I have lunch a few times a week with my Montreal buddy on the floor (not Frenemy, much more normal, but sometimes the anti-Leaf shows). Anyway, he says Tavares hasn't lived up to the last deal (that none of the core has), but each time we talk about him, he's adamant that the Leafs would be crazy not to bring him back at around the rumored numbers, and said today he'd for sure give him a 4 year deal on the basis that he still wouldn't be ancient and a $5M 3C on the back end of the deal is no problem given where the cap is going.
Ironically here, I'm the one who's hesitant, but yeah, you have to sign that $5m x 4 and be thrilled. That's locking down 30+ goals, a C who excels at faceoffs, and yeah, $5m is peanuts. I wish Tavares wouldn't hold us up for a fourth year, but if that's what it takes to get the discount, just do it because you can't have an offseason where you lose both Marner and Tavares when you could've at least kept Tavares for way undermarket.