• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

It's people like Bettman who literally suck the fun out of sports.

You have a hockey nation that can be competitive, let them play.

Soccer went the right way on this one expanding the tournament to allow teams like Iceland to play. Hockey? Pan euro team, **** off Slovakia thinking you can play on the same ice as canada or Russia.
 
Yeah, I'm sure you'd be thrilled if Canada were racking up bronzes and quarter-finals appearances regularly.

What does being thrilled have anything to do with it? Sweden and Finland are always competitive in these tournaments and consistently take home medals. Switzerland is never competitive and practically never does. Its just the facts.

But please keep going on about how Switzerland is a comparable successful hockey nation to Sweden and Finland. Everyone totally believes your sincerity.
 
It's people like Bettman who literally suck the fun out of sports.

You have a hockey nation that can be competitive, let them play.

Soccer went the right way on this one expanding the tournament to allow teams like Iceland to play. Hockey? Pan euro team, **** off Slovakia thinking you can play on the same ice as canada or Russia.

The NHL is probably the most ineptly-run major sports organization around, so it's unsurprising to see them screwing up one of the only good things that they've been able to accomplish (a working agreement with the IIHF for NHL player participation in the Olympics).
 
What does being thrilled have anything to do with it? Sweden and Finland are always competitive in these tournaments and consistently take home medals. Switzerland is never competitive and practically never does. Its just the facts.

But please keep going on about how Switzerland is a comparable successful hockey nation to Sweden and Finland. Everyone totally believes your sincerity.

Please keep stating the obvious. I'm sure everyone on here is dying to learn from you that Sweden and Finland have historically been more successful than Switzerland in hockey. I honestly had no idea. Without your highly cogent insight and brilliant analysis I would have continued labouring in ignorance that the Swiss are as talented.
 
Iceland tied the 6th-ranked team in the world (and eventual tournament winners), drew the 19th-ranked team in the world, defeated the 10th-ranked team in the world, defeated the 13th-ranked team in the world (and former World Cup champions), and eventually got kicked out by the 7th-ranked team in the world.

Pretty impressive. Not a minnow in the list either.

England won a WC 50 years ago. Iceland had a good tournament but seriously the only name team they "beat" was England who was vastly overrated again. When you think soccer, you don't think Austria as a powerhouse. I also wouldn't necessarily go by rankings given it still has Belgium as the 2nd team and Argentina as number one.
 
The NHL is probably the most ineptly-run major sports organization around, so it's unsurprising to see them screwing up one of the only good things that they've been able to accomplish (a working agreement with the IIHF for NHL player participation in the Olympics).

agreed
 
Please keep stating the obvious. I'm sure everyone on here is dying to learn from you that Sweden and Finland have historically been more successful than Switzerland in hockey. I had no idea.

Sweden is a nation of 9 million. They'll never have the talent to hang with the big boys. Why invite them at all? Let's create a pan-Nordic team instead. I'm sure Finns would have no problem playing on the same "national" team as Swedes after all.

Don't put that on me. You slid down your own slippery slope.

Should there be a qualifier for the final two teams in the tournament? Sure, why not. Does that change the fact that the importance of these international tournaments is solely related to the best players playing and nothing else? No.
 
The NHL is probably the most ineptly-run major sports organization around, so it's unsurprising to see them screwing up one of the only good things that they've been able to accomplish (a working agreement with the IIHF for NHL player participation in the Olympics).

This is really sad because FIFA exists.

They literally can't beat FIFA.
 
It's a shame that 101 doesn't seem to realize that the incredible American talent that is currently being produced in the NHL today is a direct result of the Miracle on Ice occurring. How many kids would have actually taken up hockey without that seminal event growing up?

Under his pretense, the Americans never would have been in the tournament to begin with. They had no chance at winning after all. The Olympics provided that platform. They provided the legitimacy and the credibility.
 
It's a shame that 101 doesn't seem to realize that the incredible American talent that is currently being produced in the NHL today is a direct result of the Miracle on Ice occurring. How many kids would have actually taken up hockey without that seminal event growing up?

Under his pretense, the Americans never would have been in the tournament to begin with. They had no chance at winning after all. The Olympics provided that platform. They provided the legitimacy and the credibility.

They would have been there. American players on team world. It would have had the same effect, I promise.
 
And to really put the screws to nations like Slovakia, Switzerland, Germany, etc, when they have a talent good enough to be playing in the NHL, the NHL wants to ban that player from playing in the Olympics, where his country is actually represented.
 
