• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Lineup Going Forward

You've gotta figure the pin will drop soon on the roster moves to alleviate the overstuffedness of the line up.

That said, looking back over the history of recent trades, there have been very few preseason trades in the NHL. Most trades these days seem to come midseason.

But the Leafs probably need a trade soon to avoid the waiving of a guy like Rychel. More importantly, though, they need to free up space for Kapanen and Dermott.
 
I doubt that the potential of losing Rychel weighs much on their decision-making. At his age, and with what he's shown in the AHL thus far, he's not much of a prospect. Particularly in an organization as deep on the wing as Toronto.

The only waiver-eligible bubble-boy that they probably don't want to lose is Leivo. But with Kapanen, Soshnikov and guys like Johnsson & Aaltonen all being waiver-exempt, they do have some wiggle room if they'd prefer to wait for the right deal to present itself for some of their surplus forwards.

As for Dermott, they do have the space right now to fit him in. With Hunwick & Polak gone, and only Hainsey coming in, the 6th, 7th & 8th spots on defense are there for Dermott, Marincin & the rest of our kids to fight over
 
Rusty after several months of barely thinking about hockey. Yeah, Leivo should have been the one rather than Rychel mentioned above.

In terms of the blueline, there's a lot of bodies to compete for the bottom pair and depth position. That said, true with Polak and Hunwick out that Dermott is unlikely to be blocked.
 
Rusty after several months of barely thinking about hockey. Yeah, Leivo should have been the one rather than Rychel mentioned above.

In terms of the blueline, there's a lot of bodies to compete for the bottom pair and depth position. That said, true with Polak and Hunwick out that Dermott is unlikely to be blocked.
The thing with Leivo is that I don't think the Leafs face much risk of losing him on waivers. We should have more than enough room on the roster for him if we waive veteran flotsam & jetsam like Ben Smith and Eric Fehr, and if they send down their waiver-exempt forwards that are on the bubble.

The biggest risk is that he might demand a trade. At his age, he can't really afford another wasted development year where he plays in fewer than 20 games all year and watches the rest as a healthy scratch in the press box. At a certain point, he'll have to look out for #1 if he's once again sitting out for lengthy periods of time with no clear path into the starting lineup.
 
Rare for D+1 defenders to make the NHL. Over the last pile of years it's basically Chychrun, Hanifin, Ekblad, Jones, Larsson, Fowler, Hedman, Kulikov, Doughty, Schenn.

A few of those were clearly rushed (Hanifin, Larsson, Kulikov, Schenn), and most of the list were all big kids (Average size on this last has to be about 6'3). Leave Timmy in the AHL and let him dominate there if he's able to. We have a ton of options who can hold down the fort on the right. Zaitsev-Hainsey-Carrick is more than serviceable
 
Because hockey is starting to infect my brain again ...

Marleau-Matthews-Marner (3M)
Kapanen-Nylander-Komarov
Grundstrom-Kadri-Brown
Martin-Moore-Leivo

Pretty deadly forward lines with decent two way balance.

Gardiner-Zaitsev
Reilly-Hainsey
Dermott-Carrick
 
If I was purely guessing what Mike Babcock's lineup will be on opening night, barring injuries, I'd go with:

Zach Hyman - Auston Matthews - William Nylander
James van Riemsdyk - Tyler Bozak - Mitch Marner
Patrick Marleau - Nazem Kadri - Connor Brown
Matt Martin - Dominic Moore - Leo Komarov

Until anyone gets traded away or leaves as a UFA, I'm of the opinion that Mike Babcock is probably going to keep the Matthews & Bozak lines of last year intact. Let's face it, he loves Zach Hyman, and he also believes in having a mucker on each line. So I'll believe Hyman getting banished to the 4th line when I see it.

And having Marner babysit JVR & Bozak still makes sense.
 
i just don't see how Leo - not only the best defensive forward on the team but the most leaned on in that role by babs - gets taken off the checking line.
 
Thats the beautiful thing about having legit depth. Some players are going to get less ice time than they probably deserve. And some that are good enough to make it probably won't (Kapanen, Dermott).
 
Thats the beautiful thing about having legit depth. Some players are going to get less ice time than they probably deserve. And some that are good enough to make it probably won't (Kapanen, Dermott).
Yeah, that's always the problem you're hoping to get to eventually if you're drafting & developing properly, and/or bringing in good players as FA.

Komarov's presence on the fourth line, along with swapping Ben Smith for Dominic Moore, might also turn our "fourth line" into a somewhat capable shut-down/checking line as well.

And no matter what line Leo, Brown or Hyman play on, they're still going to get a ton of ice-time on the penalty-kill.
 
I still don't see it. Komarov was the defensive matchup guy all year. That line was the only line he actually trusted defensively. They got some of the most extreme matchups in the entire league. No way he moves off the checking line, imo.

We know they were going to trade JVR for Hamonic, so we know where ideally they had Marleau slotted into the lineup. As of now, the only real fit in the lineup is in Hyman's or Brown's spot, imo.


But I like that you mentioned Dermott - wouldn't be surprised if he didn't spend a day in the AHL this year.
 
Well yeah that was the point. Guys like Dermott/Kapanen making the team and Komarov/Hyman playing top 9 roles would be a given most years.

This is a deep team.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I really think the only thing that holds us back from winning it all is potentially Andersen.

If he has a solid year of even .920 or so, I really see us as one of the favorites.
 
I read an article (by Yost? Can't remember who) that compared Komarov's Corsi, xGA /60 against teammates and concluded Komarov is hardly irreplaceable from a defensive angle, while offensively he's dragging the Brown-Kadri line down.

I think Leo will be moved this season - if not by trade deadline, then even earlier.

At the same time I don't see Marleau playing on the "third line", I can also see Moore helping out on PK and ES checking role, and there's plenty of young blood to challenge for Komarov's spot on the Kadri line - Kapanen, Hyman (bumped down from the 1st line) and Leivo are all possible candidates.

I'm perfectly fine with this on opening night:

Marleau - Matthews - Nylander
JVR - Bozak - Marner
Hyman - Kadri - Brown
Martin - Moore - Kapanen
(Sosh, Leivo)
 
Last edited:
Does xga take usage into account? That seemed to be a blindspot in the analytics community last year.
 
from mid-march:

Top5 TOI qoc

1.Komarov 29.90
2.Kadri 29.85
3.Brown 29.52
4.Hyman 29.48
5.Matthews 29.45

Top 5 xGF%

1.Kadri 56.22
2.Nylander 55.61
3.Matthews 53.42
4.Komarov 53.16
5.Hyman 53.14

Top 5 xGFrel

1.Kadri +4.94
2.Nylander +4.94
3.Matthews +1.14
4.Hyman +0.67
5.Komarov +0.54
 
i just don't see how Leo - not only the best defensive forward on the team but the most leaned on in that role by babs - gets taken off the checking line.

The consequence of stacking his best defensive players on one line is that the others ranged from iffy (Matthews) to frightening (Bozak). Much like spreading out the offensive talent, it is prudent to do it with the defensive skill as well.
 
Back
Top