• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

As soon as the Olympics embraced the current best on best format beginning in Nagano eighteen years ago, the importance of Canada Cups/World Cups as the determining measure of a national team's true quality became obsolete.

Yeah, but only because the NHL players started playing in the Olympics. If NHLers stopped playing in Olympics and went back to the World Cup, it would revert right back. Its the players that make it important. The importance follows them.
 
I wonder if the tournament would be seen as legitimate if the KHL had just gone and made it up. Or the DEL.

Just making up tournaments for the shits and giggles, breaking up national teams, making up other teams, excluding established teams.

Then to top it off they would push it as a replacement for KHL participation at the Olympics.

Probably not.

They already have a watered down version of this, and it's surprisingly fun to watch every Christmas/New Year's Eve: Switzerland's annual Spengler Cup tournament. A "Team Canada" and "Team USA" normally participate, and they play against other club teams often featuring fellow countrymen.

So the NHL is basically hosting a Spengler Cup with (obviously) better players, although it its worth mentioning that the 2005 edition of the tournament was really good. I think Thornton and Nash playing for HC Davos beat "Team Canada" in the final. That's essentially what the World Cup is embracing as a format.
 
Yeah, but only because the NHL players started playing in the Olympics. If NHLers stopped playing in Olympics and went back to the World Cup, it would revert right back. Its the players that make it important. The importance follows them.

That's good because it sounds like team Russia is going to be completely unaffected by this.

Some other euro nations will probably follow suit.
 
They have those sorts of match-ups every single year. It's called the Stanley Cup Finals. You seem to be refusing to acknowledge (along with zeke) why the respective national team element is important to people.

The national team element is still there. The team North America is the only part that doesn't fit with that, but I doubt that's a permanent feature if the World Cup continues.

Its not like they are having a fantasy draft.
 
Yeah, but only because the NHL players started playing in the Olympics. If NHLers stopped playing in Olympics and went back to the World Cup, it would revert right back. Its the players that make it important. The importance follows them.

Yeah, but if they do it correctly like the 1996 and 2004 versions it would give the tournament a modicum of credibility that this edition is desperately lacking. You can't have national teams and hybrid teams and call it a real, representative international tournament.
 
They already have a watered down version of this, and it's surprisingly fun to watch every Christmas/New Year's Eve: Switzerland's annual Spengler Cup tournament. A "Team Canada" and "Team USA" normally participate, and they play against other club teams often featuring fellow countrymen.

So the NHL is basically hosting a Spengler Cup with (obviously) better players, although it its worth mentioning that the 2005 edition of the tournament was really good. I think Thornton and Nash playing for HC Davos beat "Team Canada" in the final. That's essentially what the World Cup is embracing as a format.
But if they went and called it the world cup and the team that won it as the best hockey team/nation would you buy that?
 
The national team element is still there. The team North America is the only part that doesn't fit with that, but I doubt that's a permanent feature if the World Cup continues.

Its not like they are having a fantasy draft.

Literally 25% of the tournament is comprised of make-believe teams (you omitted the pan-European squad). That's ridiculous. It would have made far more sense to have had Switzerland and Germany/Denmark or one of the other quality second-tier teams occupying the final two spots. Those countries have already proven to be a reliable pipeline of NHL talent the past two countries, developing annual first round draft selections, winning medals at the World Championships, and defeating the Big Six clubs on occasion.
 
The national team element is still there. The team North America is the only part that doesn't fit with that, but I doubt that's a permanent feature if the World Cup continues.

Its not like they are having a fantasy draft.

I'm sure Slovakians( who ice a competitive team more often than not) are going to be following team Europe with bated breath.
 
But if they went and called it the world cup and the team that won it as the best hockey team/nation would you buy that?

Of course not. They weren't playing in a true international format sanctioned by the official international governing body. If a bunch of UEFA member clubs got together with a handful of CAF members and CONMEBOL national federations and held their own non-FIFA "World Cup," absolutely no one would take it seriously.

They'd make money, I'm sure. But it would have no prestige, no bragging rights for the winning team, no credibility. I agree with you entirely on this matter.
 
None of those teams have a chance to win. This gets more NHL players involved, and raises the competition level and all the countries that legitimately have a shot to win are involved. I don't have a problem with trying new things to improve the product.

That said, like mentioned earlier, the NHL plans to have a qualifier for those last spots moving forward.
 

The winner of a tournament with all the best players in the world would be the best team in the world. Thats the only thing that makes the notion of the winner of the Spengler Cup as the best team in the world ridiculous. Sidney Crosby isn't involved.
 
Sorry Switzerland, you'e too shitty to play in our international tournament. We don't want you guys getting blown out and -- oh, wait...

[video=youtube;tLKKjpFBy3g]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLKKjpFBy3g[/video]
 
That was a fluke. You guys can't hang with the big boys and -- ah crap.

[video=youtube;pGTn-GfgxVw]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGTn-GfgxVw[/video]
 
None of those teams have a chance to win. This gets more NHL players involved, and raises the competition level and all the countries that legitimately have a shot to win are involved. I don't have a problem with trying new things to improve the product.

That said, like mentioned earlier, the NHL plans to have a qualifier for those last spots moving forward.

It's like you've never seen an upset in sports. Why bother having the tournament at all? Just give Canada the title and hold NHL training camp at the same time as usual. :lol
 
Leicester City will never win the Premier League. They should stay in the Championship. They're just wasting Chelsea, Manchester United, Manchester City, Tottenham, and Liverpool's time... oh wait.
 
None of those teams have a chance to win. This gets more NHL players involved, and raises the competition level and all the countries that legitimately have a shot to win are involved. I don't have a problem with trying new things to improve the product.

That said, like mentioned earlier, the NHL plans to have a qualifier for those last spots moving forward.

Representing your country>chance to win?

What Swiss grows up wanting to win a tournament with a Frenchman Latvian and German on their team?
 
Come on man. Switzerland has won one world championship medal in like 60 years. Lets not pretend like they belong with the big boys because they've won a couple games over the decades.

If this was a strictly 8 team international tournament they legitimately might not qualify.
 
The Netherlands is going to be absolutely annihilated in the World Baseball Classic. Wait, they beat the Dominican Republic twice and made the semi-finals? Crazy. It's almost like less talented teams have an opportunity to win and go far in short tournaments.
 
Back
Top