• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

The problem with this tournament is it is just randomly put together. Sometimes 8 years apart, sometimes 12. We want more money, let's have a world cup!
I really feel 96' was the last one that felt something. Two years later the pros started to go to the Olympics. They also were not spread apart nearly as much in years.
 
https://youtu.be/HIV5-H-HGZ0

yeah those finns didn't care at all

You did not post Canada's sad celebration in 2004. Why? Because it pales in comparison to Olympic wins.

Go to 1:24

[video=youtube;ZX-o0lscjwk]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZX-o0lscjwk[/video]

Can't find it, but Damian Cox actually wrote an article the next morning about how it felt anticlimactic and how Brodeur's "jump" was put-on and not genuine.
 
Last edited:
man that team was awesome.

a little tougher to celebrate a dominant win than an OT nailbiter, but they looked plenty happy to me.
 
2014 was as dominant as you'll see, and they looked plenty happy.
Yes, talking about Crosby's goal on home ice in 2010' would be unfair. But I still get the feeling the players care more in the Olympics. Would Martin St.Louis ask for a trade being left off a world cup roster?
 
Meh.
I'll watch some games but the subdividing of talent is abhorrent. At this point I want Canada to win because of nationality, but I want the North Americans win so Matthews and co. get some legs under them. It's just a mess and they could have mandated teams have a certain amount of young talent or whatever, though that's also pretty contrived.

I can't imagine there will be much contact here either, which could turn this into a glorified All-Star Game.
 
Last edited:
The NHL isn't necessarily done with the Olympics. At least that hasn't been confirmed. It sounds like they want to got to Beijing, and I'm sure they would go to a North American games. It doesn't sound like they see much value in South Korea.

And I don't think its accurate to say players don't care about the World Cup. They are professional athletes. They all want to represent their countries and compete for championships. Do they care more about the Olympics? Maybe, who cares.

I think the importance of the venue for the international, best-on-best tournament is being greatly overstated. Was Crosby's golden goal in Vancouver a great, once in a lifetime memory? Absolutely. But so was Paul Henderson, and Gretzky/Lemieux in 87 Canada Cups. I wasn't alive/old enough to watch either, and I've still seen/heard about those plays countless times. Are they not meaningful because it wasn't the Olympics? Because they are treated as some of the most meaningful plays in the history of the game.
 
Last edited:
I forget, which teams were in the final for the 1987 Canada Cup? Was Team Young Gunzz one of the competitors?
 
The real question is would it have mattered? If Canada won a Gretzky/Lemieux show down no one would remember? Is that the argument. No one would have cared to see that?

"I am a real hockey purest. I have no interest in seeing the two greatest players in the history of the game going head to head in their prime. Its just a cash grab."
 
Last edited:
If you honestly think that the 1987 Canada Cup would have had the same lasting impact among hockey fans if 22 year-old Mario Lemieux had been split off from Team Canada onto a "Young Gunzz" team, and it was that team that Canada faced in the finals instead of the Soviet Union...I really don't know what to tell you. We just fundamentally disagree.
 
We sure do. Gretzky vs. Lemieux for the Canada Cup in their primes might have been the best, most talked about hockey game to witness ever. I wish that was a thing I could watch. I don't understand how anyone who enjoys hockey would talk negatively about the possibility of that.

Give me McDavid vs Crosby.
 
Last edited:
I dunno...I guess the disconnect here between us is that for me, as much as Gretzky vs. Lemieux in 87 might have been interesting to watch, and on paper it would've been a good matchup---the best part about these tournaments and sports in general for me is the emotional investment. When I genuinely care about which team wins or loses.

So that's why, even when they're mediocre or a garbage team, I find Leaf games more interesting than other games involving the best teams in the NHL. Aesthetically, those other teams may be much better hockey to watch, but if I genuinely don't care what the outcome is, it's hard to get anywhere near as excited as I do watching Leaf games, or games involving Canada's truly best team and another real country's best possible team.

It doesn't mean those "better" games aren't still worth watching, but they're not nearly as fun.
 
Last edited:
But if you find Leafs games more interesting than other games even when they stink and no matter who they are playing because you are emotionally invested in the Leafs, why would you be any less emotionally invested in Team Canada because they are missing a couple of players or their opponent?

