• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

hell, just look at nash this season.

i am no fan of carter's, but imo it is indisputable that he is the most talented teammate nash has had to date. now, i know i'ts been a bumpy road and he has been injured, but nash's totals have actually declined substantially.

and it isn't like he'd be taking a big step up moving to toronto. short of breaking up one of the most successful tandems in the league, he'd be looking at playing with grabovski/connolly, macarthur/kulemin and the like.

not really any better than the guys he has played with in columbus.

Watching cammalleri make the move to centre.I wonder what Nash would feel about playing centre for a while.

cammalleri broke into the league as a C and was used at C with some regularity until signing with montreal.
 
eXUq8.png
 
Assuming the leafs make the playoffs in the 8th seed and we play the Rangers, I think we'll win the series in 6. The rangers have shown time and time again they can't match our speed, and also they don't have much firepower in their lineup, the leafs have what it takes to win that series. If we play Boston in the 1st round were ****ed, we'll be lucky if we don't get swept by the Bruins, because we just dont have the size/goaltending/defence to compete with the cup champs.

The way this team is playing the last two and a half weeks, we would be gone in 4. Doesn't matter about fire power, they would dominate the goaltending department which is all that matters in the playoffs.
 
Nash has made his linemates numbers better.....doesn't change the fact those linemates are the likes of Vermette, Umberger, Vyborny, etc.

He's no Kovalchuk, but if you don't think he'd have put up considerably better numbers with linemates like Savard, Hossa, Heatley and Kozlov over the years, you're only kidding yourself.

That's not really my argument. I simply don't believe he is worth what Columbus is asking for him. I really believe a team paying high for him will have buyer's remorse. I also don't think he's made his linemates better when they are still producing at levels they were with previous teams.
 
I don't understand why Nash all of a sudden became such a shitty, overrated player. Two years ago, when he was named to team Canada, the team with by far the deepest pool of talent, nobody seemed to have a problem with him.

The guy has been playing for the worst team in hockey his entire career and it's affected his numbers.

You guys don't want to pay him 7 million, but I'd much rather do that than pay Connolly his 4.

What's with all the hyperbole? Nobody thinks Nash is a "shitty" player. He most certainly isn't. What he is though is overpriced both in salary and in cost to acquire.
 
1) Kovalchuk has had significantly better line mates throughout his career.

2) Kovalchuk is simply a better player than Nash.....doesn't mean Nash shouldn't be acquired, or hasn't been punished by having significantly inferior line mates.

3) Carter is about as poor a line mate as you could find for a Rick Nash type of player.......a soft, shoot first center, who is having the worst/injury plagued, season of his career.
 
Hell yes to Nash, hell no to Carter.

You do realize the asking price is disgustingly high for Nash right? The Jackets wanted JVR , Borbrosvky, and one of Schenn or Courtierer, thats a high price. The equivalent to that on the leafs would be Kulemin, Gus, and one of Kadri or Colborne, that is a VERY steep price for a guy who constantly been stuck in the 50-65 pt range and who is having by far his worst season in the NHL.

No thanks to either of those bums.
 
Try for Nabokov and let Reimer licks his wounds this season and work on coming back to form next season.
 
You do realize the asking price is disgustingly high for Nash right? The Jackets wanted JVR , Borbrosvky, and one of Schenn or Courtierer, thats a high price. The equivalent to that on the leafs would be Kulemin, Gus, and one of Kadri or Colborne, that is a VERY steep price for a guy who constantly been stuck in the 50-65 pt range and who is having by far his worst season in the NHL.

No thanks to either of those bums.
Kulemin, Gus and Kadri for Nash? I'd do that in a heartbeat. Doubt Columbus would be stupid enough to, though.
 
You do realize the asking price is disgustingly high for Nash right? The Jackets wanted JVR , Borbrosvky, and one of Schenn or Courtierer, thats a high price. The equivalent to that on the leafs would be Kulemin, Gus, and one of Kadri or Colborne, that is a VERY steep price for a guy who constantly been stuck in the 50-65 pt range and who is having by far his worst season in the NHL.

No thanks to either of those bums.

I am well aware that they want a lot for Nash. Unfortunately, we will not get him for Kulemin, Gustavsson and Kadri. It will cost more than that. Also, your comparison of Leaf players to Flyers shows that you do not have a firm grasp on the values of these players.
 
