• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

But no one "truly wants to be a Leaf" in the sense that they would forgo other opportunites in the hopes of maybe signing with the Leafs. Rick Nash didn't even do that. You can't sit around and wait for someone to chase you. Another team will beat you to the punch. Take action.
 
No thats not what I said. What I am saying its high risk to trade a boat load of assets for a player with no guarantee of wanting to play here for the long term. My point is to wait it out until hes a UFA, and if he truly wants to be a leaf then sign the guy to a long term contract.

And your point sucks because this type of player is rarely available via UFA and if he does get there, you have other teams willing to structure the contract in a way that Burke isn't.

Make the deal and get the player extended at the first opportunity. Burke's already negotiated a long term deal with Getzlaf for an extremely fair price.
 
But no one "truly wants to be a Leaf" in the sense that they would forgo other opportunites in the hopes of maybe signing with the Leafs. Rick Nash didn't even do that. You can't sit around and wait for someone to chase you. Another team will beat you to the punch. Take action.

I'm sorry but if I'm the GM of the leafs I'm not giving up tons of valuable players for a guy who may or may not want to be here in the 1st place. What I would do is the minute said player hits UFA status is make a serious sales pitch and hope he accepts the offer, if not then move on to plan B.
 
I'm sorry but if I'm the GM of the leafs I'm not giving up tons of valuable players for a guy who may or may not want to be here in the 1st place. What I would do is the minute said player hits UFA status is make a serious sales pitch and hope he accepts the offer, if not then move on to plan B.

So you're saying all we have to do is wait for good players to become free agents and then sign them? Jesus, why hasn't anyone thought of this before?
 
And you would be passing on an opportunity to add an elite player, at your teams biggest position of need, who is only 26 and brings a combination of skill and physical play that not many, if any, others bring. Big mistake IMO.
 
So you're saying all we have to do is wait for good players to become free agents and then sign them? Jesus, why hasn't anyone thought of this before?

Again... what I'm saying is I would NOT give up serious assets for 1.5 years of a player who odds are wont want to resign here when his contract is up, I would rather wait until hes a ufa, if he wants to sign here then great ink him to a long term deal, if not then we keep our assets without being burned in the short and long term.
 
I'm sorry but if I'm the GM of the leafs I'm not giving up tons of valuable players for a guy who may or may not want to be here in the 1st place. What I would do is the minute said player hits UFA status is make a serious sales pitch and hope he accepts the offer, if not then move on to plan B.

This is why you're not GM of the Leafs...
 
And you would be passing on an opportunity to add an elite player, at your teams biggest position of need, who is only 26 and brings a combination of skill and physical play that not many, if any, others bring. Big mistake IMO.

Back it up there a second, our teams biggest need is not a top flight centre, its a solid goalie. Thats all I'm going to say on that one......
 
Again... what I'm saying is I would NOT give up serious assets for 1.5 years of a player who odds are wont want to resign here when his contract is up, I would rather wait until hes a ufa, if he wants to sign here then great ink him to a long term deal, if not then we keep our assets without being burned in the short and long term.

You know, if you base your arguments on things you make up and assert as fact, that doesn't make them stronger.
 
Back it up there a second, our teams biggest need is not a top flight centre, its a solid goalie. Thats all I'm going to say on that one......

Maybe. But one of those things isn't hard to get, and we may already have, and the other is practically impossible to get and we don't already have.
 
If we are able to move Colborne, Schenn and picks for Getzlaf that would be another rape. No way that's happening! Ducks GM will ask for at least 2 solid 2nd liners (Grabo and Kully) and 2 solid young players (Kadri and Schenn). Do we give up that much to get this guy? I personally wouldn't do it because i want 3 solid lines instead of 1 great line and a bit more.
 
If we are able to move Colborne, Schenn and picks for Getzlaf that would be another rape. No way that's happening! Ducks GM will ask for at least 2 solid 2nd liners (Grabo and Kully) and 2 solid young players (Kadri and Schenn). Do we give up that much to get this guy? I personally wouldn't do it because i want 3 solid lines instead of 1 great line and a bit more.

Getzlaf 5.325 million

Schenn 3.6 million
Grabs 2.9 million
Kulemin 2.35 million
Kadri 1.72 million

Total: 10.57 million

I'm going to assume Anaheim has an internal budget and will not be looking to add 5.2 million in cap space.

That said, I don't really care if we have to give up either to get Getzlaf.
 
Last edited:
Getzlaf 5.325 million

Schenn 3.6 million
Grabs 2.9 million
Kulemin 2.35 million
Kadri 1.72 million

Total: 10.57 million

I'm going to assume Anaheim has an internal budget and will not be looking to add 5.2 million in cap space.

haha, smarty pants ;)...Fine take away Schenn and add Colborne instead. The point is they want roster players who can play. Besides, we already raped them once no way he's stupid enough to give us Getzlaf without damaging us quite a bit.
 
I disagree that the trade would be a "rape." IMO Kadri/Schenn, Colborne and 2 firsts is a hell of a lot to give up. That is two legit top prospects with some success at every level and another 2 first round picks (and we all know what happened last time the Leafs made a deal like that).

I think Getzlaf is more valuable, and the Leafs would do well for themselves making that deal. But based on the assumption that you are trading Getzlaf, that is a pretty good return.

Richards and Carter were both traded for a top prospect and a solid young player and Philly did pretty damn well in both deals. This is two top prospects and two firsts, essentially what Richards and Carter went for combined.
 
I disagree that the trade would be a "rape." IMO Kadri/Schenn, Colborne and 2 firsts is a hell of a lot to give up. That is two legit top prospects with some success at every level and another 2 first round picks (and we all know what happened last time the Leafs made a deal like that).

I think Getzlaf is more valuable, and the Leafs would do well for themselves making that deal. But based on the assumption that you are trading Getzlaf, that is a pretty good return.

Richards and Carter were both traded for a top prospect and a solid young player and Philly did pretty damn well in both deals. This is two top prospects and two firsts, essentially what Richards and Carter went for combined.

Yeah, I agree. Schenn + Colborne + two firsts is a lot. It's tough to make that trade but I think it's worth it for Getzlaf. I think the Leafs would get ripped by people for that deal too.
 
Back
Top