I disagree that the trade would be a "rape." IMO Kadri/Schenn, Colborne and 2 firsts is a hell of a lot to give up. That is two legit top prospects with some success at every level and another 2 first round picks (and we all know what happened last time the Leafs made a deal like that).
I think Getzlaf is more valuable, and the Leafs would do well for themselves making that deal. But based on the assumption that you are trading Getzlaf, that is a pretty good return.
Richards and Carter were both traded for a top prospect and a solid young player and Philly did pretty damn well in both deals. This is two top prospects and two firsts, essentially what Richards and Carter went for combined.