• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

how many young guns would be top-6 forwards, top-3 dmen, or #1 goalies on Canada or the US?

how many would even make those teams in any capacity?

McDavid, Gaudreau, Eichel, Matthews and maybe Jones. US gets ****ed a bit.
 
a couple things:

1. I prefer the world cup idea better than the olympics. The fifa world cup is the best tourney in the world and hockey should emulate it. This one may not be perfect but it's definitely the right direction.

2. The young guns team is made up of players who simply wouldn't be key parts of their teams (rightly or wrongly). It shouldn't impact the integrity of the other teams at all, and it should alllow lots of top talent to have significant roles in this tourney that they wouldn't otherwise. In fact, it might help break one of the more annoying habits of these tourneys - teams sticking with old boys clubs and gritty checkers instead of bringing their best players.

3. The tourney has to be in the offseason. Just has to. Makes no sense to do it midseason.

1.) Soccer isn't hockey. The FIFA World Cup works cause its a 32 team tournament where the 32nd team can be somewhat competitive. Its also a month long tourney which the Olympics can't replicate for soccer... Hockey are both 2 week tournaments. The Olympics works fine cause its a small number of teams that can compete, and important games. You don't need a month long tournament to separate 32 teams like you do in soccer (where you need more off days and more teams, hence the length).

2.) Connor McDavid, Jack Eichel should be on their teams. Some others would compete for spots. Saad scored over 30 last year for example; Gaudreau and Jones likely make the US too.
 
We sure do. Gretzky vs. Lemieux for the Canada Cup in their primes might have been the best, most talked about hockey game to witness ever. I wish that was a thing I could watch. I don't understand how anyone who enjoys hockey would talk negatively about the possibility of that.

Give me McDavid vs Crosby.

You want Crosby vs craved? That's fine. This tournament as a supplement to the Olympics is fine (even if it's a cash grab).

This tournament instead of NHL participation at the Olympics is what is getting to people. I'm sure it's a fine little tournament by itself, one I old never watch but won't begrudge those who do. But it's not olympic hockey and it will never come close.

Russians care about the olympics.

Europeans care about the olympics.

Canadians care about the olympics. 15 million watched the gold medal game in sochi at stupid in the morning. 17 million watched the gold medal game in Vancouver. The world cup will never come close to that.

Americans care about olympics. 27 million tuned in to the gold medal game in Vancouver.

European hockey nations are already laughing off this tournament, I doubt the Russian take this seriously and heck, it's running into a great amount of indifferent in North America.

You guys are living in a fantasy world if you think this will be accepted as a olympic replacement. It's a niche little tournament but it will never come close to the level of attention that the olympics get.

So we shall suck ass where everyone actually cares about international hockey and we shall watch as the Russians and swedes laugh at our self imposed handicapping and be great at a tournament that nobody outside a few die hard hockey fans care about. A world cup the world doesn't care about. Cute.

That's what people are not getting here.

On a side note I wonder what the penalties for the Europeans and Russians who care about their country than their nhl team are going to be? Is Washington going to suspend ovechkin for 10 games during the playoff hunt? Would he care? Probably not, just stay in Russian and see if he can replicate usain bolt post gold medal tail haul.
 
Last edited:
Thats a little dramatic. No one cared about Olympic hockey before the NHL players started playing in it. Its not like tens of millions were watching then. NHLers weren't bailing on their teams to go play. People only started caring when the NHL players started playing. They'll stop caring about Olympic hockey again if the NHL stops participating (which hasn't happened yet). The Olympicsn aren't the draw. The best players in the world competing is the draw. Without the NHLers is just a worse World Championships.
 
Last edited:
Thats a little dramatic. No one cared about Olympic hockey before the NHL players started playing in it. Its not like tens of millions were watching then. People only started caring when the NHL players started playing. They'll stop caring about Olympic hockey again if the NHL stops participating (which hasn't happened yet). The Olympicsn aren't the draw. The best players in the world competing is the draw.