These great moments were created because of the one game anything can happen tournaments with the best players in the world. Those tournaments create moment after moment for hockey fans. Canada Cups, World Juniors, Olympics, World Cups. They've all created memorable lasting moments.

Sure if Team North America has that moment, it might not resonate with anyone. But does that mean if Crosby scores an OT winner against the US or Finland it won't be remembered and replayed over and over again? Somehow I doubt it.
 
Last edited:
But if you find Leafs games more interesting than other games even when they stink and no matter who they are playing because you are emotionally invested in the Leafs, why would you be any less emotionally invested in Team Canada because they are missing a couple of players or their opponent?
If the NHL determined that the best way to decide the Stanley Cup was to split up the two finalists into four teams and have a tournament, would you find that as exciting?

Wouldn't you like to see Auston Matthews & Nazem Kadri compete with Mitch Marner & William Nylander for the Stanley Cup?
 
I dunno...I guess the disconnect here between us is that for me, as much as Gretzky vs. Lemieux in 87 might have been interesting to watch, and on paper it would've been a good matchup---the best part about these tournaments and sports in general for me is the emotional investment. When I genuinely care about which team wins or loses.

So that's why, even when they're mediocre or a garbage team, I find Leaf games more interesting than other games involving the best teams in the NHL. Aesthetically, those other teams may be much better hockey to watch, but if I genuinely don't care what the outcome is, it's hard to get anywhere near as excited as I do watching Leaf games, or games involving Canada's truly best team and another real country's best possible team.

It doesn't mean those "better" games aren't still worth watching, but they're not nearly as fun.

Not saying this is you LGM(not sure what you stance was) but this is definitely not true for good portion of this forum. I think we established this last season when so many said they rarely watch the games because nobody wants to see a garbage team play.

I definitely agree that it isn't as important as Leafs games but i'm all ready for hockey and getting to see the best compete i'm definitely a little excited about it.
 
a couple things:

1. I prefer the world cup idea better than the olympics. The fifa world cup is the best tourney in the world and hockey should emulate it. This one may not be perfect but it's definitely the right direction.

2. The young guns team is made up of players who simply wouldn't be key parts of their teams (rightly or wrongly). It shouldn't impact the integrity of the other teams at all, and it should alllow lots of top talent to have significant roles in this tourney that they wouldn't otherwise. In fact, it might help break one of the more annoying habits of these tourneys - teams sticking with old boys clubs and gritty checkers instead of bringing their best players.

3. The tourney has to be in the offseason. Just has to. Makes no sense to do it midseason.
 
If the NHL determined that the best way to decide the Stanley Cup was to split up the two finalists into four teams and have a tournament, would you find that as exciting?

Wouldn't you like to see Auston Matthews & Nazem Kadri compete with Mitch Marner & William Nylander for the Stanley Cup?

Well I don't really think that is comparable, but somehow I think we would all be pretty damn excited watching any version of the Leafs compete for a cup.
 
Not saying this is you LGM(not sure what you stance was) but this is definitely not true for good portion of this forum. I think we established this last season when so many said they rarely watch the games because nobody wants to see a garbage team play.

I definitely agree that it isn't as important as Leafs games but i'm all ready for hockey and getting to see the best compete i'm definitely a little excited about it.
To be clear, I was speaking in a more general sense, because I didn't find the Leafs enthralling last year either, at least until they called up Willie and all the other kids after the deadline. So, when the Leafs are actually trying to win, and they're not in the very early stages of a rebuild with a roster full of short-term place-holders, I'm more interested in Leaf games than teams involving any other teams in the NHL, even if those other teams offer the viewer technically better hockey.


Well I don't really think that is comparable, but somehow I think we would all be pretty damn excited watching any version of the Leafs compete for a cup.
What's the difference between my scenario and what the NHL is doing for this World Cup?
 
how many young guns would be top-6 forwards, top-3 dmen, or #1 goalies on Canada or the US?

how many would even make those teams in any capacity?
 
What's the difference between my scenario and what the NHL is doing for this World Cup?

They just aren't doing that. They aren't splitting up the two finalist teams into four and holding a four team tournament in the championship game.

They aren't changing teams at all. They just have two teams that aren't countries.
 
Back
Top