Wait....Nash has been consistently stuck in the 50-65 point range?

He's basically a .85-1.0 ppg player....who has done this on an absolute island as a one man band.
 
You do realize the asking price is disgustingly high for Nash right? The Jackets wanted JVR , Borbrosvky, and one of Schenn or Courtierer, thats a high price. The equivalent to that on the leafs would be Kulemin, Gus, and one of Kadri or Colborne, that is a VERY steep price for a guy who constantly been stuck in the 50-65 pt range and who is having by far his worst season in the NHL.

No thanks to either of those bums.

Forget Kuly,Gus and Kadri for Nash.... I'd do Kuly,Gus and Kadri for JVR,Borbrosky and Coutierer
 
You do realize the asking price is disgustingly high for Nash right? The Jackets wanted JVR , Borbrosvky, and one of Schenn or Courtierer, thats a high price. The equivalent to that on the leafs would be Kulemin, Gus, and one of Kadri or Colborne, that is a VERY steep price for a guy who constantly been stuck in the 50-65 pt range and who is having by far his worst season in the NHL.

No thanks to either of those bums.

Nash's rookie campaign was worse.
 
1) Kovalchuk has had significantly better line mates throughout his career.

not in his last year in atlanta, he didn't. and over that span he was on pace to match his career in goals and points.

2) Kovalchuk is simply a better player than Nash.....doesn't mean Nash shouldn't be acquired, or hasn't been punished by having significantly inferior line mates.

no, but your argument is that nash will produce more once he gets to play with better linemates.

tell me... if nash is just a ~35 goal, ~70 point winger then would you give up a package including some combination of 4 out of kulemin, kadri, schenn, the leafs 1st, grabovski, colborne, gardiner to acquire him? would you be ok with him bieng the team's highest paid player?

3) Carter is about as poor a line mate as you could find for a Rick Nash type of player.......a soft, shoot first center, who is having the worst/injury plagued, season of his career.

well, hold on. who is nash going to play with in toronto? phil kessel, a soft, shoot first winger?
 
not in his last year in atlanta, he didn't. and over that span he was on pace to match his career in goals and points.

That really doesn't change my point, in the slightest.....for the vast majority of his career Kovalchuk played with linemates Nash could only dream of...


no, but your argument is that nash will produce more once he gets to play with better linemates.

agreed.


tell me... if nash is just a ~35 goal, ~70 point winger then would you give up a package including some combination of 4 out of kulemin, kadri, schenn, the leafs 1st, grabovski, colborne, gardiner to acquire him?

Yes.....Kulemin, Schenn, 1st, Grabo.



would you be ok with him bieng the team's highest paid player?

Yes, because I don't mind overpaying for productive talent.....if we can blow $11 million between Komisarek, Lombardi and Armstrong, we can overpay a guy like Nash.

In fact overpaying a guy like Nash, would force Burke to be more fiscally responsible......purge those other three from the team, and limit him making those kinds of mistakes in the future again.



well, hold on. who is nash going to play with in toronto? phil kessel, a soft, shoot first winger?


No one's saying Nash is the final piece......you'd have to work to surround him with quality linemates here as well. And no, I wouldn't have him playing with Kessel.
 
I'm entirely fine with paying Nash the 7.8...but I'm not entirely fine with having to win a ridiculous bidding war to get him. I'm cool with us giving fair value for a ~70+ point winger in his prime being paid 7.8 million dollars....I'm not cool with giving up "fair value" for "Rick Nash: Franchise Player" as the media touts him to be

In a cap world NHL, his "value" (obviously a tricky term because his value is whatever some twit GM will pay for him) is pretty well established, or should be.

B Prospect or better + useful player with reasonable contract + necessary salary filler + pick

So, something along the lines of Colborne + 1st or Kadri + 2nd + Schenn + Armstrong/Lombardi/Komisarek
 
With all this talk about Burke not having met expectations, I though it would be fitting to take a look at the roster he started with just 3 years ago:

Antropov-Stajan-Ponikarovsky
Hagman-Grabo-Stemniak
Blake-Mitchell-Kulemin
May-Devereaux-Mayers

Kaberle-White
Kubina-Schenn
Finger-Frogren

Toskala
CuJo

Record after 59 games: 21-26-12

There isn't a single slot in the lineup that isn't improved and the team is now younger had has a fully stocked cupboard.
 
Back
Top