• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Only two teams are interested in mac according to my guy. GUESS Leafoffaith and teeds are right about this guy. Just an anomaly.
 
I hope Burke either goes big today (Stastny, Richards, etc) or stand pat today. Let's not trade for 3rd liners or 3rd unit dman anymore.

I do hope we bring in 1 of Liles or Wideman.

Agree on the first statement, and hoping for Liles. But Wideman sucks.
 
Only two teams are interested in mac according to my guy. GUESS Leafoffaith and teeds are right about this guy. Just an anomaly.

I think interest in him will spike in an hour or two.

Someone will get stupid. And Burke is waiting, ready to pounce...
 
So much talk from you always, and all that talk of yours end up being dead wrong.

hmm, seems like I've been much better at predicting the returns on trades of guys like Beauch and Boyes so far. . but you sure seem to be beating your chest lately despite being wrong time and time again.

If you want to compare Mac with Tucker (which as players, is not a bad comparison), why would you ever compare the 25 year old Mac to the 32 year old Tucker? If you want to compare them, you should be comparing the 25 year old mac to the 25 year old Tucker. That's the only comparison that could possibly give us any information worth talking about.
 
Only two teams are interested in mac according to my guy. GUESS Leafoffaith and teeds are right about this guy. Just an anomaly.

And probably not a complete anomoly, imo - maybe slightly over his head, but this is more or less his ceiling, I think.

He'll be a 50 point guy most years from here on out.
 
And probably not a complete anomoly, imo - maybe slightly over his head, but this is more or less his ceiling, I think.

He'll be a 50 point guy most years from here on out.

I would keep him for.... now but thats only because were within 4pts of 8th spot, there is no need to f_ck up this roster. Just get a depth D, and get rid of old man giggy, and call it a day.
 
hmm, seems like I've been much better at predicting the returns on trades of guys like Beauch and Boyes so far. . but you sure seem to be beating your chest lately despite being wrong time and time again.

If you want to compare Mac with Tucker (which as players, is not a bad comparison), why would you ever compare the 25 year old Mac to the 32 year old Tucker? If you want to compare them, you should be comparing the 25 year old mac to the 25 year old Tucker. That's the only comparison that could possibly give us any information worth talking about.

Too bad you have a short and weird memory - I also predicted a good return for Beauch. I just said he's a second pairing guy AT BEST, and kinda sucks. And what's Anaheim doing with him? Playing him 15 minutes a game, as a 4th or 5th guy. Guess you were right about him being a stud first pairing guy! Yeah, too bad I haven't been wrong about, oh, ANYTHING.

Also too bad that you selectively quote AND have pretty shitty reading comp skills. Maybe go back to my post re Mac and Tucker and actually read it, instead of quoting the first line and ignoring the fact that I acknowledge the players are different, but the TRADE OPPORTUNITY is similar. And then acting like a dick and commenting about how I made a bad comparison about the players. Keep typing indeed, jerkoff.
 
Mac has proven to be a very nice complimentary player, which is what I'm sure Burke is stating in contract negotiations right now.

He would need to be traded to another ideal situation for him to perform at the same level.

Right now, Burke is testing Mac's loyalty. His options are obvious, throuw out some roots and get established with great line-mates in Toronto -OR- be traded to the highest bidder, enter new contract negotiations in July or go to arbitration. The alternative could mean another 2-3 moves before he gets to settle into a real NHL contract.
 
Why does he need to prove his loyalty? I mean he's got it good here, he's happy as a pig in dirt. He's getting top mins, he's got 2 great linemates, a coach who has faith in him (wilson having faith in anyone not named beauchimen, lebda, mitchell is a rare thing), plus his cousin is on the team. I think he does really want to be here.
 
This is Burke trying to knock down the price on Mac. They set a price and Mac set his. He knows mac wants to stay... so he floats the "I may have to move him " so that Mac says "fine I'll take this deal". He is a shrewd business man.

Doing the same with Liles I think
 
I think you have been blinded by the fact that Mac is wearing Tuckers number.

