• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Lineup Going Forward

which is why they signed marleau - to add defensive responsibility to one of the scoring lines.
 
Yeah, slotting marleau in on that top line and moving hyman down to a line more appropriate for his skill level is pretty much a no brainer.
 
Marleau fits on any line. He is a great fit with Matthews and lets Hyman slide down to a more appropriate spot in the lineup.

I think the checking line is a great fit too, because lets face it, Kadri is a legit ****ing awesome top line center and scored 60 points playing mostly with Komarov and Brown last year against tough competition. A Marleau-Kadri-Brown line isn't some defensive, non scoring line.

He would probably have the biggest postive impact on Bozak-Marner, but JVR isn't really the best fit anywhere else. He doesn't do the dirty work needed to play with Matthews, and he can't go anywhere near a shut down line.

They have so many good options.
 
from mid-march:

Top5 TOI qoc

1.Komarov 29.90
2.Kadri 29.85
3.Brown 29.52
4.Hyman 29.48
5.Matthews 29.45

Top 5 xGF%

1.Kadri 56.22
2.Nylander 55.61
3.Matthews 53.42
4.Komarov 53.16
5.Hyman 53.14

Top 5 xGFrel

1.Kadri +4.94
2.Nylander +4.94
3.Matthews +1.14
4.Hyman +0.67
5.Komarov +0.54

Komarov together with Brown and Kadri are the most leaned on line for tough matchups, that much we know, so QoC is not a surprise at all.

I wonder how Komarov's xGF stats are helped by the fine plays of Kadri and Brown.

I also wonder what's the xGA if we're to look at defense alone and not offense.(still, I know that's still more of a line-stat than individual stat, especially when Kadri and Komarov pretty much play all the ES minutes together, and Brown in the 2nd half of the season)
 
Marleau-Matthews-Marner
JVR-Nylander-Kapanen
Komarov-Kadri-Brown
Moore-Bozak-Hyman
Martin

I know it won't happen, but you have to figure the positive possession impact from simply swapping Bozak out for Nylander would be one of the more dramatic impacts that can be made in optimizing the lineup. That and replacing Hyman with someone that can score more than 6 ES goals.
 
Last edited:
Marleau fits on any line. He is a great fit with Matthews and lets Hyman slide down to a more appropriate spot in the lineup.

I think the checking line is a great fit too, because lets face it, Kadri is a legit ****ing awesome top line center and scored 60 points playing mostly with Komarov and Brown last year against tough competition. A Marleau-Kadri-Brown line isn't some defensive, non scoring line.

He would probably have the biggest postive impact on Bozak-Marner, but JVR isn't really the best fit anywhere else. He doesn't do the dirty work needed to play with Matthews, and he can't go anywhere near a shut down line.

They have so many good options.
This.

Any characterization of the Kadri line as a "third line" is just silly. As long as Willy's on the wing, Kadri is unquestionably our second-best center after Matthews, and he'd be a clear #1 or #2 on most teams in the league. And like you say, the other likely member of that line, Connor Brown, scored 20 goals as a rookie, and is a real solid all-around player.

If you put Marleau with those two, it'd be a hell of a line, and make for a disgustingly deep top-9. But Marleau's a swiss-army knife; he'll be fine on any of our top-3 lines.
 
If we can share the defensive load a bit more, I think Kadri line can be a lot more productive offensively. THink about this - playing against the toughest matchup, Kadri scored 30G/60 points and Brown 20G as a rookie. This is pretty absurd for a 'checking line'.

If Babs can feel more comfortable sharing some of the checking duty to his other lines (including a 4th line that feature Moore now, and a 1st line that has a Marleau on it) I think it's good for the entire team.
 
well if the hamonic trade had gone through i think we can be pretty sure marleau would have just slotted into jvr's spot with the other lines untouched.
 
but both marleau and hainsey should let babs stop with the overcoaching extreme matchups that he gave the kadri line and the rielly-zaitsev pair last year....hopefully.
 
well if the hamonic trade had gone through i think we can be pretty sure marleau would have just slotted into jvr's spot with the other lines untouched.
Yeah, it seems pretty clear that was the plan.

Marleau would've replaced much of JVR's offense, while also giving Mitchy another linemate that isn't a basket-case defensively.
 
I don't know if that's such a no-brainer. If the hamonic trade has gone through, we'd have a 1 more roster spot open, but does that mean marleau would take the empty spot and nothing else changes? The team's also got Kapanen and Sosh pushing for roster spot, not to mention Leivo (is Babs gonna keep him in pressbox for another season??!).

I still think it makes no sense to sign Marleau for that kind of money and contract and play him with our "3rd line center" (Bozak is essentially our 3C)
 
I think Kapanen would slide in when Bozak leaves and Willy moves to C.

and then the likes of Sosh/Leivo/Grundstrom/Korshkov get a chance to fill Komorov's spot.
 
Since he does it every year, I think Brown suprises again and hits 30 goals.

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
 
Since he does it every year, I think Brown suprises again and hits 30 goals.
If I was to guess a potential step forward for Brown, I'd probably go with 50 points rather than 30 goals.

I think the ability for that is there, my only question is if he'll get the opportunity with our forward depth. As it is, whatever offensive numbers he puts up will probably have to come almost entirely at even strength.
 
Assuming no trades, based on what you've seen in the preseason thus far, what line up would you like to see for the start of the season (not to predict what Babs will do)?

The Pump Up JVR's Trade Value Edition

JVR - Matthews - Nylander
Marleau - Kadri - Brown
Komarov - Bozak - Marner
Leivo - Fehr - Hyman
(Martin)

Gardiner - Zaitsev
Rielly - Hainsey
Dermott - Rosen
(Carrick)

Anderson
McElhinney

Once JVR is traded, bring in Kapanen.
 
JVR isn't getting traded.

He's going to walk as a UFA, unless they decide to resign him.

iu
 
Ok I tried one last time but i'll change my mind again in an hour.

Leivo - Matthews - Nylander
VanRyk - Bozak - Marner
Marleau - Kadri - Komarov
Martin - Hyman - Brown
(moore - fehr)

Gardiner - Zaitsev
Rielly - Hainsey
Dermott - Rosen
(Carrick)

Andersen
(McElhinney)



*****

Grundstrom - Aaltonen - Kapanen
Soshnikov - Smith - Johnsson
Clune - Mueller - Rychel
Lindberg - Gauthier - Bracco
(Timashov - Brooks)

Borgman - Liljegren
Valiev - Holl
Nielsen - Marincin/Polak
(Loverde)

Sparks
(Kaskisuo)
 
Back
Top