The only teams that are going to suck as a result of this are team Canada and team USA. I'm sure enough Europeans stars and Russian stars play hooky to go get their medals with a silly 1 or 2 game suspension when they return to ice competitive teams.

In the meanwhile I'm sure no American gives a damn about this WC and I'm sure the Russians and euros won't give a damn either. Again, a world cup the world doesn't care about.
 
Thats a little dramatic. No one cared about Olympic hockey before the NHL players started playing in it. Its not like tens of millions were watching then. NHLers weren't bailing on their teams to go play. People only started caring when the NHL players started playing. They'll stop caring about Olympic hockey again if the NHL stops participating (which hasn't happened yet). The Olympicsn aren't the draw. The best players in the world competing is the draw. Without the NHLers is just a worse World Championships.

it's weird that people don't know this.
 
Why though? They never did that before the NHL started particpating. And besides if everyone loves the Olympics so much, why would only Europeans bail on the NHL and not Canadians and Americans. I mean the world cares about the Olympics so much.
 
Why though? They never did that before the NHL started particpating. And besides if everyone loves the Olympics so much, why would only Europeans bail on the NHL and not Canadians and Americans. I mean the world cares about the Olympics so much.
Good point. I hope the Crosby's and subban's just up and go.

Again, I'm curious to see what the penalties are. Does a team suspend their star player when they might need them the most?
 
I wouldn't count on it for a certainty that Ovechkin and other Russian NHL players would skip out on their NHL tems without permission to go play in the next Olympics.

They may have threatened to do it in 2014, but that's when the games were being hosted in their home country in lavish style by glorious leader Vladimir Putin.
 
I wouldn't count on it for a certainty that Ovechkin and other Russian NHL players would skip out on their NHL tems without permission to go play in the next Olympics.

They may have threatened to do it in 2014, but that's when the games were being hosted in their home country in lavish style by glorious leader Vladimir Putin.

http://m.thn.com/blog/ovechkin-says-hell-play-at-2018-olympics-whether-nhl-players-are-going-or-not/

Ovechkin says he'll play at 2018 Olympics whether NHL players are going or not

If*Alex Ovechkin’s*dedication to suiting up for the Russian national team wasn’t obvious from his*scrambling across the pond to play in the 2015 World Championship, his commitment to playing in the 2018 Olympics should be all the evidence you need.

In an interview Wednesday, Ovechkin said that no matter the NHL’s decision on whether NHL players will be allowed to play at the 2018 games in Pyeongchang, South Korea, he’ll be pulling on the Russian sweater at the tournament.

“The same situation was with the (2014) Sochi Games, they said NHL could not be allowed to come,” Ovechkin told*Russian outlet TASS. “I hope the sides will reach an agreement.

“Anyway, I and other players will definitely come [to the 2018 Olympics].”

Hmm?
 
People care about the Olympics because this is a best-vs-best country-vs-country tournament. For athletes, that means a lot.

Sure there is something about the Olympics medal to a lot of these players, but if WC hockey = FIFA World cup soccer, then can i replace the Olympics as the best-vs-best tourney playing for your country? Yes, I think so.

But in order for that to happen, the WC need to be organized in a WAY MORE serious manner. The way WCoH is right now, it's a freaking cash grab, and it's a joke. Esp with this 'young guns' team idea ... it just makes the whole tourney a freaking joke. It will never replace the Olympics if it continues down this path.
 
People care about the Olympics because this is a best-vs-best country-vs-country tournament. For athletes, that means a lot.

Sure there is something about the Olympics medal to a lot of these players, but if WC hockey = FIFA World cup soccer, then can i replace the Olympics as the best-vs-best tourney playing for your country? Yes, I think so.

But in order for that to happen, the WC need to be organized in a WAY MORE serious manner. The way WCoH is right now, it's a freaking cash grab, and it's a joke. Esp with this 'young guns' team idea ... it just makes the whole tourney a freaking joke. It will never replace the Olympics if it continues down this path.

I did read somewhere that for the next WC, they'll have a proper qualifying tournament, but for this one didn't have time to schedule the pre-tournament qualifier.
 