Different players, different situation.
 
If you listen to Mac talk, you can tell this is not a dumb guy. Mac is smart, and he KNOWS it is in his best interest to stay in Toronto, and play with Kulemin and Grabo next season. He's bounced around enough in his young career, and he definitely doesn't want to leave the 1 town where he's finally found success. The extra $500k or so, or the extra 1 or 2 years in contract length just isn't worth the risk.

So anything you hear Burke or Meehan say between now and whenever Mac re-signs, is just posturing. Both sides are trying to work the price, but at the end of the day, both sides want to keep Mac here. Probably Mac wants it a little more than Burke but you do have 2 willing parties in here, who are not THAT far apart in contract talk neither.

If his agent isn't meehan he'd be signed by now.
 
Too bad you have a short and weird memory - I also predicted a good return for Beauch. I just said he's a second pairing guy AT BEST, and kinda sucks. And what's Anaheim doing with him? Playing him 15 minutes a game, as a 4th or 5th guy. Guess you were right about him being a stud first pairing guy! Yeah, too bad I haven't been wrong about, oh, ANYTHING.

Also too bad that you selectively quote AND have pretty shitty reading comp skills. Maybe go back to my post re Mac and Tucker and actually read it, instead of quoting the first line and ignoring the fact that I acknowledge the players are different, but the TRADE OPPORTUNITY is similar. And then acting like a dick and commenting about how I made a bad comparison about the players. Keep typing indeed, jerkoff.


Ease up, bud - you're the one making the personal attacks. You've been plainly wrong on the returns for Beauch and Boyes - the two guys we've disagreed on the most, so I'd slow down with telling other people they're wrong all the time.

The trade opportunity isn't similar - a 32 year old UFA with a track record of performance and health/age concerns going forward vs. a 25 year old RFA having his first breakout year is not a comparable situation. Thinking that it is can only lead to a flawed analysis.
 
Why does he need to prove his loyalty? I mean he's got it good here, he's happy as a pig in dirt. He's getting top mins, he's got 2 great linemates, a coach who has faith in him (wilson having faith in anyone not named beauchimen, lebda, mitchell is a rare thing), plus his cousin is on the team. I think he does really want to be here.

Then sign on the dotted line.

Justin Williams (a very similar player style-wise) just signed for $3.6ish, MacA can't expect anything over $3 IMO.

Arby sucks MacA, go for term.
 
Ease up, bud - you're the one making the personal attacks. You've been plainly wrong on the returns for Beauch and Boyes - the two guys we've disagreed on the most, so I'd slow down with telling other people they're wrong all the time.

The trade opportunity isn't similar - a 32 year old UFA with a track record of performance and health/age concerns going forward vs. a 25 year old RFA having his first breakout year is not a comparable situation. Thinking that it is can only lead to a flawed analysis.

Dude, you're outright lying and you know it. That's why you piss me off sometimes because it's like you have to make shit up to appear correct. Must I dig up from the archives?

You know full well I said that Beauch should return something good because I thought some dumb team would still be high on his Cup win and would pay a decent amount for him. In fact, I PREDICTED Anaheim repeatedly since last year since they knew him best. I called it.

Regarding Boyes, I don't even know what you're talking about? Did we debate about his return? I only remember saying that I liked him (which I still do) and that I would like the Leafs to get him. I don't recall saying anything at all about his return. Maybe I did, but I don't remember it being any sort of issue with me.

As for MacA and Tucker, in my original post, which you did not bother reading, I acknowledged the differences between them. But I said I have a feeling that like the Tucker situation back then, where we could've traded him for a good premium, chose not to, and saw him stall and regress right after, I am sensing something similar with MacA right now. This is our chance to get something really good back for him, and we'll likely never have that shot again, due to his great season, his low $1M salary, and the logjam in the West. It is a unique trade opportunity. Plain and simple. There is no "mistake" in that analysis, much as you want to pretend there is.
 
Back
Top