leafman101
Well-known member
how many young guns would be top-6 forwards, top-3 dmen, or #1 goalies on Canada or the US?
how many would even make those teams in any capacity?
McDavid, Gaudreau, Eichel, Matthews and maybe Jones. US gets ****ed a bit.
how many young guns would be top-6 forwards, top-3 dmen, or #1 goalies on Canada or the US?
how many would even make those teams in any capacity?
a couple things:
1. I prefer the world cup idea better than the olympics. The fifa world cup is the best tourney in the world and hockey should emulate it. This one may not be perfect but it's definitely the right direction.
2. The young guns team is made up of players who simply wouldn't be key parts of their teams (rightly or wrongly). It shouldn't impact the integrity of the other teams at all, and it should alllow lots of top talent to have significant roles in this tourney that they wouldn't otherwise. In fact, it might help break one of the more annoying habits of these tourneys - teams sticking with old boys clubs and gritty checkers instead of bringing their best players.
3. The tourney has to be in the offseason. Just has to. Makes no sense to do it midseason.
McDavid, Gaudreau, Eichel, Matthews and maybe Jones. US gets ****ed a bit.
We sure do. Gretzky vs. Lemieux for the Canada Cup in their primes might have been the best, most talked about hockey game to witness ever. I wish that was a thing I could watch. I don't understand how anyone who enjoys hockey would talk negatively about the possibility of that.
Give me McDavid vs Crosby.
Thats a little dramatic. No one cared about Olympic hockey before the NHL players started playing in it. Its not like tens of millions were watching then. People only started caring when the NHL players started playing. They'll stop caring about Olympic hockey again if the NHL stops participating (which hasn't happened yet). The Olympicsn aren't the draw. The best players in the world competing is the draw.
Thats a little dramatic. No one cared about Olympic hockey before the NHL players started playing in it. Its not like tens of millions were watching then. NHLers weren't bailing on their teams to go play. People only started caring when the NHL players started playing. They'll stop caring about Olympic hockey again if the NHL stops participating (which hasn't happened yet). The Olympicsn aren't the draw. The best players in the world competing is the draw. Without the NHLers is just a worse World Championships.
Good point. I hope the Crosby's and subban's just up and go.Why though? They never did that before the NHL started particpating. And besides if everyone loves the Olympics so much, why would only Europeans bail on the NHL and not Canadians and Americans. I mean the world cares about the Olympics so much.
I wouldn't count on it for a certainty that Ovechkin and other Russian NHL players would skip out on their NHL tems without permission to go play in the next Olympics.
They may have threatened to do it in 2014, but that's when the games were being hosted in their home country in lavish style by glorious leader Vladimir Putin.
Ovechkin says he'll play at 2018 Olympics whether NHL players are going or not
If*Alex Ovechkin’s*dedication to suiting up for the Russian national team wasn’t obvious from his*scrambling across the pond to play in the 2015 World Championship, his commitment to playing in the 2018 Olympics should be all the evidence you need.
In an interview Wednesday, Ovechkin said that no matter the NHL’s decision on whether NHL players will be allowed to play at the 2018 games in Pyeongchang, South Korea, he’ll be pulling on the Russian sweater at the tournament.
“The same situation was with the (2014) Sochi Games, they said NHL could not be allowed to come,” Ovechkin told*Russian outlet TASS. “I hope the sides will reach an agreement.
“Anyway, I and other players will definitely come [to the 2018 Olympics].”
It's more than just a tad ironic to see fans of NHL hockey bitch about a cash grab.
People care about the Olympics because this is a best-vs-best country-vs-country tournament. For athletes, that means a lot.
Sure there is something about the Olympics medal to a lot of these players, but if WC hockey = FIFA World cup soccer, then can i replace the Olympics as the best-vs-best tourney playing for your country? Yes, I think so.
But in order for that to happen, the WC need to be organized in a WAY MORE serious manner. The way WCoH is right now, it's a freaking cash grab, and it's a joke. Esp with this 'young guns' team idea ... it just makes the whole tourney a freaking joke. It will never replace the Olympics if it continues down this path.
I forget, which teams were in the final for the 1987 Canada Cup? Was Team Young Gunzz one of the competitors?
The NHL isn't necessarily done with the Olympics. At least that hasn't been confirmed. It sounds like they want to got to Beijing, and I'm sure they would go to a North American games. It doesn't sound like they see much value in South Korea.
And I don't think its accurate to say players don't care about the World Cup. They are professional athletes. They all want to represent their countries and compete for championships. Do they care more about the Olympics? Maybe, who cares.
I think the importance of the venue for the international, best-on-best tournament is being greatly overstated. Was Crosby's golden goal in Vancouver a great, once in a lifetime memory? Absolutely. But so was Paul Henderson, and Gretzky/Lemieux in 87 Canada Cups. I wasn't alive/old enough to watch either, and I've still seen/heard about those plays countless times. Are they not meaningful because it wasn't the Olympics? Because they are treated as some of the most meaningful plays in the history of the game.
The real question is would it have mattered? If Canada won a Gretzky/Lemieux show down no one would remember? Is that the argument. No one would have cared to see that?
"I am a real hockey purest. I have no interest in seeing the two greatest players in the history of the game going head to head in their prime. Its just a cash grab."
We sure do. Gretzky vs. Lemieux for the Canada Cup in their primes might have been the best, most talked about hockey game to witness ever. I wish that was a thing I could watch. I don't understand how anyone who enjoys hockey would talk negatively about the possibility of that.
Give me McDavid vs Crosby.