider him "core" every team has one like him.

Clarkson's contract is immovable. No sense in debating it.

So, your look ahead at the hockey team for 2016-17 is this, if you keep all eight:

1) William Nylander - xxxxxx - Phil Kessel

2) James Van Riemsdyk - Nazem Kadri - xxxxxx

3) Leo Komarov - Peter Holland - xxxxxx

4) xxxxxx - Frederik Gauthier - David Clarkson

1D) Morgan Rielly - Cody Franson

2D) xxxxxx - xxxxxx

3D) Stuart Percy - xxxxxx

Jonathan Bernier
xxxxxx (although, Antoine Bibeau is showing promise)

That's what you build around. And frankly, it's not a bad starting point if you can bottom out this year and grab a Dylan Strome or (if luck is kind) Connor McDavid.
 
Last edited:
JVR _________ Kessel
______ Kadri Nylander
Komarov Holland ______
______ Gauthier Clarkson

_______ Franson
Rielly Gardiner
Percy _______

Revising this to include Gauther, Percy and Clarkson.

Realistically, there aren't that many holes to fill, potentially.

The trick is in filling them right. And for years, we've needed the managerial creativity to find today's Riseborough and swipe today's Gilmour from him.

That's not our job to do, it's management's. And if they can do it, and convert the other removed parts (Bozak, Lupul, Phaneuf, and others) to fill other needs, then we've got something.

If we have the same idiots running the show who give away guys like Steen and Rask for nothing, or sign guys like Clarkson for everything, then there's little chance of this ever happening other than by fluke in trade or by luck at the draft.
 
It's actually really interesting when you think about filling those blanks and having Bozak, Lupul, Phaneuf, Santo, Winnik, Polak, Robidas, and non-critical prospects to use as currency.

A smart GM could at least capably fill a couple of the major holes.
 
I wouldn't expect to.

I'm just not seeing such a big difference between one or the other, and I still kinda lean towards Reimer anyway.

Given that Reimer is under contract for cheap next year, I prefer to just go with him than to trade him for nothing and sign Bernier long term.

Still overall torn on this subject since they both have their warts, but that's probably what I'd do.
 
Back
Top