I forget, which teams were in the final for the 1987 Canada Cup? Was Team Young Gunzz one of the competitors?

It's funny that people talk about that Canadian team in such high esteem. Obviously it's a legendary roster, but they almost got defeated by a no-name Soviet goalie in that tournament during the period of probably the worst goaltending the communists produced between 1954 and the fall of the Iron Curtain in 1989. If the Soviets brought even a marginally better goalie they would have won the tournament in all likelihood.
 
The NHL isn't necessarily done with the Olympics. At least that hasn't been confirmed. It sounds like they want to got to Beijing, and I'm sure they would go to a North American games. It doesn't sound like they see much value in South Korea.

What, they'll go to one non-traditional hockey nation located in Asia but not another?

And I don't think its accurate to say players don't care about the World Cup. They are professional athletes. They all want to represent their countries and compete for championships. Do they care more about the Olympics? Maybe, who cares.

I'm sure that most players care about representing themselves individually fine and playing fairly well. All athletes do because they all harbour individual elements of pride. However, I doubt that there's the element of national pride that is commonly associated with events like the Olympics. No one brags about having won a World Cup. Olympic victories are eternal. Their respective order of importance isn't even comparable.

I think the importance of the venue for the international, best-on-best tournament is being greatly overstated. Was Crosby's golden goal in Vancouver a great, once in a lifetime memory? Absolutely. But so was Paul Henderson, and Gretzky/Lemieux in 87 Canada Cups. I wasn't alive/old enough to watch either, and I've still seen/heard about those plays countless times. Are they not meaningful because it wasn't the Olympics? Because they are treated as some of the most meaningful plays in the history of the game.

Paul Henderson's famous goal in 1972 was significant because it occurred during a period of time when IIHF rules prevented the best North American players for suiting up for Canada or the United States in international competition. It also extended beyond politics to the Cold War and was as much of a political victory for Western democracy over authoritarian communist regimes and the Soviet way of life as it was a victory on the ice. There was so much more at stake there beyond hockey. As soon as the Olympics embraced the current best on best format beginning in Nagano eighteen years ago, the importance of Canada Cups/World Cups as the determining measure of a national team's true quality became obsolete.
 
The real question is would it have mattered? If Canada won a Gretzky/Lemieux show down no one would remember? Is that the argument. No one would have cared to see that?

"I am a real hockey purest. I have no interest in seeing the two greatest players in the history of the game going head to head in their prime. Its just a cash grab."

It's more so that there's no use in pretending that these are actual representative national teams if your entire premise is based purely around elite talent playing elite talent.

If the NHL wants to stage a fun little exhibition tournament featuring the best players in the world playing against each other on teams not determined by nationality, go ahead. But don't have this bizarre hybridized "kind of national teams, but not entirely" format and call it the "World Cup." It's not.

It's even worse when the league is considering this replacing the only true international competition in which the best national teams compete against one another. I'd rather watch the annual World Championships over this. At least it draws crazy insane attendance and stellar television ratings over in Europe, where it enjoys a huge amount of credibility and viewership.

And hell yeah a Gretzky/Lemieux showdown would have been a thrill. But not with one playing for "Canada" and the other playing for "Team Gunz" or whatever the hell the concept is supposed to be here.
 
We sure do. Gretzky vs. Lemieux for the Canada Cup in their primes might have been the best, most talked about hockey game to witness ever. I wish that was a thing I could watch. I don't understand how anyone who enjoys hockey would talk negatively about the possibility of that.

Give me McDavid vs Crosby.

They have those sorts of match-ups every single year. It's called the Stanley Cup Finals. You seem to be refusing to acknowledge (along with zeke) why the respective national team element is important to people.
 
I wonder if the tournament would be seen as legitimate if the KHL had just gone and made it up. Or the DEL.

Just making up tournaments for the shits and giggles, breaking up national teams, making up other teams, excluding established teams.

Then to top it off they would push it as a replacement for KHL participation at the Olympics.

Probably not.
 
Back
Top