JaysCyYoung
Legend
You don't think the Flyers got good deals for those two malcontents? Brayden Schenn, Wayne Simmonds and a 2nd round pick for Mike Richards? B. Schenn had more value last offseason than Luke or Gardiner does now didn't he? And this was for a guy with 12 years left on his deal. That's why I'm saying it would take one of those guys, plus added value (from Toronto in a Nash deal) since Brayden was considered one of the top prospects in hockey at the time.
Carter went for Jakub Voracek and the 8th overall pick (Couturier), plus a 3rd rounder.
I'd rather have Nash than either of those guys (although Richards is debatable), but yeah, the deal is going to have a somewhat similar value, I would think.
The Flyers did get a good deal for those two players.
But it did not require the complete pillaging and destruction of their respective minor-league systems in order for Los Angeles and Columbus respectively to acquire Carter or Richards.
A comparable deal from the Leafs for Carter would be Nikolai Kulemin and the 7th overall pick (Kadri), plus a 3rd rounder. The Leafs certainly could have matched that offer without killing our system.