I never said I disagree with growing the game though these tournaments. That is the exact reason why I said I think they'll end up going to Beijing. The Chinese market is too big of an opportunity to pass making an impression on.
 
England won a WC 50 years ago. Iceland had a good tournament but seriously the only name team they "beat" was England who was vastly overrated again. When you think soccer, you don't think Austria as a powerhouse. I also wouldn't necessarily go by rankings given it still has Belgium as the 2nd team and Argentina as number one.

A few things:

1.) Whether that World Cup occurred fifty years ago or not is kind of immaterial to the point I'm making. England are still one of the elite teams in the world. It was a colossal upset.

2.) Even if you want to go by Elo rankings (which I personally think are much more accurate), the teams they beat are still all in the upper-tier of the world's nations. And Austria was on an absolute tear heading into the tournament. They had a legitimate claim to that top ten ranking, even if a more casual observer of football might find it strange.
 
I never said I disagree with growing the game though these tournaments. That is the exact reason why I said I think they'll end up going to Beijing. The Chinese market is too big of an opportunity to pass making an impression on.

The problem I have is that you seem to think that those of us opposed to the present World Cup are opposed to it based on an aversion to seeing elite talent, or something. It has nothing to do with that. The problem comes in when it's billing itself as a replacement even for the Olympics, or when it commits itself to branding the tournament as an international event on par with the major tournaments sanctioned by the IIHF, but then doesn't even invite all of the respective national teams, or re-brands these teams in a way that they are a compilation of players from different countries.

You can't have your cake and eat it too. If it was something like the NHL's "Fall Classic Invitational Cup" or something (someone could obviously brand it much better than that), and it had the best players in the world on different teams, rather than calling them national squads, that would be awesome. But it hasn't done that. That's the problem.
 
A few things:

1.) Whether that World Cup occurred fifty years ago or not is kind of immaterial to the point I'm making. England are still one of the elite teams in the world. It was a colossal upset.

2.) Even if you want to go by Elo rankings (which I personally think are much more accurate), the teams they beat are still all in the upper-tier of the world's nations. And Austria was on an absolute tear heading into the tournament. They had a legitimate claim to that top ten ranking, even if a more casual observer of football might find it strange.

I don't care how weak their path was (and it wasnt), for a nation with a population smaller than brampton Ontario to be competitive with nations like Austria and England is madness. It's a amazing story. It's one that people like Bettman and leafman and zeke would rather not see, in its place some artificial team like team under 23 or Team pan europa.

Sick.
 
the best thing is for all the hissy fits, Jays and this Habs guy are going to watch every minute of every game.

I thought they were weird enough in the olympics thread, but this is even weirder.

you know what the worst thing about the FIFA World Cup is? All the shit teams that obviously don't belong.

And the NHL is doing great, for the record, despite idiots like these criticizing everything they do. NHL again set a revenue record by reaching $4b this year, which is 40% more than just 5yrs ago. This despite the loonie losing value. They also set a new attendance record this year. You guys are dumb. and weird.
 
the best thing is for all the hissy fits, Jays and this Habs guy are going to watch every minute of every game.

I thought they were weird enough in the olympics thread, but this is even weirder.

you know what the worst thing about the FIFA World Cup is? All the shit teams that obviously don't belong.

And the NHL is doing great, for the record, despite idiots like these criticizing everything they do. NHL again set a revenue record by reaching $4b this year, which is 40% more than just 5yrs ago. This despite the loonie losing value. They also set a new attendance record this year. You guys are dumb. and weird.

I'm not watching a minute of this shit, you can take that to the bank.

I would bet you posting here for a year that the world cup doesn't come close to the Olympics in terms of interest or viewership.

The nhl is doing fine, sure. No one is arguing that. What we are arguing is that this world Cup of hockey won't even come close to being as good as the olympics.

Again, I would bet posting here for a year on it. Would you?

Also https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pwDOQ3pQXI0
 
It's a shame that 101 doesn't seem to realize that the incredible American talent that is currently being produced in the NHL today is a direct result of the Miracle on Ice occurring. How many kids would have actually taken up hockey without that seminal event growing up?

Under his pretense, the Americans never would have been in the tournament to begin with. They had no chance at winning after all. The Olympics provided that platform. They provided the legitimacy and the credibility.

Actually, they would have been because they were the host,,,,
 
Back
Top