• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

You don't think the Flyers got good deals for those two malcontents? Brayden Schenn, Wayne Simmonds and a 2nd round pick for Mike Richards? B. Schenn had more value last offseason than Luke or Gardiner does now didn't he? And this was for a guy with 12 years left on his deal. That's why I'm saying it would take one of those guys, plus added value (from Toronto in a Nash deal) since Brayden was considered one of the top prospects in hockey at the time.

Carter went for Jakub Voracek and the 8th overall pick (Couturier), plus a 3rd rounder.

I'd rather have Nash than either of those guys (although Richards is debatable), but yeah, the deal is going to have a somewhat similar value, I would think.

The Flyers did get a good deal for those two players.

But it did not require the complete pillaging and destruction of their respective minor-league systems in order for Los Angeles and Columbus respectively to acquire Carter or Richards.

A comparable deal from the Leafs for Carter would be Nikolai Kulemin and the 7th overall pick (Kadri), plus a 3rd rounder. The Leafs certainly could have matched that offer without killing our system.
 
The Flyers did get a good deal for those two players.

But it did not require the complete pillaging and destruction of their respective minor-league systems in order for Los Angeles and Columbus respectively to acquire Carter or Richards.

A comparable deal from the Leafs for Carter would be Nikolai Kulemin and the 7th overall pick (Kadri), plus a 3rd rounder. The Leafs certainly could have matched that offer without killing our system.

Your outburst was based on discussion of the following trade proposal:

Gardiner, Colborne and a 1st wouldn't be unreasonable.

You're saying that this would represent the complete pillaging and destruction of our minor-league system?
 
Does anyone think the Blues would trade Chris Stewart? He's having a terrible season but would be a perfect fit for the Leafs.
 
I wouldn't trade Gardiner. I'd hate to give up Kadri or Schenn, but I'd do it for the right player.

I wouldn't trade a defensman with Gardiner's skill set and potential. Even if he never reaches his full potential, I'm taking my chances.
 
Does anyone think the Blues would trade Chris Stewart? He's having a terrible season but would be a perfect fit for the Leafs.

Good question. Any player is likely available for the right deal, but you would have to think that the Blues and Davidson would be less-inclined to sell low when Stewart is likely to recoup his value next season.
 
Does anyone think the Blues would trade Chris Stewart? He's having a terrible season but would be a perfect fit for the Leafs.

Its a possibility, I'm not sure what it would take to get him though, what are the blues weaknesses that need upgrading?
 
First of all, Howson sucks. Second of all, the number of teams Nash can go to is small.

I think it's going to come down to which other GM can make the cap work. 7.8 is a lot of cheese. Columbus will have to take some salary back, which naturally they will want to be players who can help them rather than bad contracts, which of course means you aren't also getting a whole wack of the other team's best young assets for Nash. It's a balancing act.

the only thing is, I can't help but imagine The Weasel hovering in the background, Stern-like, on this one. He just gave them the allstar game and I doubt he's too thrilled with the idea of the already bottomfeeding Jackets unloading their best player and face of the franchise.
 
Originally Posted by axlsalinger
The BJ's don't have to trade Nash. They are going to want to get at least one young player who looks like a potential stud ... that's why Bernier and Gardiner make sense. If they feel that way about either Schenn or Kadri, we might have a chance, but the deal Corky suggested is along the lines of what it will take.

Outburst by jayscyyoung
The Flyers didn't have to trade Carter or Richards either.

Every single year there are big names up for grabs and people always consistently over-estimate what it will take to acquire them. Every. Single. Year.

Stop falling for the blatantly obvious hype, people.

You responded to me talking about that proposed deal. Basically you were agreeing with LOF that we could trade them a couple of B prospects, after I had said they must get back at least one A prospect.
 
You responded to me talking about that proposed deal. Basically you were agreeing with LOF that we could trade them a couple of B prospects, after I had said they must get back at least one A prospect.

No, I wasn't. That was your interpretation.

I was speaking in generalities: each season there is a star player available, like Hossa, or Thornton, or Kovalchuk, and every single time the return is a pittance compared to what people think they will garner.

That's what my comment was referring to specifically. It wasn't necessarily addressed at yours, although I can understand how you came to think that. But I think that a Kadri or Colborne does represent an A prospect if you're going that route, don't you think so? A B prospect refers to a Blacker or Scrivens type.
 
First of all, Howson sucks. Second of all, the number of teams Nash can go to is small.

I think it's going to come down to which other GM can make the cap work. 7.8 is a lot of cheese. Columbus will have to take some salary back, which naturally they will want to be players who can help them rather than bad contracts, which of course means you aren't also getting a whole wack of the other team's best young assets for Nash. It's a balancing act.

the only thing is, I can't help but imagine The Weasel hovering in the background, Stern-like, on this one. He just gave them the allstar game and I doubt he's too thrilled with the idea of the already bottomfeeding Jackets unloading their best player and face of the franchise.

Agreed on all counts.

And Bettman, like Stern, is just corrupt enough to try and get involved in individual team transactions if he doesn't think that the bottom line is good for the league or, specifically, one of his pet expansion failures.
 
Mike In Buffalo posted this recently....

That the Bill Watters tweet from a few weeks back was....
Luke Schenn, Nazem Kadri, Mikhail Grabovski and Mike Komisarek for Nash and Kristian Huselius) “appears now to be a Blue Jackets request and not a Toronto offer.”

Looking at things now, you can maybe see that the Jackets want players who can play NOW as opposed to prospects. This also goes with the idea of a 4-5 player deal....
 
Good question. Any player is likely available for the right deal, but you would have to think that the Blues and Davidson would be less-inclined to sell low when Stewart is likely to recoup his value next season.

True, but Stewart is a RFA at the end of the year, along with Oshie and Perron. They're going to have $28 million in cap space but still, it's a name to watch out for, and I have no doubt Burke is looking at him.
 
No, I wasn't. That was your interpretation.

I was speaking in generalities: each season there is a star player available, like Hossa, or Thornton, or Kovalchuk, and every single time the return is a pittance compared to what people think they will garner.

That's what my comment was referring to specifically. It wasn't necessarily addressed at yours, although I can understand how you came to think that. But I think that a Kadri or Colborne does represent an A prospect if you're going that route, don't you think so? A B prospect refers to a Blacker or Scrivens type.

I don't know what to call Kadri at this point. I guess it depends on whether they think he's an A or B prospect, as it could go either way, but I think the risk of him being a bust is too great to be the centerpiece, which is why I think they will insist on at least one of Gardiner or Luke Schenn. Colborne is definitely a B prospect, Blacker and Scrivens are C prospects.
 
Mike In Buffalo posted this recently....

That the Bill Watters tweet from a few weeks back was....

Looking at things now, you can maybe see that the Jackets want players who can play NOW as opposed to prospects. This also goes with the idea of a 4-5 player deal....

As much as I like all of Schenn, Kadri and Grabo...I do that deal.
 
It's an interesting one. Taking on Huselius for Komisarek is appealing, Schenn and Kadri are fair requests. Why would they want pending UFA Grabovski though?
 
I think Burke needs to at least consider this deal, because it makes sense for both the short and long term. Luke Schenn has been a solid NHL player and he'll get better as the years go on, so losing him will hurt but to get something of value you need to give up something equally valuable. Grabo again is a solid 2nd liner but hes a pending UFA July 1st there is a chance he may walk, so it is best to trade him for something then let him go for nothing. Komiserak is just a cancer on this team, and he needs to go like yesterday. Kadri again has potential to be a good player but he'll likley never amount to anything elite either. Nash is a coveted 1st liner with size, something were lacking, and he would be an upgrade on Lupul IMO.

I'm not saying Burke should do this deal, just that he needs to give it some serious thought before either doing it or hanging up the phone.
 
Back
Top